The Sweet Tooth Fairy

Every bite amazing!
I love me a giant piece of chocolate cake, so we came here.
When we walked in we were asked if we were first timers…
We Were! The kind young man behind the counter let us pick out a free cake bite to try. I had the chocolate peanut butter. Whew! That was crazy good. Then my mom handed me her chocolate salted caramel. (she doesn’t eat cake…) That also blew my mind… But they are so small. Granted there is a lot of quality in that bite, I still had to spring for the entire cupcake of chocolate peanut butter pretzel. OMG!!! Best cupcake EVER!
So glad I don’t live in Mesa and you know why. ;)

Holy cow. These treats are AMAZING. Salted Carmel cake bites are amazing. Great service and not too expensive. Plan on ruining any diet you might be on.

I ordered a special 8 inch round birthday cake and 20 gluten free cupcakes for my son’s 5^th birthday.
We have a gluten allergy and the great reviews about the gluten free cupcakes is what drew me in.
I requested for the top of the cake to have black-​and-​white checkerboard and NASCAR written on the side. I placed an order and provided a picture a week before the party. I spoke with the manager on duty, Austin, and discussed that they would not be using fondant and that it would not match my picture exactly. I said that was fine.
I placed an order with a bakery that takes cake orders and not with my friends-​friend (so to speak), I didn’t think there would be any issue.
I stopped in about an hour and a half before the scheduled pick up time, the cake wasn’t ready. I spoke with the manager on duty, Jen, and asked if they had any issue with the checkerboard? She gave me a I have no idea what you’re talking about look. So I explained the conversation that I had had with Austin and informed her that I had given him the image of what the cake should look like.
She went into the back and confirmed with Baker that they did have the image and we discussed not using fondant once again. I was dismayed that they didn’t have our order ready yet as they had a week to prepare for my order but I didn’t give it much thought as I felt confident after speaking with the on-​duty manager. My husband went in to pick up the order and texted me an image of the cake, I was not happy with the checkerboard. I asked him to ask them to write «Happy Birthday Jaxon». They refused saying that all the bakers had gone home, they are not trained to write on a cake. He paid for our very expensive order and left. I called the shop and spoke with Jen the manager and asked why they couldn’t simply write «happy birthday» on the cake? Anybody at any grocery store who gets paid minimum wage can write happy birthday on it, why couldn’t the specialty shop? She said all the bakers had gone home and that they wouldn’t dare write anything on an order. I am formed her that the cake looked like it was thrown together very quickly and I was very unhappy with the way the checkerboard looked and how is it that a bakery can not write «Happy Birthday» on a cake?! She started explaining how it was not fondant and buttercream would not look as good as fondant. I told her that I understood that but what they gave also did not look very good. They put no thought or effort into the checkerboard and they could’ve called and told me this ahead of time but they didn’t. The cake looks thrown together at best. I asked to have a call from an owner to discuss this further as I am completely dissatisfied with their customer service and have yet to receive a call.
The customer service here is poor at best. I gave plenty of time for the Baker or anybody who works at this location to review my order and give me a call if there was any question or issue. They clearly put the cake together in under an hour and didn’t care that it did not turn out how I had asked. Please do not order any specialty cakes from this place, they will not give your order any thought and throw it together at the last minute and not care about your satisfaction.

I love cupcakes. I love cake, let’s not kid ourselves– cake is one of the most delicious deserts on the planet. Sweet Tooth Fairy has some of the best cupcakes I’ve ever eaten. The staff at this location were incredibly friendly, and I was ELATED to find they typically do a whole variety tray of gluten free items daily! (As opposed to other places that offer only a white and chocolate GF option)
The cupcakes were moist and flavorful! The frosting was perfect — I can’t wait to need a cupcake again!

I’m not sure if the prices drop at the end of the night but I got 4 cupcakes for $ 13 bucks.
On the menu it said 4 for $ 19.95…I might of read he sign wrong but for an HR till closing time they were super busy
Can’t wait to try these cupcakes

I ordered a gluten free cake from them last summer for my sister-​in-​law and it was beautiful and tasted like heaven. Going to see if they’ll do a vegan pie for my son’s birthday this week.

Son asked for cake pops last min for his Birthday so I was happy to find STF open and so near us. Calling to inquire about the availability of cake pops I was told they had «cake bites» that were the same thing but without a stick.
We were incredibly disappointed. The cake bites are nothing like cake pops. Texture of both the cake and the frosting was totally wrong. I am the last person to normally turn down baked goods but I took one small bite and passed on the rest. Cake was blah and frosting too rich. Definitely sample before buying and don’t go here if you’ve ever had a good, real cake pop.
Only reason I gave 3 stars is that the girls working were friendly and helpful and we only tried the one product. The shop itself was clean and cute.

