Stephanie Trentacoste McNally, MD

I am recommending everyone to Dr McNally and her Colleagues at All About Women Ob/​Gyn. In the space of three years I had two pregnancies and both were great experiences. Dr. McNally never rushes me. She sits and listens and she just compassionate. It’s like talking to one of my girlfriends. The other doctors at the practice that I have interacted with are just as amazing. I love that there is always someone willing to help. Dr McNally is truly passionate about her job and that comes through it the way she treats her patient. I also like the ladies at the front desk and the nurses are amazing. Having a baby other any other gynecological issue??? Then this place is great!!!

Soooo this is my first Unilocal review. Shocking though I used Unilocal to make a decision to go to Dr. McNally. The front desk staff were polite and professional. Dr. McNally’s nurse was amazing. Dr. McNally was through and patient, answered any question I had. I didn’t feel rushed or like a number. I didn’t have the anxiety that comes along sometimes with going to the gyn, good vibes. I had an another health issue and she followed up with me the same day. Again, I can’t say how great she and her nurse were.

I was referred by a friend to all about women facility in Garden City. She said all of the doctors were really nice so I called and made an appointment. Thank God the staff booked me with Dr. McNally. I’m so glad I found her. She is such a warm, thorough and knowledgable Doctor. She’s always so patient, gentle and informative with me. Takes the time to hear me out and answers all of my questions and concerns. She listens to what I want and then either agrees or disagrees and advises me on what she thinks is best but keeps my concerns in mind when it comes to treatment. She’s also excellent with follow ups and so easy to get ahold of. I’m always nervous and anxious when it comes time for GYN exams but that has decreased now thanks to Dr. McNally. Her personality is awesome and she treats and talks to me like a friend more so than one of her patients. My mom now sees her and I’ve been recommending everyone else to her because she’s THAT good.

I had my first child 7 months ago. I had an awful experience with my OB and switched to All About Women late in my pregnancy. From the day I entered the office Dr Trentacoste McNally was amazing. My Husband loved her from the start because she loves baseball, and the same team as us of course :) She had warned me that I had a big baby, and that I might need a c section. I was very stubborn, and didn’t want to believe this, but I put my trust in her because she was such a great Dr. On the morning my daughter was born Dr McNally was getting ready to end her shift, and she came to speak to me. She explained that the baby was too big, and I really needed a c section. She was so compassionate, and she knew I was nervous-​but promised me that she wouldn’t suggest this to me unless it was absolutely obstetrically necessary. Two hours later Dr Cafaro who was the next Dr on confirmed that I would need a c section because of the size of my baby. He assured me that everything would be okay, and calmed any fears I had. He then delivered our baby who weighed in at 10lbs 1 oz!!! Dr Cafaro did an amazing job with my surgery. I healed quickly, and with little scarring. He gave me the most amazing gift anyone could give. I am so grateful for Dr Mc Nally, Dr Cafaro, and everyone at All About Women for making the birth of our daughter– the most amazing experience possible. Having a baby is such a scary thing when you’re a first time Mom, and I felt so safe in the hands of these Drs. I recommended these Drs to my coworker who just had her baby this week, and she absolutely LOVED all the Drs, and the practice. I would recommend this office to anyone!

First visit. I’m floored at how nice Dr. Trentacoste-​McNally was to me. The office and support staff were so kind and accommodating. So happy that I switched.

Stephanie is amazing. She is sensitive, always in a good humor, and she will listen and answer all of your questions without making you feel like an idiot for asking. I had a very difficult labor with my son and a lot of pain during my recovery. I was extremely nervous about the six week check up following the birth. She was very gentle and understanding and helped to put me at ease. I would highly recommend her.

Dr Trentacoste McNally is an awesome doctor. Does anyone know where she is practicing?

Never received a letter or phone call that Dr. Trentacoste was and has left the practice. I had to find out when I called the office to renew my prescription. Highly unprofessional!!!

Dr. Trentacoste seemed like a very nice person and a competent doctor, with a couple of glaring exceptions. First, she didn’t bother to go talk to my husband after she performed surgery on me at the hospital. Secondly, she left her practice and I didn’t find out until I happened to call her office on her last day. The woman who answered acted like I should have known it was her last day, and she didn’t offer to place me with another doctor until I prompted her. A couple of other times when I’ve had doctors leave their practices, I’ve gotten a letter in the mail explaining the situation and referring me to other doctors. When Dr. Trentacoste left her practice, I got nothing. I find this unprofessional and inexcusable. I’ve found another doctor elsewhere, and to be honest I’m glad to be rid of that cramped office and the shady staff.

I’ve been coming to this office for just over 3 months now during my pregnancy. I absolutely love it. The staff is amazing. Maybe I’ve just been lucky with those that I’ve dealt with, but they’re always friendly and patient. They’re very accomodating, for example if you completely mix up appointment days, they squeeze you in when they can.
All the doctors are great, but Dr. McNally is my favorite. She is unbelievably easy to talk to and has a fantastic sense of humor. She even made my husband feel comfortable. She answered all of our ridiculous questions, that I’m sure she’s answered a thousand times before, but never made us feel that way. I felt like I had known her for years the way I felt so comfortable with her.
Sadly though, I just saw a note in the office today that she is leaving the practice to go to North Shore (I think). But, if you can see her, she is absolutely amazing and you’ll love her!

