Whidbey Pies Cafe

If you get a chance to get out of Seattle and make a day trip to Whidbey Island, you will find a regional beauty with true local charm. One of the spots that truly speaks to that is Greenbank Farm. They not only have this café, but vast fields and woods for hiking trails, a wine tasting shop, a cheese place and other gift shops.
This review is based on the café itself. We were recommended this place by a friend in the area. Having grown up in New England, I couldn’t believe that there were actually berries that I had never eaten before. Would love to come again during a time where they offer berry picking options. They offer a wide selection of fruit pies, as well as some other savory pies and food options. The server recommended the marionberry for a sweet tooth and the loganberry for something more tart. We were really surprised that there were barely any seats available in this kind of, middle-​of-​nowhere type of place. I guess this is THE place to be for a Sunday brunch, and believe me when I say it was packed. We ordered the loganberry, as we had never tried it before and got it a la mode with ice cream. What a delicious treat. The tartness of the berry paired well with the sweet ice cream to create the perfect bite. I’m sure if I had a whole pie, I would eat it all in one sitting. (By the way, they do sell whole pies). Definitely come check this out place out if you are around the island!

Loved it. Cute, quaint and above all delicious! That triple berry pie warmed with ice cream is a winner!
I love that they have a dog park outside.

Mmmm the loganberry pie was very very delicious. (Fun fact: the Greenbank farm used to be the largest producer of the loganberry in the world.) My friend and I weren’t that hungry so we decided to share one. A slice of pie is $ 5.50 and the added vanilla ice cream was an additional $ 1. The size of the pie was perfect for the both of us and they gave two small scoops of ice cream on the side. Although it doesn’t seem like it, the place is a sit-​down with to-​go options. Highly recommend stopping by if you are in the area. They also serve food items such as sandwiches, soups, and salads.

Marionberry pie. Yes. Salted Caramel Apple Pie. YES. delicious salads and grilled cheese on point. the pies are not too sweet and delicious crust. love this place. will come back every time when on whidbey.

Their thanksgiving pie is absolutely delicious.

This is part of an Oh-​Too Cute! tourist stop. They have 3 art shops, a wine shop, and this café — maybe more, we ran out of time. Play the letterbox treasure hunt if you have time. Whatever you do, do not go near the art shops.
We had quiche, savory pie, several kinds of fruit pie, several kinds of coffee. Oh, and the Reuben sandwich, which was Awesome. Everything seems freshly home made and the pie crust is superior — as good as mine. My favorite was the Loganberry pie, because I like tart. Try the Breve coffee, which is made with half and half for the steamed milk. Late lunch for 4, with some wine & coffees: $ 83 plus tip.

Loved it that they had some pumpkin spice lattes already! WOOHOO!!! My pal bought their caramel sauce and it was fantastic!

This is a very charming place to stop for a lunch or just to get some pie. I had the quiche of the day and my husband had a savory pie with sausage. Both were served with a mixed organic green salad. Very delicious! We had a piece of loganberry pie with ice cream for dessert. It was amazing.
I highly recommend this café. The staff was very friendly and it’s in a great location.

So Yummy! The salted caramel apple pie ala mode and the triple berry pie were delicious. Friendly staff and a very nice environment around the café.

An excellent idea with a great deal of potential but a few execution problems.
They make super bread, that obviously started life crusty and flavorful, but then they must do horrible things to it in the back, because we had a lot of soggy leather crusts. It’s served with a nice herb butter, but it serves even better as the shell to a BLT where fresh lettuce and tomato, a little bit of cheese, and a nice turn through the panini press turn it back into something worthy.
They also have some nice looking pies, though our loganberry was a little too sweet and jammy, with a crust that was both too scant and not cooked as long as I would have liked. But maybe it’s our fault for not just getting a cherry pie.
And while this really isn’t the café’s fault, I recommend not going during the Highland Games, when your relaxing lunch in the front yard will be accompanied by the endless enthusiasm of bagpipes.

Everytime we are in town we have to buy an entire pie from them. So delicious; it’s unable to be matched. Their loganberry pies which you can get heated up topped with ice cream is the meal of all happy places.
Their turkey and cranberry panini is amazing — crunchy and packed with flavor that makes it feel like thanksgiving.
The café is small but feels familiar and like home. The outdoor seating is perfect in the summer with a view of the Greenbank Farms which is fantastic for photo ops.

Quaint little place excellent lunch and pie!
Have eaten here a lot and never disaapointed

Are these the best pie’s ever? No. It’s also in the tourist trap known as Greenbank Farm. Still, I can’t give them just three stars. Give in to your Whidbey cliches and get a slice of loganberry pie. It’s real good. They have pretty good coffee as well. The staff is very friendly, even locating someone who could unlock the closed wine shop next-​door so we could by some sea-​salt on our last day in town.

Noms! Pie, sandwiches, and coffee right next to an off-​leash dog park. What could be better?! Weeellll… sorta pricey for what you get, but its delicious.

Great pies here. Nice crust, and wonderful filling — I had the rhubarb pie, and the filling was nice and tart, like it’s supposed to be, with just the right balance of sweetness. It’s offered with whipped cream or ice cream, but doesn’t really need either. We also had a bowl of the seafood chowder which was very nice.

Fantastic food & pies, located at the lovely Greenback Farm. Next door they offer local wine tasting and further down are several artisan shops. A must visit if you’re on Whidbey Island.

They deserve 5 stars just for customer service! I drove up from Portland just to buy Loganberry wine.
Thank you so so much for making my trip worth while. Your kindness won’t be forgotten. I’ll be back for pie!

PERFECT PIES! !!! Outstanding marionberry, loganberry, and huckleberry. Favorite was marionberry. Crust is tender with a rich buttery flavor, and the berries are perfectly sweetened to bring out the best decadent flavor. The pie was served at a perfect temperature. It’s a good thing I can’t go to this café daily or I would quickly outgrow my wardrobe. Outstanding Americana coffee that was pure perfection.
Place was under staffed so service was slow. But the pies were worth it! !!! Go there for pie!

I came here with my boyfriend and two other friends after he had raved about how amazing the pies were. We came here this last Saturday when they had a festival on the grounds, so it was a very very busy time at Whidbey Pies. All in all, we had a good time and had yummy food.
**ENTREES**
CLASSIC REUBEN — so so
I ordered the Classic Reuben, which was a typical sandwich, nothing too special, and came with a couple pieces of pickled veggies. It was good, but not good enough for the priceL $ 9.25. I don’t particular recommend this.
PORK & YAM POT PIE — thumbs up
My boyfriend ordered this and boy do I wish I had ordered this too! Although this too was overpriced for the size of the pie it still tasted really good and it came with a huge side salad.
**PIES**
We ordered four different slices of pie: MARIONBERRY, LOGANBERRY, HUCKLEBERRY, and STRAWBERRY RHUBARB. They were all delicious. The slices were small to average size. It’s an extra $ 1 for a la mode.
The MARIONBERRY and LOGANBERRY in particular blew my mind. They were very very good. The perfect amount of sweetness with really awesome crusts.
The Huckleberry and Strawberry Rhubarb were on the tart side but also very well made and very good.
**SERVICE**
They were super swamped, but they tried their best and they were helpful and nice.
I’d come back, but just for the pies. Minus one star for pricing and sandwiches.

A great lunch place, amazing pies, and wine-​tasting next door – what more could you ask for?
During our last lunch visit, we loved our quinoa salad, turkey with cranberry sauce panini and seafood chowder. But best of all are the fresh-​baked pies! Buy a couple and through them in your freezer.