Sully’s Pub

Good food, good variety, wonderful atmosphere…

I grew up in Galesburg and used to love Sullys hot wings. I’ve been going to Sullys for 15 plus years and lost all respect for the customer service provided at this establishment from my experience of my last visit. I ordered over 70 wings for my family while I was in town visiting and the order was completely wrong. They made all of the wings mild when 50 were supposed to be spicy AKA screamers. The wings had little to no sauce after kindly asking for saucy wings. This wasn’t a big problem until I called in and talked to a man named Andy that was extremely rude and insulting when we asked kindly for compensation. Ive never known Sullys to have such a disregard for the people they serve. He said «I can give you a couple ranches and that’s it» followed by a chuckle. After supporting this business for years I can easily say I will never go back and I am disappointed that things have gone so poorly with a place that we grew up with and used to love. I highly discourage anyone going there that is looking for a quality dining experience or even just a friendly environment to enjoy wings. Ive never felt compelled to write a negative review but they were so rude and so far from an average customer service response to their mistake I couldnt believe it.

Went there with a group of ten. Got us in right away. Nice local flavor with reasonable prices for food and drink. Our waitress was very friendly and did a great job with our group. Will go back again if my sons college team plays near there again.

I came in for a late lunch. The drunk puking at 141pm on a Tuesday afternoon was a bad harbinger.
Things did turn around. The bartender was very helpful and courteous!
They have these huge Baseball sized mushrooms. It had potential but to be that big with no flavoring was a sin. It should have been stuffed maybe with a cheese? Or served with a horseradish cream. But as presented there was too much batter.
The Pork tenderloin was huge and delish! I would come back for that alone. It is hard to believe that it is hand made because it is perfect circle and huge. It has Sysco written all over it. Regardless it was excellent!

Love this place. My 2^nd home. Great food, great people, great beer!

One of my favorite resteraunts in Galesburg.
Servers have always been fast and attentive.
Great little atmosphere, like a traditional irish sports pub.
Their huge tenderloin is probably my favorite dish.

Yummy wings and good beer. Great place to watch the game!

Best catfish, great wings, great tenderloin and great service! I wish Galesburg was closer to San Francisco!

There are few choices in Galesburg to eat but this place is my FAVORITE! I no longer live in Galesburg but still visit family and friends often. I can’t come without having wings! I have not found a better place to go for them and I compare all wings to Sully’s wings. Great service! Great food! Great prices! Yep… love this place!

The best tenderloin sandwich!

Oh how I love this place ! The mushrooms are sooooo good, service is always great, food is fast and good, the beer is cold… what more could you want?

Lots of tasty and greasy bad for you food. A decent albeit not expansive beer list. Very middle of the road and easy atmosphere. Service can be a bit inconsistent.

Sully’s Pub has pretty delicious wings. The last time I was there I thought I’d be bold and try something different as I usually partake in the wings they have. This time I tried the Bacon Cheddar burger. It was good but was a hot sloppy mess. I looked like I was eating without the use of my hands, and was trying to eat it by sticking my face in it and just going at it. So I probably won’t do that again.
But if you are looking for really decent bar food, and really that is everyones M.O. in the Burg, I’d give it a shot most definitely.