Tiffany’s Tap & Grill

A friend of mine recommended Tiffany’s Tap & Grill in Eynon, PA. Why not? This tap and Grill is divided into two sections, the bar side with a few tables and the dining side. A very nice setting and an older building. Even the town/​village has an antique touch.
We were greeted by our server, Amanda, who read us the specials. Bread and crackers arrived shortly thereafter. We asked for water. We ordered an appy of clams in a wine/​basil-​based sauce. Very tasty to sop up the sauce with the Italian bread.
Our drinks came. The Moscow Mule was excellent with just the right amount of lime juice. Kudos to the bar. I was mildly surprised they had a variety of tapped craft beers. I had to sample a few of the local PA brews.
We both ordered the Angus Onglet Steak which is a tenderloin full of flavor, I ordered mine cooked medium. Onions and mushrooms coat this fare. We weren’t clear on the*after the entrée and our server explained the extra cost.
All in all the atmosphere, food, & the ambiance were a joy. Even one of the owners came over and introduced herself. Nice touch!
Caveat: please serve crackers only when ordering soup. Don’t short yourselves on good bread.

The food is pretty good, but could be better. It definitely seemed overpriced for what you get

One of my favorite places to go for an upscale dining experience. The beer and wine list is quite extensive, and the menu always has something to offer including seasonal favorites. I regularly order the Steak which I recommend, considering the full body flavor makes up for the slightly small serving size. My only major complaint is that this establishment DOES NOT accept Discover Card as a method of payment.

This is one of the best restaurants in the area. There’s always something fresh and in season on the menu– and it’s always amazing! My favorite thing on the regular menu is the fish tacos– they are the best I’ve had! There’s always a great drink special and a great choice if beers on tap.
Tom and Cheryl are friendly and welcoming and the service is outstanding.

Tiffany’s is just the kind of rare gem I look for when I travel. It’s a little mom and pop style restaurant with awesome food and a great atmosphere. It’s definitely worth a visit if you are in town.

I don’t understand all of the good reviews; the owner must have a big family.
I’ve been here twice, the second time because I figured the first was an aberration bases on all of the good reviews.
If you like very fancily names dishes with very small portions and little flavor, then Tiffany’s is perfect. I had the overlooked 6 ounce steak the first time and the half chicken breast the second. Neither was anything but basic. You can make it better at home.

Such a nice place. The service is very good and our waitress really took care of us.
I had dinner with some colleagues; they had a black angus beef, I tried it and it was very good.
I had one of their speciality that was mac and cheese and it was tasty and very well made.
I am going to be back and I surely recommend it.

My parents retired from the Philly suburbs to Waymart late last year and one of the things I really thought they would miss is good food! They’ve tried a bunch of places in the area and often have been disappointed.
I was up for a visit last weekend and my dad suggested Tiffany’s. He had been once before and loved it – and he’s a picky dude!
Since it was July 4 weekend we made a reservation. Boy did I feel silly when we arrived and there was no one there lol. Upon walking in I wasn’t very impressed. To me, it looked just like any other bar/​pub in Philly that has decent beer specials and an ok menu. I thought this would be one of those places that HAS a dining room, but no one goes just for dinner. Much to my surprise, the food was absolutely delicious!
We started out with the southwest eggrolls which were very good. The portion was somewhat small — two eggrolls cut in halves, so four pieces for the three of us.
My dad had a steak smothered in onions, some kind of sauce, and mushrooms (well he did order mushrooms but they were not included). From what I could tell it was cooked a perfect medium. He said it was delicious regardless of the missing mushrooms. His only complaint was that it was small. I’d have to agree. It looked to be around 6.5oz and the price was ~$ 27.
My mom and I both ordered the crabcakes which were truly tasty. They were sauteed perfectly with very little filler. Every single bite had chunks of crab. The onion mashed potatoes were also very good and the vegetable medley (while somewhat small) was so fresh and perfectly cooked. The tartar sauce was homemade and you could tell.
For dessert, my parents split a brownie sundae and I had the Lemon Coconut White Cake. O. M. G. It was an incredible dessert. Homemade. Airy and fresh with vibrant flavors. I was still thinking about that cake the next day. I mean wow.
I had a beer and my mom had two sangrias. I believe the total was $ 97. For a delicious meal WITH drinks, that’s really a bargain. In the city that meal would probably exceed $ 130.
My brother is visiting from Houston this week. I told him he HAS to make mom and dad take him to Tiffany’s and I plan on going back myself!

With all the fervor around farm to table, this is one of the only restaurants in the area that does it right. Amazingly fresh food in creative recipes. Love this place.

I have been here many times and have never been disappointed but the AMAZING food that was presented to me last night is forcing me to write a review.
To get right to the point, I ordered ghost pepper mango salmon off their weekly special menu. I know, ghost pepper … I was scared too at first but it was perfectly blended in with a delicious butter mango sauce on top of a bed of rice pilaf and mixed vegetables. The salmon was crusted with a teriyaki/​ginger combination and it was AWESOME. I ordered their beef satay as my appetizer and it was one of the most delicious things I have ever eaten.
This is a great place to go for a laid back meal. It will be my go-​to restaurant in the area when I am in need of a dependable great, meal.
My only knock is the craft beer selection is somewhat limited but that is something I can easily get over.
I highly recommend trying Tiffany’s if you haven’t yet! (No complaint about service but I have never been there during a typical rush).
Enjoy!

Good clean restaurant with pleasant décor. Food and service are very good. Only drawback for me is the multiple and ever changing craft draft beers. I not into a craft beer taste test every time I dine. I would prefer a few proven domestic draft beers such as Yuengling, MIllers (not lite) mixed in with the craft selections.

This used to be a great place. However, every time I have been there in the last year or so, it has gotten worse. Food takes forever to come out and the service could certainly be better and more attentive. You can do better.

Hidden treasure. Who new absolutely delicious from apps to entrées. Desert made in house. Brad was pur server and he was awesome.

The best restaurant in the area, hands down. A few years ago, a co-​worker told me to try this place, so I did. They have the most unique dishes I’ve seen on quite some time, that being homemade and made by the chef. Everything I’ve ever eaten at this place was fresh and homemade. Great apps, entres, beer selections and service. The chef/​owner will even come to your table and ask how everything was. Go here for a nice evening, you will not be disappointed.

Good food but their owner and service is lacking. They have a different menu for the area however are really overpriced. I prefer to not eat here unless it’s someone else’s choice.

Went here for a work Xmas party. Food was excellent. Beer selection was solid. Mixed drinks were good (White Russians were on point), service was awesome and best of all the boss was paying for everything. Fuck it, another round of drinks!

Only been here a few times, but each visit was very enjoyable. They have a very good selection of craft beer and unique menu items you don’t generally find in this area. Good place to take a date, not fancy or pretentious, and cozy.

My fiancé and I along with 14 close friends celebrated her 28^th Birthday at Tiffany’s. I’m glad we made the choice to celebrate there! Everything was PERFECT! Food was perfect! Service was perfect! The entire staff was professional and extremely friendly!
I would highly recommend this restaurant to everyone!
We will defiantly return!

Stellar food with a newly updated menu. The service is second to none! The owners Tom and Cheryl make you feel welcome all the time and are so accommodating! Try the late night happy hour… very cool bar with great appetizers.

A great place! Innovative and basic cuisine at one place. Great apps, entrees and deserts. Staff is very friendly. Recommend fish taco’s and veal vissuvio