Miller Pizza Company

My family and I stopped here today on our way home from a Mother’s Day adventure in Chicago. The service was great! Prices were fair. And the pizza was amazing!!! We got the Chicago Pie. It was so so good. We would definitely come back and highly recommend it to anyone. Thanks everyone. The big Michigan family!!!

Just visited one of my favorite pizza places ever… these people do it just right with the perfect amount of toppings and sauce. A friend and myself ordered a pie so we could eat on the way to the concert at the casino. This is the only way it should be done. No grease. to the point… best pizza around. A top contender to most places in Chicago… My FAVORITE… If I had the money I’d ask to purchase a franchise

The pizza here is the bomb! They make some great pizza, full of flavor and perfect every time. I enjoy this place, I wish there was one closer by where we live. I always stick with the sausage and geese and it is absolutely amazing.

Our Senior Citizen group from Valparaiso had a «reading to kids» experience at Bannaker Elementary School and the host teacher suggested this place. It appears to have been an old train depot or train station by the railroad track. The place had a 50’s Fonzi, LaVerne and Shirley seating décor but with lots of interesting memorabilia on the wall. Waitress could have taught a Carnegie «How to Win Friends and Influence People» course with her outgoing friendliness and helpfulness. The portions were delicious and abundant. Keep in mind: no matter how good it looks or tastes, ask for a take-​home box. If we go back to Bannaker, we’ll go back to Miller Pizza Company.

Best pizza in the world ! My friends and I used to go almost every day at lunch when we were in high school. My husband and I make sure we stop in and get Miller Pizza when we are at home.

Pizza was just ok. Had a small Works deep disk. Didn’t care for the texture and seasoning of their sausage. Their sauce and crust lacked flavor. Once I picked out the sausage I realized there was barely any mushrooms, green pepper and onion.. I likely would not go back.

I have been wanting to try Miller Pizza for the longest time based on the reviews and for the most part I would say it lived up to the hype. I tried the thin crust and the deep dish. They were both pretty good. However, I was told by staff that the deep dish was preferred by customers over the Chicago stuffed but the stuffed looked better and I wish I would have tried it instead. The appetizers were also pretty good, especially the chicken fingers w/​blue cheese. Also tried the turkey & bacon sub. It was decent, but I found it kind of strange that they put the toppings on the side (which I didn’t know about until I already ate the sandwich). Glad to find a place that still has anchovies available for a pizza topping. Many places don’t have them anymore due to the fact that not many people request them. So overall Miller Pizza was good and I would go back.

Decent pizza in a fun atmosphere. I would not go out of my way to eat here. I didn’t really like ingredients in the pizza.

That was a disaster. We sat down at 8:30, ordered drinks, an app, a Stromboli and a large pizza all at the same time. We got the drinks in a decent amount of time but after that things just fell apart. The appetizer and Stromboli came out at the same time. We never got the pizza. At first the server said it would be 15 more minutes. More than 20 minutes go by and we check in again, still another 15 minutes. At this point at least 3 other tables have pizza that arrived more than a half an hour after us. We ended up just leaving without getting the pizza because the server didn’t seem to be able to give us an accurate estimate on if we would ever get it. Very frustrating! The pizza that others had looked and smelled amazing, wish we had been able to try some.

Went into Miller’s on a Saturday night, 9oclock. It has a really cool feel, mix of historical photos, Americana décor, trains, and notably very clean. Another plus– they tell us to just find seats, very inviting.
The server was initially amusing, clearly someone’s son or something since when we asked about what beers are on tap «I’m not sure, I’ll be back since I’m not old enough to serve»; he took a while to get back to us but that was OK since it gave us time to look through the menu.
We ordered a pizza, zucchini sticks and drinks, and one of our party ordered a sandwich. After 5 minutes the waiter came out and informed us the deep dish would take 50 minutes. While usually this wouldn’t be a problem, we were really hungry, we were in Miller for a race, so we decided to switch to thin crust. After a noticeable amount of time, our zucchini sticks came out, but also the sandwich that was ordered came out. All the food was very good but it was odd how the sandwich came out with the appetizers. After another 5 minutes, the waiter came out and apologized for the wait but our pizza should be out in about 15 minutes.
20 minutes went by. We’ve been in this restaurant for almost an hour and keep seeing other people getting their food while we wait hungry. Our waiter is also avoiding us. We flag him down, he says «oh sorry, I don’t decide when pizzas go in, but it should be another 15 minutes.» He didn’t say this with any attitude, but still, last straw. We were just promised pizza in 15 minutes 20 minutes ago.
We decided to pay our bill and order pizza from somewhere local that we could grab it from when we got home. It’s a shame too since the people who were eating looked like it was really good. Had the waiter not asked us to, essentially, change our order to save time, then fucked up, then not owned up to the fuck up and avoided us, this could have still been saved. I think I’ll just continue drinking at 18^th street brewery next year after the race.