Can’t say much for the staff as they are terrible for the most part but Dr Trentacoste is superb. Her bedside manner makes you extremely comfortable, shes super easy to talk to. Makes you feel like you’re talking to a girlfriend during the exam. No awkwardness at all. She is thorough, knowledgeable and gives the best advice on birth control and every day womens issues. Best doctor in the office!

Dr. Trentacoste is nice enough but I have zero faith in the staff. Appointments get lost even after confirmation, glitches in their email system, you’re put on hold for 10+ minutes when you call (and even when you get someone on the line, they are talking to others so you are constantly repeating yourself) and didn’t get the results of my exam even after the doctor promised to call me after I had my exam. This is not a smoothly run ship in my opinion and I will seek recommendations for other doctors.

First time seeing Dr Trentacoste-​Mcnally after hearing rave reviews from many friends/​contacts. Staff was friendly, appointment was on time, and, most importantly, the Doctor actually took me aside to her office to get to know me. We chatted about everything from birth control options to how to control PMS symptoms & she even took time to talk about baby stuff even after I’d told her I didn’t want to have kids for at least a year. I’ve had experiences w/​many NYC doctors & I have to say she was a stand out. Thanks for treating your patients so well, we appreciate it!

The low rating is mostly for the staff. The staff could do with being more efficient, clear, and professional. The doctor is very nice & competent, but dealing with the staff is just not worth it.
Dr. Trentacoste is very good as a doctor and very nice in a doctorly way. Informative and pleasant and caring to the point of trying to make sure you are well informed. Lots of friendliness, not the warmest in certain situations, but certainly supportive and helpful. She called me personally quite a few times to try to help with my situation. If this were solely for the doctor, I would surely give four stars.
However, this review must include the staff which deserves much less. Although there are a few good members at the reception desk, there are a few others that are not. You may possibly wait up to 20 minutes on calls, although there always seems to be at least five staff members at the reception desk. You may also experience deja-​vu as you repeat your requests to up to three or four staff members about your call. This has happened to me on a few separate calls. And at least on one occasion, there’s been some attitude. Meanwhile, others on the staff seem quite attentive and good at their work. So, it’s inconsistent.
Initially, I hesitated to post this. But, I recently needed to deal with billing. And clarity was not their strong point. I spent nearly 40 minutes trying to understand what they were charging me. Thankfully, one of the staff was much clearer than the first.
Generally, I like dealing with offices that don’t cause so much confusion. So, I will be searching for another doctor.

If I could give Dr. Trentacoste 10 stars, I would.
As a new patient to the practice, I was nervous about how my appointment would go. While in the waiting room, another woman turned to me and said, «You’re gonna LOVE her.» She couldn’t have been more right. Dr. Trentacoste made me feel as if she’d been seeing me for years. Her confidence in and passion for her work was immediately obvious when we met to talk in her office. Within 30 seconds of our conversation, my anxiety was assuaged.
Dr. Trentacoste completely defies the stereotype that «good» doctors lack warmth or people skills. I have never met someone in the health profession who exudes understanding and empathy the way she does, and I recommend her unequivocally to any woman in search of a great (the best, in my opinion) gyno in NYC. This woman’s truly a godsend!

Oh my God. This woman is amazing.
I recently moved to the UES and am starting over fresh with doctors in the area. I have had to go on a couple different trips to different docs to find good ones (eg: dermatologists…) but Dr. Trentacoste, and her entire practice, is awesome. The receptionists are nice and professional and the nurses were really sweet as well.
I’m not pregnant or trying to become pregnant; I just need a regular OBGYN for my yearly visits and all that. So I’m a different type of patient than some of the others who posted, but I whole-​heartedly second the reviews that have already been posted here. Dr. Trentacoste welcoming, helpful, kind, listens carefully and cares deeply about her patients, which is way more than I can say about many other doctors.
I also did not have to wait long at all. This is a huge thing in my book! My time is just as important as hers, and she treats me as such. Love her.

I found Dr. Trentacoste after scouring the UES for a great OBGYN. Everyone I was referred to was either booked for months, or no longer taking new patients. Bummed, I did a last minute search on Unilocal and found Dr. Trentacoste. SO glad that I did because she really is amazing. She is warm, helpful, takes her time, but is thorough and efficient. Finding a great OBGYN is already difficult, but I come from Houston – a highly regarded healthcare city, so my standards are extremely high. I HIGHLY recommend Dr. Trentacoste, and am so happy to have found her!

Excellent and courteous staff. Minimal waiting time. Excellent hours. In addition to all of that, Dr. Trentacoste is a wonderful person, so friendly, so nice, and very professional. She is warm and made me feel incredibly comfortable. I am a physician also and I can truly say she is a gem with an excellent bedside manner. I highly recommend Dr. Trentacoste.

I love Unilocal,so much that I even found my OB on it!
An amazing doctor, very full of energy and enthusiasm. She is a perfect fit for me, and made me feel right at ease from the first 5 minutes. Having a baby is a very nerve-​wracking task, and I think I will do just fine with Dr. Trentacoste coaching me through it!

I FINALLY found a great gynecologist with good availability and a good office staff! Dr. Trentacoste is wonderful.