Five Star Pizza

Great price, fresh ingredients, and fast delivery (it’s hot when you get it)! What more can you ask from delivery/​carry-​out pizza? Could improve the wings… but for good fast pizza it’s hard to beat.

This takes me back to my college days. I enjoyed a large cheese pizza from here and ate it on a park bench around the corner. Perfect late night dinner!

Finally got pizza 110 minutes after ordering. And it was pretty crappy pizza after all that.

Ode to the public school lunch lady! I guess this exceptionally low standard is appropriate due to the fact that this IS a college town. THE DESCRIPTION OF ONE LARGE CHEESE PIZZA… for the super «bargain» price of about $ 13.00! Mmmm… cheese that doesn’t stretch and I am almost certain is one molecule shy of my child’s playschool plastic pizza in her mini kitchen! The crust… hmmm…gluten free failure or did they rob the Catholic Church of the recipe for communal wafers crossed with a Dollar Store dish sponge! I love my garden, but DO TELL… What STRANGE fruit was that sauce derived from? Conclusion– EPIC FAIL!

Late Night New York Style pizza in Florida! You will probably hear me mention Five Star if one of our friends mentions «What should we get for food? I’m hungry». They also have a buffalo chicken pizza which I call a «BCP».

Thanks to Five Star Pizza for a great pizza experience overall. Perfect, fresh awesome pizza and pepperoni sticks appetizer! Rodney offered great service and was super friendly and helpful upon pickup. First impressions are everything and my whole group of friends would definitely eat at this spot again. Thumbs way UP!

Hungry… want food. its almost 2 am… no no I dont want steak n shake, or sonic or to sit down at the Clock or Perkins… Pizza? Hot gooey, saucey, salty cheesy pizza? YESSSSS!
Is it gourmet? no.
Is it the best pizza in town? no
Is it the worst pizza in town? No (that would be little caesars/​Hungry Howies for the tie)
for pick up/​take out are they quick and efficient? yes
are they priced correctly? Yes. For a take out large cheese? 7 bucks. and believe me at 2 am you dont need anything else BUT cheese on that.
At a certain point in the evening/​early morn they will just crank out the Large Pepperoni, Large Cheeses and thats it. like an assembly line and hand them to us tipsy, hungry people. It was delicious, and hit the spot.

5 stars. No questions.

Always fast, cheap, and yummy! They make the crust everyday by hand. And they pile on the cheese.

I bought a slice here on my way to the Double Down during Fest 10. Basically just an average slice of pizza — a little greasy, but otherwise tasty. It’s certainly better than Pizza Hut or Dominos, but I’d wager it stays in business primarily because of the location.

For what it is, and for the cost… its pretty good.
My friend orders this place to her dorm and she always gets a deal «campus special».
Bottom Line: Its Pizza, its greasy, its good for what you pay for. Want higher quality? Go somewhere else and pay more.

All I can say for Five Star is: Get the job done.
I would describe their pizza as like a slightly better Pizza Hut. If that appeals to you, then you should grab a slice. It does to me, so I was pleased, but all the while knowing «There is far better pizza to be had.»
Good, not great. Not a terrible decision.

I’ve only ever bought pizza by the slice here during music festivals, and it’s decent enough when you need to keep moving and don’t have time to eat anything else.
I definitely wouldn’t call it anything above average, but it’s not bad for what it is.

I have never been so upset with a business in all my life. I live 5 blocks south of this place and they will not deliver to my home, apparently because it is a majority minority neighborhood. I’ve lived here 4 years, and while its a mixed income/​race area, its been a lovely place to be as a student.
After I placed my order, I called about 45 minutes later to find out where it was, and was informed that «we don’t deliver to your neighborhood due to crime issues» Really? I ended up having to pick the order up (yes even though its 5 blocks away — by that point I was sober AND pissed off)
I think their delivery policy borders on racism and I hope you take that into account. The owner gave me some blah blah about crime — and yet, since I have seen the actual crime stats for where he DOES deliver (all around this small area) and know that those stats are much higher than where I live (I am grad student with access to that info) i know he is wrong. Until he changes his policy I shall continue to tell the world how slimy this attitude is.
Oh, and the pizza ended up being barely average. Guess I’m not missing much there after all.