Pizza Pauls

Only three slices left but Theresa warned them up for us and was very nice. Awesome pizza

Their pizza is a good (but unspectacular) thick crust pizza if you like that style of pizza. The real star here is their chicken wings though. I my opinion the best chicken wings I’ve ever had. Awesome sauce! I love getting a slice with my dozen wings and dipping it in the leftover sauce. My mouth is watering just thinking about it.

Pizza Paul’s is probably where I sure the most on Main. Ironically enough, I would probably give it a low rating if I had to review just the pizza. It might be a downstate opinion, but Mia’s pizza is so much better. Paul’s crust is way too thick.
Everything else on the menu is amazing! I love the subzone and get it all the time. The balls are also really tasty and filing for how cheap they are. I still haven’t seen anything like them anywhere else.

good lord let’s be honest here

While the pizza was delicious, the service was surprisingly mediocre. And when I say surprisingly, I literally could not believe what what I was hearing. We (a group of four people, including myself) ordered a small pizza and 12 wings (mild and hot) with no problem. They told us we had a 15 – 20 minute wait, and with that being the average waiting time for a fresh pizza, it was expected. However, after we ordered, I overheard a woman customer behind us ask to pick up the order she placed. All of the sudden, I hear alarms go off in the kitchen and a slight panic arose from the employees. Then I see a employee rush out of the kitchen and into the storage room (I’m assuming) with a burned pizza. I then hear the young lady at the counter tell the customer who had placed an order for pick-​up that they forgot about her pizza and it burned in the oven. Ever so graciously, the customer understood, said no problem and left the pizza joint in search for something else.
Fifteen minutes later, as promised, our pizza was brought to our table. They literally just set it down on the table, and the male employee left. We all stared at each other a bit confused. Not confused by the pizza, but because we had no plates to eat the pizza on! A member of our group had to get up and ask an employee for plates, and he said, «Oh yes! sorry, um… I forgot you guys need plates.» Then, another person in our group asked for parmesan, and the young lady at the counter said, «Sorry, we forgot to order the cheese.» Although a bit weird, we just brushed it off and dove into the pizza as we were hungry.
Since we ordered wings to go with our meal, we wanted to eat both the pizza and wings together, so we just munched on a slice each to fill our stomachs while we waited for our wings to come out. Mind you, it had already been about 20 – 25 minutes since we ordered them. Another 15 minutes passes by, the cheese on our pizza has congealed, and the boys in our group already gave up on waiting for the wings and ate their share of pizza. The same member of our group that asked for the forgotten parmesan cheese asked the male employee if our wings were ready. The employee, who looked very shifty and slightly embarrassed said, «Uh yeah… We’re just about to toss them right now.» And lo and behold, 30 seconds later our wings come out.
We received two boxes of wings, 6 in each, with one tiny container of bleu cheese, and a few sad pieces of white looking celery. For one, the wings were warm, not hot, not cold, but a nice «been sitting out for longer than it had to» warm. Another thing, the sauce of the wing was almost nonexistent. It looked like we ordered 12 pieces of tiny fried wings. However, there was a thin, orangey, oily looking substance sitting on the bottom of the box, which I assume was the sauce? Also, we ordered two flavors, mild and hot, and we literally could not tell the difference between the two. Whatever flavor the wings had, it was barely noticeable. Lastly, the wings were so tiny. I was not expecting jumbo wings, but the wings we received we SO SO small, and we even recieved a few tiny broken drumsticks.
Needless to say, we were a bit disappointed by the service and wings. Maybe they should stick to pizza? I will say that maybe the unprofessionalism from the staff is due to their young age since Geneseo is a college town. However, in opinion, some of the things we witnessed were a due to a lack of common sense and very basic restaurant service skills.
Like I said, the pizza was delicious. It had the right amount of toastiness and the sauce was divine. I would recommend carrying out, that is if they don’t forget your pizza in the oven

«I’ll call you back mr president, I’m at Pizza Paul’s» fact is I don’t plan on calling him back, cuz I want to rant and rave about Pizza Paul’s here in Geneseo ! who dat who dat is P i z z a Paul’s !
What a great locally owned pizza and sub shop. I was in Geneseo for work and it was lunch time. What to do where to go. I said let me check Unilocal.And of course Unilocal came through and showed me the light. No complaints from me here nothing but foodie goodness in my belly ! Ordered only a simple turkey sub and was blown away like a tumble weed in the desert! The sub rolls are amazing, the meat was stacked like a hustlers bank roll. It was delicious. And the price was low… Get low get low to the window to the wall low.
Can not can not wait till next time I’m in the area, I here the subzone is something that needs to be on everyone’s bucket list. A half sub plus a calzone. Bye bye diet hello yummy goodness. Can’t wait. My diet is being a foodie. «Don’t care, look over there… I’m eating»

Thank goodness for Pizza Paul’s. We had a wedding on a Sunday with a slew of out if town folks who were hungry! No place said they would deliver, all but Pizza Paul’s said they were too close to closing time. After talking to them a bit and offering a credit card they realized I was on the up n up. I guess they get many a prank call or order n no show from the college.
They whipped up up some sheet pizzas, threw in what hadn’t been picked up by no shows and called it a night. The pizza was average pizza shop pizza, nothing fancy, but the service made it 4 stars.

LOL so i didn’t relize this was a pizza place until my señor ano, but i’m so glad i did. They easily have the best pizza on their side of main.
I brought a girl here once and she almost hooked up with me, but then her boyfriend came (he was a GDI LOL)
You guys know i’m a pizza guy, so when I say this place has good pizza, you know i’m not jonesing you. Pretty cheap slices for the amount of bread you get. If you’re feeling rowdy you can also get «Paul’s Bulls», don’t let the name fool you, they are as good as a sorority girl on bids night.
Overall I give this place a…4/5 on the kenny k excel-​ants scale (my new scale-​like it or go home dude)

SUBZONE? Nobel Peace Prize winning SUBZONE? Having one of these is a better education in the game of life than the college next door. The pizza besides that sucks. Get a SUBZONE.

Great pizza! When you move out of the area you will soon realize that this is one place that you will miss like crazy.
The Quad and Subzones are absolutely phenomenal and the Subzone is a great bang for your buck. Paul’s Balls (dough with garlic cheese) are great too.
Always a good place to go grab pizza, whether it is lunch, dinner, or late night drunk hungers. Would recommend as the best pizza in town and one of the best in Western New York, unless you are looking for thin crust pizza. If you want that, go across the street to Mama Mia’s.

This place is the best pizza place in Geneseo.
Unlike the students that keep lying and giving me wrong change back at Mia’s, these people give me a nice vibe and has been very nice to me while I’ve been here in Geneseo.
It’s food here is not bad, although sometimes when you go when they’re busy, they may serve you cold pizza. However, when I go there and I have time, I’d always go pick up a Subzone. It’s soooo amazing.
Although it’s pricier than a slice of pizza, it’s worth it… and from what I’ve seen, most people that have come to Geneseo have never even tried it. If they want to compare the two pizza stores on main street, they should really eat this before making their decision.
The people are nice here, and the «family» that works here seems very nice. I’ve eaten here a whole summer and saw how hard they work to keep this establishment serving the best. Pizza Paul’s all the way!

THICK, filling pizza, with a pretty tasty sauce. Really hits the spot when you’re drunk and hungry. They make pretty decent subs as well.
The best part about this place is that it’s not completely run by college kids meaning your food won’t have pee/​spit/​semen in it and you’ll get it delivered in under 2 hours.