I’ve had a lot of different kinds of pizza. Brothers is the #1 pizza I’ve had. Im from New York so I know what good pizza tastes like. I love their pizza. I also love their chicken wings to. I was raised in New York and I have had a lot of different kinds of pizza but Brothers is just like the best pizza in the world which is New York pizza.
Just A.
Classificação do local: 5 Nashua, NH
Swinging through Fredericksburg for a long weekend trip and craving pizza. Because who WOULDN’T crave pizza in the land of BBQ? Fortunately, I discovered this gem. Perhaps the best pizza I’ve had in a long time. Large pies with a New York style crust. The sauce is the right balance of sweet and tangy. The cheese is zesty without being overpowering. The ONLY downside is that they are CASHONLY. If you only have a card, find a bank. But it’s so worth it.
Sherry D.
Classificação do local: 2 Fredericksburg, VA
Pizza soggy and not evenly prepared all the toppings in the middle not much around the edge. Stomboli was filled with tons of onions not much else. Need some work on the preparing of the food.
Ryan G.
Classificação do local: 5 Denver, CO
Service was fantastic and quick. The food was great. Pizza really tasted like that good NY style pizza. Only thing that was a downer would be it is small but who cares the food was great.
Michael N.
Classificação do local: 5 Fredericksburg, VA
Great Pizza to say the least! Always treated like a friend when you come here!
Karl B.
Classificação do local: 4 Fredericksburg, VA
The bottom line here is that this the best pizza I’ve found in FXBG. I’m not even a fan of NY style pizza but this is better than all of the popular options in the region: Sam’s, Mama’s, etc. I would definitely recommend this over the options as the pizza here doesn’t taste generic or like they’re trying to mimic Papa Johns/Pizza Hut like the other places do. I would have given 5 stars however not offering delivery or accepting cards are kind of a drag.
Nicole R.
Classificação do local: 3 East Islip, NY
Ok I am a LI’r…lived there my whole life… so yea I’m a pizza snob so-to-speak…this place is ok… the owner used to live in Brooklyn so yea, he knows how a NY pie should be… he’s got the crust right… the thin-ness and even the grease right lol… However. the sauce is BLAND. very very Bland. The garlic knots are good just like NY. but I won’t bother getting pizza here again because the sauce is not good. So would I say it’s «just like or as good as NY pizza» NO. The only place your gonna get real NY pizza is in NY. If your not from NY though you will probably like this.
Marcia R.
Classificação do local: 5 King George, VA
My family is always hearing how this or that pizza is just like New York Pizza. In the last 16 years as a local resident each time I am met with grave disappointment. Today, finally, I was able to try Brother’s Pizza and FINALLY, the real deal. How did they succeed? They are from Brooklyn, my old neighborhood. The crust is just thin enough to fold it over, good amount of cheese and oh my the drippy olive oil. Bring cash, no credit cards are accepted. I will be back!
Paul L.
Classificação do local: 5 Locust Grove, VA
I am a New York pizza snob; I have NO problem criticizing so called«New York Style» claims of good pizza. So if you want really great NY pizza, run to Brothers Pizza. I have sampled pies from coast to coast and this pizza is better than many NY pies. I was born in NYC and this stuff is top of the list. The pepperoni medium is my go to.
Sarah H.
Classificação do local: 3 Fredericksburg, VA
Good selection of typical pizzeria/Italian items. We ordered a pepperoni pizza. The crust was well cooked and al dente even in the center which was appreciated. It was too greasy and very thin. Not a lot of sauce or cheese but generous pepperonis. Decent flavor but not good enough to bring me back again.
Kevin M.
Classificação do local: 5 Fredericksburg, VA
Greatest pizza in dead Fred, all the food I have had was great. Cheese steak, chicken pArm, pasta all great for a semi fast food place. Nice staff and good value
Connie B.
Classificação do local: 5 Fredericksburg, VA
Always hot and good. They do not accept credit or debit cards. However, it is worth the trip to an ATM to enjoy their subs and pizza. We had a steak and cheese sub and two pizzas they were fabulous.
Patric O.
Classificação do local: 5 Woodbridge, VA
Doesn’t matter what you get here, it’s amazing. The sausage rolls are incredible. The pizza is the best in town. The steak subs are the best in town… We drop by prettying every week to grab something from here. Take cash, though — no plastic accepted…
Alicia R.
Classificação do local: 1 Fredericksburg, VA
This pizza has no flavor and taste like it’s frozen. Wait staff was to busy talking to check on us. Waited 10 mins for a refill. Pizza was so greasy. If you want good pizza you gotta go to georges pizza in five mile fork.
Jason C.
Classificação do local: 4 Spotsylvania, VA
Good thin crust NY pizza just not enough sauce on it but it is hand made dough that is cooked good & it tasted good. We had the bacon cheese fries with ranch which were good as well. It is a family owned small business turning out a good product at a fair price & is worth trying– we will be back.
Shawn S.
Classificação do local: 4 Key West, FL
The pizza in this place is outstanding. Very fast service and friendly. We will definitely be back. Small place so if you have a lot of folks get it to go! They only take cash.
Joseph V.
Classificação do local: 5 Fredericksburg, VA
Best thin sliced pizza in town.
Tom M.
Classificação do local: 3 North Tonawanda, NY
Fresh in from in Buffalo and looking for good Pizza and wings on Fredericksburg. The reviews pointed me here so we stopped to check it out. The wings were… Eh… Better than a chains, but I wouldn’t order again. The wings were fairly small and. Breaded? One does not bread chicken wings. The sauce was just hot sauce and just poured on top. I’m sorry but it doesn’t take much to make chicken wing sauce. If you don’t know what you are doing drive over to Wegman’s and they have a halfway decent sauce. The pizza was good. It was a good thin NYC style. Not too greasy. If you like NYC style then come here. I like it but I prefer a thicker crust with more cheese and toppings. It is counter service, which is good as it saves money from not having to leave a tip. Make sure you bring cash as they don’t take credit. I knew this before I came and thought I had enough cash on me. They also take checks and thankfully I had my checkbook in the car.
Lai S.
Classificação do local: 4 Orange Park, FL
Never had NY pizza but my husband said it was amazing greasy and good, the cheese looked real good and stringy like how you would imagine a really good pizza would. I had the Philly chicken and it was good, not dry-thank goodness, at other places I would have to add salt and pepper not this place it was perfect! My daughter loved the fries too! A must try and bang for your buck!
Michele G.
Classificação do local: 4 Fredericksburg, VA
Best NY style pizza between here and DC. People love the steak & cheese sandiches, Pasta, etc. Specials include: Pizza by the slice or 2 with a drink. All around delicious.