Florham Park Pizza

I can’t recall a single time that I’ve dined in at Florham Park Pizza, yet I eat their amazing food all the time. I work in the area and this is the office go to spot for take out lunch and catering for office meetings and events. When the staff wants pizza, we go here without hesitation.
The pies are NYC quality at reasonable prices. Hot subs are of the same quality. You might be able to find bigger portions at other places (only talking about the subs, pizzas are huge), but quality isn’t the same.
One tip. try the grandma pie ;-)
so Good!
The prices here are the best in the area. If your looking fast, delicious, Italian awesomeness that will not kill your budget, come here.
If it’s not on the menu, ask, they will be more than happy to accommodate you if they can.

The food here is the absolute best!!! The staff is so accommodating, they always make sure that the food is perfect even when you have special requests! My father loves their sausage parm sandwiches and likes the bread lightly toasted, they always go out of their way to make sure it is perfect and that he is happy. I can’t say enough about their pizza, it is simply perfect!

Love the food here. They are always willing to accommodate any order. Pizza is so delicious, but the best thing here are their calzones!!! They are the biggest I have ever seen and so tasty!
Back in August I had a party for my daughter and last minute decided to order 6 pizzas, there was no question within an hour we had 6 wonderful pizza’s!!!
Can’t say enough good about this place!

Went here on Monday night and had a great meal! The chicken special was so good! Service was great they even brought out bread and bruschetta! Will be coming back again!

This place will get our business in the future. Our pizza (grandma) and entrée (meatballs with a delicious side of bread) were good, but — this is why we’re coming back. I came in on a winter night with just me and my 3-​year-​old. I needed to carry out a pizza and an entrée. Seeing that I was out of hands, the manager asked if I wanted help out to the car –NEVER EVER have I been offered help elsewhere under similar circumstances — and one of the guys behind the counter was coming out before I could even say yes. That kind of small extra customer service has won my loyalty, and I definitely recommend them!

Pizza is ok. They have good crust… but it was too thick for my taste. Got the Hawaiian Pie and it was bland.

Pizza is very good, though can be a little oily. Meat pizzas are loaded with meat and reasonably priced. One of the better pizzas in the area.

After ordering 3pies, a salad, and garlic knots last week and being dis satisfied, we opted to give FP pizza a second chance. I loved that the owner Dominic read and responded to my brothers review and asked us to give them a try again. Tonight was the night we did that. We got 1 large cheese pie and 1 half eggplant, half onions, both of which were complimentary. I love that customer service is alive at FP pizza and that they care enough to address a Unilocal review. With that being said, out of my family the reviews were mixed. We all agreed that tonights was better than last week, which was a lot thicker than we like and was very well done. I personally think that their pizza is good, despite it being a bit «doughy.» I like that they use less sauce and more cheese. My husband likes more sauce The eggplant was phenomenal, thinly sliced and absolutely delicious. I think that next time we will branch out and try some dinners next time to get a broader perspective. Any establishment that cares about their customers gets a second chance from me. We will definitely be back. I have been reading great reviews on the Grandma’s so that will have to be next time! Thank you FP pizza

Our last night in NJ visiting my sister and her family and my mother and we decided to get some pizza. I’ve lived in the Seattle area for the last 16 years after growing up in NJ and miss the proliferation of all the great pizza at reasonable prices back here.
We normally order from other places in Madison and the surrounding areas but after seeing the great reviews on Unilocal,I pushed for us to order from here (take out). It is possible that it was an off night, but boy were we all severely disappointed. We got three pizzas: cheese, half cheese/​half meat lovers (sausage, bacon and pepperoni) and half eggplant/​half onion along with two salads and garlic knots. The pizzas were all overcooked, more doughy and thicker than we like. I had two slices from Romanelli’s in Madison the other day that were so much better and typical of other local pizza that I love. The sauce/​cheese wasn’t bad but so overwhelmed by the chewy/​thick dough and crust.
The salads were good and the garlic knots not bad, but we ordered here for the pizza and came away very disappointed after reading such high praise. I’d likely go in and grab a slice and see if it was an off night, but definitely couldn’t recommend based on my single experience.