This is one of my favorite places to stop for a dessert treat!
They’ll let you sample a free cake bite when you stop in for the first time.

I have mixed feelings. Their product is delicious that’s for sure but the customer service is lacking. I have only been in the store twice and each time I’ve been served by the same gentleman. He just has this attitude about him like he’s doing me some huge favor.

YUM! Today is our 7 year anniversary, and we had a horrible diner experience. I wanted something sweet, so we stopped here. It made the dinner fade into the night as though it never happend. Thank you Sweet Tooth Fairy for saving our anniversary!

Holy wow this is the best cupcake place EVER! First of all, the employee helping us was SO NICE and enthusiastic about helping us decide what we wanted to try! We got to sample the cake bites because it was our first time and they were divine. We ended up trying the Reese’s cupcake, a sugar cookie, and bought a pumpkin loaf. Everything is absolutely delicious. Five stars and then some!

My daughter brought some cupcakes from your shop and I have to say the best cupcakes I’ve had in a long time. Thx!

Oh these cupcakes. Be still my soul. So yummy. The cookies are delicious as well. I find everything in general to be a bit overpriced. The location is darling, always clean and the staff is friendly.

We received these beautiful cupcakes and cake bites as a gift. The cupcake cake was soft, tender, and the frosting had a lusciously rich strawberry flavor. There was a single sliced strawberry on top. The cake bites were like the bon bon version of cake and adorable to behold. The cake for the cake bites was a little denser and slightly drier than the cupcakes but still tasty. Overall I prefer the cupcake over the cake bites but the bites are a perfect portable gift for bite sized morsels.

Best cupcake place ever probably.
We’re completely obsessed, come here all the time. Their cakes are light and sweet, their frosting is rich and delicious and truly unique — I was talking with one of the girls who works here tonight about how different it is from any other frosting I’ve ever had. I don’t know WHAT they put in it but it’s completely addicting and makes particularly their sugar cookies absolutely to die for.
Love love love their cupcakes as well. I typically go for the Samoa cupcake (tastes like the Girl Scout cookie in composition but like… 8 zillion times better) but I also like the toasted coconut or the s’mores if they have it. Cookies and cream and cookie dough are go-to’s if the others aren’t available.
I’m truly sad that I’m moving out of the state in a week so I won’t be able to partake in these blessed cupcakes again for awhile. Come to Florida, guys!

Absolutely the most delicious and moist cupcake I have ever had the pleasure of enjoying!!!
Stopped in earlier today to grab a few cupcakes for my hubby’s birthday. Great selection and outstanding customer service. I will return. Cupcakes are a perfect option if you want to celebrate a birthday but don’t want sweets in your house for days.
I highly recommend this bakery.

I went with the heart shape sugar cookie and strawberry shortcake cupcake. So far so good. I do agree it is a bit sweet but this is why today is my cheat day and only today
My household will be back being the service is on point and the space is very clean. Thank you

My hubby and I had wanted something sweet and after forgoing the ridiculous line at Frost we looked up cupcakes on Unilocal.
Due to the already amazing reviews we decided to drive over to Sweet Tooth Fairy.
From the moment we arrived the staff were so welcoming and friendly. We were able to try a cake bite for our first visit there that was delicious!
We ended up getting three cupcakes and sugar cookies. They even were giving away a free sugar cookie on Valentines Day.
Will defiantly return to Sweet Tooth Fairy!

I really like how cute this place looks. Its simple and amazingly refreshing to walk into. I like the décor and feel of this place! The cake bites are a tad bit too sweet for my liking but it tastes great. The cupcakes are good as well but a bit too sweet. If the sweetness were taken down a little i think id enjoy it better. I tried the strawberry shortcake cupcake and the frosting was a little too much for me but overall it wasnt horrible. My husband had the cupshake and he said it was good but mentioned they should provide a bigger straw because it was real hard to drink it when the chunks of the cupcake were clogging the straws. I gave only 4 stars due too it being overly sweetened but i would definitely come back again!!! The pricing wasn’t cheap nor too bad.

Love the cupcake selection! Great place to by someone you love a sweet treat.
The cupcakes are anything but average– tres leches, salted pretzel something, cookie dough, lemon and so on. They have such a beautiful assortment of flavors. The artistic work of this cupcakes deserves 5 stars! However I am more about cake then the frosting so I had to give them 4 stars. Their cake bites are a bit too sweet for me. Also I wish they had more vegan options.