The best pizza and sides in town. Even the delivery people know your name. If a mistake is made, it’s fixed Johnny on the spot. Nice eat in atmosphere too. You get it like it’s ordered. GREAT!

We had the thin crust with pepperoni, it was very good nothing spectacular. It’s a cute place with friendly service and decent food. Next time we’ll definitely try the stuffed.

I found out about Millers when some ladies talked about a lunch special. For a little over $ 5.50 (I think it might be $ 5.61) you get 2 huge slices of filling pizza and a soda. The pizza is deep dish, choice of sausage, pepperoni or cheese. The pizza is good and super filling but it makes me happy that this is not a chain and it makes a difference in the community.
It’s a bonus that across the street 18^th St. Brewery opened, you can grab a pie and beer to go. Yum!
This last visit I waited in the restaurant area. It was very clean and super cute. Staff is very friendly. I love this place

First time at Miller’s. We all loved the pizza. We ate at Giordano’s in Chicago yesterday, and all four of us agreed that Miller’s was better Chicago style pizza. (We loved Giordano’s too).
The wings were not spicy at all– that was a bit disappointing. Kind of just fried chicken. Good, but not buffalo tasting at all. Super friendly staff. We were the only ones in the restaurant on a Saturday night. I thought that was weird, but then someone told us in a text that Gary, IN is dangerous or something? We are from out of town. Maybe Gary is sketchy at night.
Great pizza! Great experience.

Good Chicago style pizza. I’ve been eating here since high school, and now I stop by here when I make it back to town. The sandwiches are also good!

The Chicago stuffed was excellent! Unexpected delicious pizza from a local Chicagoan, I was very impressed by their food. Service wasn’t the greatest but the food was amazing. Definitely world recommended to a friend.

We visited 18^th Street Brewing last night and ordered a pizza from here. It only took 45 minutes for them to deliver it right to the pub, which is across the RR Tracks.
We also ordered appetizers of Fried Pickles and Cheesy Garlic Bread. Both were very good, there were a lot of pickles but the bread was a little small, I thought.
Our Deep dish sausage and pepperoni had a lot of cheese on it, and a lot of sauce. My wife didn’t care for so much sauce but I liked it. The pizza had really good flavor and was a good size.
I had not had pizza from this place before and was very satisfied with the overall taste and cost.
They delivered to the Brew Pub, so that says a lot in itself about them going the extra mile.
I’ll order from here again. (Probably when we visit the pub again) But, this is worth driving a little out if our way to get, even if the pub wasn’t next door.

Good deep dish pizza but by no means legendary. If you are in the neighborhood stop by. This weary traveler enjoyed the deep dish with plenty of sausage. The epic carb loading, right before hitting the road again at 10pm, ensured a bright eyed journey… until the insulin crash.

Got the Chicago stuffed pie, with black olives, sausage, ground beef and pepperoni. Holy crap this is the best pie I’ve had in a long while. I would recommend this place to everyone. The service is excellent, the atmosphere is awesome and the food is even better. The wait though leaves something to be desired but if you call ahead it wouldn’t be as bad, I will be returning here for sure.

Awesome thin crust pizza. Really good stuffed pizza. Take note that the deep dish pizza is not true Chicago-​style deep dish, but a pizza with a thicker crust. This is our favorite place for pizza!