Mr P Pizza & Pasta

After a long day of corn-​holing with a good group of men, all that was craved were some quality slices of pizza. After pondering over whether to order between the oldest rivals Papa Johns and Dominos, we decided to go all in with a «Mr Ps.» What a crucial decision that ended up being. 2 pizzas. One pepperoni, one buffalo chicken. Each slice was hand crafted to perfection. No one was left unsatisfied,

Well, I found out something important as well as disappointing. The hamburgers here have all of the flavor, but the meatballs are in a different class altogether. Ready to enjoy a meatball sub at my recent visit, I was in for a surprise: the meatballs had NO flavor at all and tasted as if they had been boiled. Yuk! They were very unappetizing, to say the least. I won’t be ordering this again for sure!

Best pizza in Manayunk roxborough area!
Food is delicious the girls at the counter are a little slow but the food makes up for all of that.
Thank you Mr. p!

Go to the one in Flourtown! I tried this one in Roxborough because it’s closer to where I live but I was disappointed. My half cheese half pepperoni only had pepperoni on a third of the pizza, and the bottom of the crust was burnt. I ordered «garlic knots» and ended up getting a bag of hard bread with no garlic or seasoning or flavor.

What a pleasant stop in Lewes! Others had recommended it but I was admittedly skeptical. Besides the great pizza, the beer offerings are a good way to get acquainted with local drafts and the service was tops! I tried the nitro-​version of an IPA and am looking forward to having it again. Just as owner, Rick said the process makes for a creamier and smooth flavor. Highly recommend.

Today was the third time my order has been messed up. And when I called to let them know my sandwich wasn’t correct, I had to drive back in to the restaurant and bring the old sandwich (because I’m lying?!) with me. After doing as I’m told because I’m not in the mood to start conflict, I get a poor explanation as to why the issue occurred: a mixed cheese hoagie and Italian hoagie look the same in the system when printed out if you don’t read the whole order. Along with my verbal explanation, no other good customer service qualities besides «Sorry.» Really?!
I’ve lost all respect for this place, and I hope I’ve shielded you from making a huge mistake as well. Tony Ronis across the street is a much better option!

Great food, friendly staff — including the owner, who stopped by to see how everything was — and reasonable prices. What more could you want? (Maybe a few more tables.)

Stopped here randomly the blond woman ringing us up was very nice. We didn’t try any food but the pizza but it was one of the best slices I ever had. I loved the thin crust.

I stopped in here for a slice a few weeks back, the pizza was great! It’s very neighborhood-​y, you can tell that it’s a lot of the same customers. It is BYOB, they do table service, but you can also just walk up to the counter to order. Tried take out, and it was also very good, we will definitely be ordering from here again.

The food is hot and good. It’s not special or memorable but if you need a hot meal in a hurry it is nothing to scoff at. Order was fresh and quick and the price wasn’t terrible (but there are cheaper alternatives in the area).

Mr. P’s is a prototypical pizza joint in a strip mall. While everything is ok-​to-​good, nothing really shines, and nothing really stinks. Eating at the restaurant is a much better experience than delivery, but only by a half-​star.
Entering Mr. P’s one sees a wide variety of freshly made pizza. PERFECT spot for a quick slice — and they heat it up before bringing it to you. Weird service model — you order, find a seat, and they bring it to you. Always uncomfortable knowing how much to tip. Paper plates and napkins are the rule. Soda is available in bottle or on draft, but refills must be asked for. Anything fried comes out piping hot, but it’s all clearly frozen. Pasta is good… not great… but at a fair price and large portion. Pizza, in house, is 4-​star.
Delivery is where Mr. P’s tends to fall short. Pizza is often not really all that hot, fries are almost always cool, the pasta weirdly textured… things don’t really survive the trip home. The key to pizza is, however, as a leftover. Mr. P’s does NOT hold up well the next day. Eat it fresh. Pizza size is nice an large, if you order a large — which I recommend as best value. Avoid the deep dish — it’s just… thick. Not bad, not good, just… thick.
Unfortunately Roxborough has few really good pizza places, and none of those deliver. Mr. P’s is the best option for delivery, in my opinion. Three stars for a solid, if uninspired, performance.

My husband and I love this pizza, of all the places in Roxborough. The pasta, hoagies, and appetizers are very good too. My dad was impressed, for such an unassuming place, it is very tasty. The owner made us a a surprise special bubbly bread with olive oil and seasonings. It was similar to lavash. It was a pleasant gesture from the owner.

I have only tried Mr P’s plain and white pizzas, but have been extremely pleased with both. Delicious!
I will continue to come here and will try new menu items soon!

Dry food and burnt roll tonight. Usually pretty good but I have gotten the wrong order delivered before. Overall usually good but disappointed a few times

We came here after a recommendation from a friend who previously lived in this neighborhood swearing this was the best pizza around and we were semi-​pleased with our simple quick dinner. I felt the selection of pizza available was very limited as I was looking for something with meat. I settled for my other favorite type of topping which was some sort of mushroom topping. The actual menu had a really good selection of other things like pasta and salads. Pizza was good. much better than Costco but not the best I’ve had. There were some flies hovering over the pizzas on display waiting to be purchased and re-​heated which was a little unappetizing. but heat disinfects right? Good value… so-​so pizza. Maybe we need to try the other things there, too. Very cute mom and pap feel to the place, and I’d be willing to order a pizza from here sometime to give it a second try. Maybe.

Updating for my friends and because I now live in the neighborhood. Mr. P still has the best pizza and I particularly like the variety of pizza they have on display. When I’ve had a long day and don’t feel like cooking, I often stop here for a slice or two to go. The staff is really friendly, particularly the owners, and I always get efficient service. In addition, they’ve added a fun nicety lately at their shops of free sugar coated fried dough (not quite donuts) for you to snack on whilst waiting.
All the slices are good. I particularly enjoy their pepperoni, sausage, Sicilian and tomato pie slices.
Roxborough has a pretty vast Italian population and with that, lots of Italian and pizza places. I have tried many since I’ve moved here and among them, Mr. P’s remains my favorite.

On my first visit, I ate in and had a slice of their white pizza. Quick service, yummy pizza, great prices. Our second episode was delivery pizza and a cheesesteak– it came earlier than promised, super hot, and was everything I expected. They will definitely be on the regular lineup whenever we’re in need of a quick lunch while out shopping, or if we’re feeling delivery.

Used to order from here all the time I really like the mozzeralla and tomato hoagie with a side of tomato sauce for dipping. My friend loved their pasta dishes.
Then they started going downhill. Would take forever for the order to come. Then twice it never came at all! We called and they had already closed and just never showed up. I actually can’t believe I ordered again after the first incident. I learned my lesson after that

Order ANYTIHNG on this menu you win EXCEPT THE SPAGHETTI AND MEATBALLS!..
All their food is very good, till I made the mistake of ordering the spaghetti and meatballs, on a whim… I hated myself for 2 hours afterward
I like this place, but it was BAD, and the owners are right off the boat Italian.
Pasta tasted like someone spilled soap in the water, the pasta was cooked perfect, but the sauce was terrible.
Now meatballs in restaraunts, are always hit or miss… they missed this one. grainy, and ZERO seasoning, couple that with the sauce it was pretty bad
Now its important to point out this was the 1^st time in MANY years ive ever had a bad meal from Mr P., everything else they make is on point

Love the cheese pizza!