Fayetteville Antique & Craft Mall

I seem to be the minority here, but honestly, I was completely unimpressed. I only bothered with the single building on one side of the road, so maybe the shops on the other side are better, but I couldn’t believe the rubbish and the super-​high prices. Seriously, most of it seemed like trash pulled out of people’s closets, attics, garages and cabinets after they passed away. Lots of rusty things everywhere, and empty jars, cans and advertising. I guess some people like that, but then the prices were outrageous — like rolling pins (exactly like my mom’s probably from the 1950’s) with prices of $ 40-​$ 50. Goodwill sells the same thing for $ 2.
I would highly recommend driving the extra few miles to go to Black Rose Antiques (in Chambersburg Mall). They have some extremely nice stuff, a lot of primitives, some clutter, and prices ranging from amazing to insane, but you are less likely to get rust poisoning!

Love, love LOVE this place! Art Deco Stanley tape measures from the 1940’s, need I say more? Theres about 5 or 6 large buildings containing untold treasures. This antique mall spans both sides of Route 30 in Fayetteville, Pa. I bought several items for myself and several others as gifts. This antique mall accepts cash & still wraps things in newspaper (which they kindly accept). My favorite stands are the antique iron tools and the old sports equipment. Also if you look carefully theres an occasional desk or bureau for sale. I really enjoy window shopping more than a thing else, the historical value is amazing!

I love this place. I usually buy antiques under $ 50, and this place is loaded with them. There are 4 buildings, and each one could qualify as an antique mall on its own. There is plenty of higher end stuff to gawk at, but there’s just so many booths of stuff that people like me can/​want to afford.

I loved it here. So glad we got off the highway and stopped. A HUGE antiques mall with tons of collectibles and weird furnishings. All over the price points, lots to choose from. The crafts were a little lacking but overall top notch and totally worth the stop!

This is a great antique mall. There is a good mix of random junk and quality antiques. I don’t like my antique malls to be to polished because that usually comes with elevated prices. I like this place because you can occasionally find a real treasure for a good price. It’s the thrill of the hunt and with four buildings there is quite a bit to hunt.

This is one amazing mess of antiques. I always feel like I might have missed an area because you just wander and drift through aisles and nooks and corners and you feel like there isn’t an end.
There are several buildings on both sides of Rt 30 and you can spend hours searching and sifting through «stuff». This place has it all you just have to be diligent about finding it.
The people are friendly and always willing to help you find something if you are actually there for something specific. Great way to spend a Saturday morning, yes there are newer items here and there, local farming items, porcelain, comics, knives and tools… all the typical stuff but in MASSIVE quantity.
Go there, and get lost!

Really like this place. It’s for the serious antiquer. You can spend the entire day and not see it all. Good prices and some very unique finds. Complex is on both sides of Route 30, so be careful crossing. It gets pretty busy sometimes. Great way to spend a Saturday or Sunday afternoon.