Oscar’s Frozen Custard

After waiting months for this location to open, I have to say it is a bit of a let down compared to the restaurant that once was in this space. Nothing about my two experiences here was terrible, but nothing was memorable either. I tried their ½ pound bacon cheeseburger, which was flame broiled, but the bacon was the cheap stringy microwave kind that you are better off without. I’ve seen a few comments about the fries not being large enough portions, however I thought that for $ 1.29 you got a good amount. I mean, you can’t even get $ 1 fries at McDonald’s anymore, so I thought the value here was fair. The chili cheese fries were alright — a bit soggy and the chili flavor was not my favorite, but still edible. Make sure if you want yellow mustard on your hot dogs, you ask for the hot dog plain and then use the mustard packets in the seating area, otherwise you will get brown mustard if you order it at the counter (this happened to us twice, despite specifically asking for yellow mustard)
Overall the place is okay. But if you’re looking for the frozen custard type experience in this area, you are way better off choosing Kopp’s instead.

I stopped here tonight to get carry out for my family. I ordered 1 burger, 1 fish sandwich, 1 grilled cheese, 2 fries and 1 onion ring. I also ordered 4 single scoops of custard. I guess, living so close to Kopps, you get spoiled and I probably use that as the bench mark for other similar restaurants. The burger was just ok. My wife’s fish sandwich was also just ok. The kids grilled cheese was less than ok. I agree with another post that the fries seemed really small in the bags and were without salt. The onion rings were solid. Now the custard… we got chocolate and vanilla. The chocolate seemed like it was pre packaged because it was icy/​gritty and the vanilla was good, but again it’s no Kopps custard. You can really tell the difference. The main difference was the cost…$ 23 and that same meal at Kopps would have been about $ 35. In my opinion if you want a great burger, fries, onion rings and custard, go to Kopps! I had really high hopes because living on the south side of town there is literally no where good to eat. I believe in giving every place 2 attempts so we will be back to see if it gets any better.

Finally opened after the nice weather is gone. Well, the food is good here. Great burger and fries. My wife says they did not cut her grilled cheese so not happy about that. Her big concern is that she likes fresh brewed ice tea. They only have crappy, yes crappy, tea out of the soda machine. Yuck !!! Which is behind the counter so no refills on soda. Correct those 3 issues and it could have been 5 stars. The big plus for me as a train buff is the G and HO scale layout in the middle of the dining room. Nice touch there guys !!!

Overview — The custard is the bomb — get it! Food 3.5÷5 Customer Service 3.5÷5
I’ve had chicken sandwiches, BLTs, burgers (get the ½ lb, the ¼ lb is to small), onion rings, fries, and soup. All of it is decent, but the real reason to come to Oscars is the custard! They make their own waffle cones in store right in front of you. I’ve never had bad custard from this location!
Customer service is eh. It’s always just ok.

When I walked in I ordered my food I had onion rings and mozzarella stick. Onion rings were good and the mozzarella sticks were amazing. I also loved the scenery especially the big mountain train set to move the train you just have to push a little dogs nose. For dessert I had a hot fudge sundae and it was amazing!!! The service was amazing and the place seemed to be clean I think it is 4 stars.

I generally don’t leave bad reviews because teams deserve a chance to redeem there selves. I tried on my first experience at this New location. We have been going to West Allis for years and Franklin is not even close. The Sprite Fountain Soda had a bad smell and taste to it. The burgers were cold. The Chili Cheese Fries nothing like West Allis, the chili was cold and missing my onions and cheese I asked for. I think I will continue going to West Allis.

I love Oscar Burgers and I’m thrilled they have a new location. My only complaint is that they were too stingy on the French fries. For almost $ 2, I only got a small handfull.