TONY T’S

I’ve been enjoying the owners pizza and various Italian grub for many years and this place does not disappoint in terms of quality and variety. Highly recommended if you are looking for a quality small town eating experience. Especially great for those of you who like their pizza with a unique twist.

Excellent food, more than generous portions. Super friendly server. Extensive menu choices. We will definitely be back.

If you go through life without having a Tony T’s «Godfather» pizza with balsamic vinegar, your life will be incomplete and a total waste of time. The sandwich version, I think they call it the «Italian round», is also worth twice the price they charge. Just order the sandwich and pizza, and try one of everything in the display case while you wait. I miss this place more than any other since having moved out of NYS, including Cortese and PS Restaurant.

Updated — see below.
I’ve only been there once, so this review is based on that.
The staff there is very friendly.
There are so many (almost too many) choices on the menu. You can literally have almost any kind of pizza you can imagine.
They have homemade mozzarella sticks, which are an acquired taste.
Their red sauce is «lazy».
Food comes out hot and fresh.
Parking is almost non existent, but lots of seating available inside.
If I go there again and get «wowed», I will probably add a star or two.
— — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — — -
FOLLOW UP:
I went back there a week ago. Totally different experience.
Staff even friendlier than the last time.
Ordered mozzarella sticks, and large cheese pizza.
Sticks tasted SO much better this time.
Pizza sauce was better also?
Just wish the cook would have paid more attention to the pie, as I don’t care for «cheese bubbles» on my pizza.
Adding 2 stars now.

The People are always friendly and the food is 9 times out of 10 a winner. Some favorites are the Pomadori Pizza with fresh tomato, basil and garlic, the chicken taco pizza which has a salsa type sauce with fresh tomatoes and lettuce on top as well as seasoned chicken, the philly cheese steak pizza is also a great choice as well as the bacon cheeseburger. The wings are never quite as crispy as I like but the interesting sauces like leaping lizard (a raspberry and hot sauce combo) keep me coming back for more. Over all a great place to order take out from. The actual dining area is a bit on the small side, gives it a hole in the wall type of charm.

Best pizza in town! Unique kinds of pizza, available by the slice. Fast, friendly service.