Old Chicago

I was hopeful going in, but Chicago old or new wouldn’t like this place imitating Chicago pizza. When I think of Chicago and pizza, I think of rich tasting sauces and cheese. This pizza honestly tasted a little like a DeGiorno’s frozen pizza. I come from a town that does pizza really well so I’m not surprised to have been disappointed. The jalapeño bread bites were really tasty. Service is kind of slow, however the serving staff is very friendly.

Loved this place! Excellent selection of beers and the pizza selections allowed us to create a perfect dinner! Also, try the jalapeño pretzels — so good!

I always go here with a specific group of friends. I’ve always had decent service here, but it helps when it’s rarely busy when we’re there. We tend to go late on Friday and Saturday nights, which is nice to find a restaurant that serves food past 10pm. The food is fairly decent. I always end up eating something different, like pizzas, lasagna, wings, and they have some decent burgers. They have a pretty big beer selection and I heard you can sign up for a membership club and you try to drink all the different beers there. I haven’t really looked into that.

The waitress was rude. She ignored us when I told her it was my daughter’s birthday, when I mentioned it again she said, «okay I will bring her a cookie.» WHO DOESN’T say happy birthday to a kid? The food was okay. The Chicago style pizza was NOT Chicago style is was simply a thick crust reminiscent of Pizza Hut. We passed on the birthday cookie and left knowing we would not be coming back– there are plenty of pizza places in Green Bay– choose another, any other one. Thumbs down Old Chicago.

I’m kinda a pizza snob and this place looked awesome. I wanted to try all weekend and when I finally did we were very disappointed. Food was very average if that. Pizza Hut quality pizza. On the plus side the crew was super friendly but I definitely would not spend my money here again.

Server was nice food was good and we where happy !! We had the pizza Thai buffalo wings and chopped salad !! Perfect !!

Seemed like the only place in town to get a late night snack. We sat at the bar since they dinning area was closed. We didn’t mind but I hate hearing the bartenders banter with the single ladies trying to get their chicken finger on at 10pm on a Friday night. Whatever. The food was good though and a good selection of reverse happy hour specials. Pretty Fresh salad and our snack platter was yummy and we didn’t get any moans and groans about ordering food so late. I hate that too –at bar and grill places. The bartender was giving out little samples of beer to the people sitting next to us. Seemed like they had a wide variety of local brews to the other garbage yeast water on tap– not my cup of liquid.

Being a WBT member, currently working on my 13^th tour, of COURSE I had to stop in while I was in town for a business trip. Sad to say though, it was just nothing impressive. I guess the one near home is just always going to be my ‘Cheers’ — the service was alright, great beer selection as compared to others I have been to, layout was a little strange — just very divided and seemed sorta cramped.

We had a great experience with their carry out recently. The Italian Nachos were pretty awesome and the Pepperoni Rolls were good as well. The food was hot and ready when promised. I’d definitely eat there again.

Good place to take your family for a quick bite more like a sports bar situation in my opinion. It may not be what I expected but it was ok. The food on the other hand wasn’t that bad. It wasn’t the worst place definitely not the best I’ve eaten at. You get those average places and this is one of those places.

So we went back and I ordered the mac and cheese and I also asked for the person that I was supposed to ask for and let her know I was there. She was really nice and very happy that I was giving them another try, she swore it was going to be better this time.
So it came out and it looked good, but I think all they did was just add a little more cream or milk, at first I thought it was good but I quickly realized that it was just like the same thing I had the first time. It is really rich and really greasy.
She told me that they are a chain and that they have to stay with the company recipe and that if she could, she would change the way it’s made.
Maybe you all will really like it, so go ahead and give it a chance, but I recommend a side salad with it to break up the richness.

Had a pizza. Hawaiian. It arrived as a mass of grease-​soaked dough. The beer selection was garbage.
If you want pizza, there are better pizza joints in Green Bay. If you want bar with televisions, there are better bars in Green Bay. Just don’t go to Old Chicago.

I know, I know. It’s pretty cliché that us Chicagoans just had to stop at a place called ‘Old Chicago’ while in Green Bay. My bf wanted to watch the Bears game and he was convinced that this was the only «safe» place to watch it in town.
Nonetheless, Old Chicago had a wonderfully friendly bartender who served us all afternoon. They had great football specials or happy hour specials — like $ 5 drinks (their version of a long island was great!) and discounted beer as well as nice selections of $ 5 apps. We tried a trio of sliders, pepperoni rolls and chicken and they were all perfect complement for watching football.
The bar had a ton of tv’s with multiple games on, but if sports aren’t your thang, there’s also a dining room with booths and tables. Nice spot!

Friendly, fast, delicious, reasonable with vast selections. Open late. Have great calzones, fried zucchini and pizza. Beer!

