Two Cousins Fish Market

I just bought some beautiful soft shell crabs today along with some great jumbo shrimp. They marinading at the moment and I’ll grille them tonight. A great place to pick up something just out of the water. The staff is great. I thank them for cleaning them for me. With the start of summer, I’ll be there quite a few times.

Swordfish is usually 2lbs /​$ 20 and is always exceptional!!!
I use the blackened rub & either grill or pan sear with veggies for great healthy meal!
I highly recommend Two Cousins.

This place is DA BAMB!!! the people are friendly, the place is clean and most importantly TOP NOTCH FRESH FISH. The review below this one, the lady was whining about the guys in the back begging for tips?! She sounds like a total DIB. The way those guys cleaned my fish and put the head and everything else so neatly in the bag for me to take home and make soup, the way they fillet my fish, all was so clean, they even took those little annoying bones out of the fillet. I dont know what shes complaining about, not giving a tip, where a tip is deserved???
I get very annoyed at that. My salmon was FRESH CLEAN and nothing like the fish I get close to my house in Brooklyn. This place is awesome!

Great customer service and fresh fish that they clean for you. Loyal customer real gem.

Today as my first time buying fish from this place, due to the reviews and ratings on here. When I first walked in everything was going well. The older gentleman gave me a warm welcome and even offered me free samples of the seafood salads they had available. He was incredibly helpful. He’s the only reason I even gave this place 2 stars.
Things went down hill when we went to the back where they clean and filet the fish. BE PREPARED TO HAVE THE GUYS RUDELY BEG FOR TIPS. One of them also claimed they work for tips like they don’t get paid any other way. The other man implied that them cutting ans cleaning the fish isn’t free like the man at the register told us. The men who works in the back are no where near as gracious as the older gentleman. The guy that was working on our fish kept offering to sell us fish scraps left over from previous customers for a really «good price». I wonder if the man in the front is aware of this hustle that’s going on in the back.
Overall the workers in the back were extremely rude and left a really bad taste in my mouth. They have no sense of customer service. They also were talking about us in Spanish not knowing I understood ever word!!! Next time I need fish I’m going down the street instead.

I remember waddling up to the fish and poking their eyes when my parents would take me here to pick up seafood for Christmas Eve dinner as a baby.
20 years later I know that if I need friendly service and quality ocean-​fare at a reasonable price, two cousins is my go-​to.
Located right on the Nautical Mile Two Cousins has been servicing the Village and surrounding areas for years.
Parking can be a bit of a pain and if their lot is full you can utilize the metered parking provided by the municipality.

This is my go-​to place for fresh fish. They have a great array of seafood and it is well organized. The guys out back who clean your fish do an amazing job. They are kind and tireless — be sure to tip them well. José cleaned my fish and did a truly professional job.

Really nice people !!! So helpful! I’m 24 and it was my first time cooking for xmas eve and I couldn’t open clam shells for my life they did it for me :)

This is excellent all seafood fresh, come here at least once a month. Staff is excellent, they clean how u want. Even have sell lemons and seasonings.

This is the best local fish market I have ever been to. Family owned and operated, local great people which is something I enjoy supporting. The fish is fresh, prices are good (have to consider the market). They will clean and cut it for you as well, if you ask. My family and I have been buying fish here for years and we will continue to. :)

OUSTANDING CUSTOMER SERVICE. My son and I came in right before closing with a bag full of freshly caught trout and asked to have them cleaned – a service Two Cousins provides FOR FREE – you just need to tip $ 1/​lb. Totally worth it, and then some. The young woman behind the counter said she would have to ask the guys, and reappeared moments later telling us to come around to the back where they clean the fish.
The guys were fast, efficient and exceptionally pleasant. They talked to my son about which ones he had caught, and offered to bag the heads separately so I could use them to make stock.
We went back into the shop to buy lemons and ginger, and to thank the front of the store team for helping us out. The gentleman behind the register asked my son all about his fishing experience and made some recommendations about where my son can learn how to tie flies and how to prepare the trout.
Remarkably, this is my first time going into Two Cousins – I’ve lived in or near Freeport over 30 years – but it will NOT be my last.
Two HUGE thumbs up! And thanks to everyone at Two Cousins.

May have been the worst meal I’ve ever had. The calamari had no flavor and the lobster bisque was nauseating. The only thing that was edible was the seafood mushrooms and I still wouldn’t recommend them. And they use Styrofoam??? Not a fan.

They have an assorted of fresh seafood delivered daily. Come here to get my seafood all the time for catering and personal use.

While stopping in Freeport in May, my daughter thought I would get a kick out of seeing this fresh fish market located along the Nautical Mile. (A) because it was so many kinds of fish… and… (B) because it was fresh. Even though I live in Los Angeles and can get to the beach with ease, the truth is, L.A. is not known for fresh fish markets, restaurants or otherwise. Sure, they exist, but it’s not a common thing nor a commodity like other ocean-​based cities, such as San Francisco, Seattle, Boston or anywhere else along the Eastern seaboard, so she brought me in here.
As evidenced by all the photos I took, you can see I was impressed by all that fish and seafood. Wow !! I don’t have a point of comparison to know how this store is priced, but I wasn’t going to buy any fish either. I was just being a tourist and enjoying it all. To be honest, if it’s really good quality, not to mention, FRESH… I don’t mind paying more for that. It’s nice to know there are places peppered throughout our country that can deliver on fresh, quality fish… and a great selection at that !!

Good variety. They offer military discount.
I like the marinated squid. The lobster bisque not bad flavor but to current I like it chunkier. Prices are okay but I found side places with cheaper big size lobsters.
I just moved from dc we have a huge fish market there nothing compared to this. But its all good.

FRESHH! That’s all you really need to know for fish markets, no? Totally fresh and totally legit. That’s all.

As far as fish markets go I can’t understand why others rate this place so high? Perhaps because they haven’t been to other markets? This is an average fish market. The prices are over priced. I believe Whole Foods is even cheaper and I don’t buy seafood there. The customer service is decent. You have to walk your stuff to the back to get it cleaned. Not a big deal but for the price they could take care of that for yA! Like any other Long Island fish market by the dock. Nothing too special here. Reality check everyone– overpriced.

The seafood here is extremely fresh and they have a lot of options. The owners and employees are super nice. The prices are also pretty reasonable. Parking is limited so try to go early in the morning.

My family and I spent the day on the beach out at Malibu Beach in Lido County. We’re not originally from the area, and wanted to come back home with some fresh fish. We spent some time researching nearby fish markets, and two cousins was by far the most popular. We took a risk, and headed out of our way post-​beach day to make a pit stop at two cousins. Let me tell you– this was the best decision we made all day, week, month and perhaps in a LONG time. We took home fresh tuna, steamers and steamed lobster, and we are still in a food coma of happiness.
This is absolutely worth the detour, and a destination that we will be stopping at again and again!

Fresh fish and shellfish. Excellent service. And plenty of ingredients to help you prepare your dishes. Simply, the best seafood market in Freeport.
Easily, four and a half stars.