This is the best pizza in the universe.
It’s all in the main ingredients. The crust is the perfect mix of crispy and soft, and the fact that they use a real pizza oven (not that conveyor belt sellout crap) is a testament to the quality of their food.
I don’t know how they make the sauce but it’s obviously house made, and anyone who eats any pizza or entrée there can taste the difference.
The best part about Florham Park Pizza is that it’s been family owned and operated since its opening, and they’ve had the same guy in the back making the pizzas for as long as I can remember. They remember their customers and treat everyone well.
Florham Park Pizza doesn’t settle for quality pizza, they also have quality service.

Best pizza in the area! Their regular pizza and grandma pie are both excellent. Service is always good and fast delivery. Our go to pizza place!

Best cheesesteaks in NJ, hands down. They are very close to my job so we order lunch from here frequently. Never had a bad meal and that’s really saying a lot since we order so often. Even though it’s a pizza place, their salads deserve mention. The spring salad with grilled chicken is excellent. The chicken strips are well seasoned and never dry. The portions are always huge. Too much for me to finish for lunch but always gone by the end of the night. It’s pretty hard to go wrong with this place and if you haven’t tried it, you’re missing out.

I’ve known this place was here for a while and always wanted to stop by because the Unilocal reviews are awesome. I stopped in just after the lunch rush and grabbed a plain slice to go. Plain slices are probably the best way to judge a place (especially if you’re a «pizza traditionalist»). They did not have a ton of pies to choose from so it’s definitely more of your standard pizzeria. But…
Wow — the pizza was awesome. I was very impressed. It was definitely one of the better plain slices I’ve had in a while. I’m going to have to make it a point to get over here more often. The cheese even tasted better than most pizza places. The guys working were pretty friendly and they had me in and out which is what I needed. It is in the same strip mall as the CVS, Panera and Smashburger so this lot can get incredibly busy. Just be warned. There’s also not a ton of seating but good enough to get a couple of quick slices. Give this place a shot. It is one that I would definitely recommend.

It was fine, nothing special, just your typical pizza place in an NJ strip mawl. I prefer that pizza at Nonna’s.

I went here for the first time since I was in the area anyway. Very pleasant service especially from the older gentleman and perhaps owner. I had a slice of «Grandma’s Pizza», slice of Scilian and a slice of another one with mushrooms, onions, etc. I ate my meal while watching some soccer game and listening to Spanish music from a radio.

The owners are great and always friendly. They have the best pizza crust you will ever have in your life. and the grandmas pizza is easily the best one in the area, ask anyone who has tried it and i guarantee they love it!
Ive never had a problem and ive been going here for years. My personal favorite is the stuffed spinach and broccoli slice with a side of marinara.
If i am in the mood for a dinner i will grab the chicken franchese, they make it to perfection, delicious sauce

Always a great place for a chicken parm hero. The restaurant was renovated within the last year and they did a great job. I am a creature of habit and always order the same thing. My family likes the pizza here, I prefer a thinner crust, but it is still good.

Very disappointing, placed an order for delivery. The delivered the wrong item and refused to refund my money. I know when customers place an order and do not pay it is called theft of services. What is this called besides bad business. I din’t eat it, open it or touch it and the owner refused to refund my money.
Bad business, plus the dough on the pizza was too thick. If I wanted a doughy pizza I would have ordered a Sicilian.

A small shop in the strip mall, they were voted at once point the best pizza in the area (on their chalkboard), and they served up a delicious ranch chicken bacon slice and a pretty decent mushroom pepperoni (the mushrooms weren’t the plain kind, either, they tasted like they’d added some pepper and marinade).
Quick and simple place to grab a slice to get in and out. They are, as Chow C. noted, a bit more pricey than some of the other local joints, though. Credit card accepted if over $ 10.

It’s not delivery; it’s Florham Park Pizza!
If you know what’s good for you and/​or are open to a strong recommendation, order the grandma’s pizza! It’s the perfect combination of cheesy goodness, a hearty crust, and basil. Classic! I probably had 1 or 2 pieces more than I should have, but carpe diem!
I wasn’t as crazy about the white (sauce) pizza. Grammy all the way!