I had a great experience from a service and ambiance perspective. Lovely staff and nice, clean restaurant. Also very clean bathrooms. Staff did a good job of rotating tables and making a busy Friday evening wait bearable! I was very disappointed in the pizza, though.
With the name Old Chicago, one expected true Chicago style deep dish! We got a 14″ Chicago thick pizza (as per our waitress’ recommendation, it was the perfect amount of pizza for three people). I knew it wasn’t going to be deep dish, but the crust and quality was the same as what you’d get at Pizza Hut. The toppings were good, I had basil and sun dried tomatoes, but the crust just wasn’t good. If you like Pizza Hut, you’ll enjoy this, but it’s not true Chicago style sadly.
I will go back to try their other menu items as I was impressed by the service, but I won’t be back for pizza.

Hit or Miss…
We have eaten here three times… and only one of them has been a good experience. The first time, we decided that the bad service and mediocre food were due to the ‘newness’ of the place. The second time (over one year later), the waitress was phenomenal, the food was great — we looked forward to coming back. Last time, OMG. No way are we ever going back here. The restaurant was not even half-​full of patrons on a Saturday, yet no tables were available because nobody was clearing/​cleaning the tables. There were two ‘hostesses’ at the door, but they were too busy holding up a wall with their boots to actually work. Our waitress stopped at our table and stared at us. Um, Hello? Can we help YOU? I asked if we were in time for ‘happy hour’ and she said, «I don’t know.» I looked at my phone and confirmed the time and said, «Yes, we are here in time for happy hour.» She had no idea what I was talking about even though I was holding the happy hour menu with the days/​times on it. We placed our orders (no idea if there were specials or deals) and waited. Our food was dumped onto our table (that was a nice touch) and she left. We didn’t see much of her (no idea where she would hide), but did watch her get hailed by another table who asked for more beverages and help with their table (it was being overrun with empty plates/​glasses). The waitress grabbed some dishes, dropped a fork on the floor, and then proceeded to put everything on a nearby table — that still had not been bussed. The fork? We thought that she was going to pick it up, instead she walked towards it and kicked it. Another server walked by it a few minutes later, picked it up, and put it on another dirty table. Wow. The food was meh. The service was beyond lousy. The atmosphere: Dirty. If a table needs to be bussed/​cleaned, DO IT. The hostesses were more concerned with their phones/​nails/​talking. The waitstaff was clueless and didn’t seem to care about a thing. Will we be back? Sure, when they clean their tables… which means, not any time soon!

I’ve been wanting to come here since we left Mesa AZ. This store has the same quality food as the ones I was used to in Mesa. They have a 2 for 20 deal which my wife and I got. You get 1 appetizer and 2 entrees for $ 20.00. We ordered the pepperoni rolls with marinara dipping sauce. They were very good. The cheese inside was so hot and gooey it made it hard to pick up with your hand. My wife ordered the grilled chicken sandwich which she thought was a bit dry and a side if fries which I thought were too salty for my taste. I ordered my Old Chicago stand by, The Chicago 7 pizza. It was perfectly cooked.
The food was delivered in a reasonable amount of time. I think the waitress could have checked on us a little more or refilled the soda once before the meal was finished. When we got the bill it was charged for 2 separate entrees and a separate appetizer. When we brought it to our waitress’ attention she immediately apologized and corrected it.
The place has a sports theme with several TVs tuned into sports channels. They have pop music as background music. The restrooms were clean. As a matter of fact the floors were still wet and somewhat slippery.
I’m looking forward to another visit to this store.

Attentive, but not excessive service. Variable appetizer menu.
Calzone was a taste delight and the pan pizza wasn’t a crust.
With 104 beers you can always find your favorite.

We ate dinner here and had the 14″ Classic — thin crust pizza– amazing flavor. Our server was Brooke and she was attentive, courteous and friendly! I would have to say it was the most amazing service by a server/​waitress EVER!
The food arrived quickly and Brooke stopped by several times to check on us and make sure our drinks were full. Servers around the world should take a class from HER!
Thanks Old Chicago!

Usually have the club sandwich, which is pretty good. Today I tried the pizza buffet for approximately $ 11 (including drink and soup or salad but not tip).
Pizza was pretty good but choices were below ave. (maybe 2 –4 kinds of pizza at one time) no problem however because I got plenty to eat! Actually i would rather have 4 kinds of good pizza than 10 crappy ones! I did like that you got a warm cookie at the end!
What wasn’t so great was the service. The waitress/​bartender was always gone. Grant it she seemed to be working hard cleaning tables or taking orders. Other times she was just absent. I did not get a drink refill until I was done eating and my salad bowl and used plates were never cleared until I got the check. I felt bad for my waitress because she seemed very nice, just spread too thin! The whole time this was taking place there were 2 hostesses standing at the door waiting to greet customers. Maybe one could have help in the barroom!