Little Nicki’s Pizza

The pizza we had tonight was great! The crust is perfect and the sauce is fantastic. Will definitely go back again. We got carry out, but the interior looked sweet. Might dine in next time!

Some of the pizza around! The strombolis are massive. One of my favorite things here are the pita pizza slices.

This place has really, really, REALLY good food. Of course they’re not the absolute best tasting food ever, but their quality is quite high, and they are reliable. Solid 4 star Italian restaurant with a variety of choices, highly recommend you check them out.

I’ve been coming here for years and genuinely love this place. The food is amazing every time and the price is right. Their chicken cheesesteaks, barbecue chicken pizza, and pita pizza are a few of my favorites. The owner is super personable and all the waitstaff are polite and friendly. Little nickis is the best place for pizza and subs in this area, hands down.

First time there we got a pizza and calzone. The calzone was amazing. The sauce is very good. Will be going back to try more.

Great Pizza. Calzones are wonderful! Hard time deciding what to get. Love the subs! We go here often. The subs and salads are good. The staff is very friendly

I pretty much love Little Nickys. It’s not fancy, but it’s good. The pizza is greasy, but it’s tasty. The stromboli is friggen huge. And it’s tasty. The pepperoni rolls are cute. And they’re tasty.
I like the guys who work there too. They’re friendly. I’m always telling the one guy about how I travel around to Europe and stuff and he’s always asking me when I get back where I’ve been.
It seems like a family joint. Nice place. And it’s tasty.

Still great after many visits. They make consistently good food here!
Friendly service, and the owner is always concerned with how your meal was!

Best pizza in town! Always have had fast service. Staff is friendly and helpful. Cheese steaks are delicious and cold sandwiches are loaded up! Highly recommended

Great local pizza and friendly owners. The pizza came out hot and fresh with simple yet flavorful toppings. This isn’t a fancy place but if you are in the mood for a good local slice look no farther.

Once again a great experience, great food and service. Can’t say enough good things about this place.

Wish I would have found this sooner! The food is amazing! My favorite is the cheesesteak. Very clean and friendly staff. You can really tell the owner cares about what they are serving its amazing! I will be going back!

Came here on a whim on a super busy Wednesday. Pizza was really good. Despite how busy the pizzeria was our server was great! Super friendly and polite. I would come here again.

Awesome food, great friendly service.

We had mild hot wings (cooked well, not dry, good size), chef salad (fresh lettuce, deli meat and cheese, lovely pickled peppers), and taco pizza (a bit heavy on the seasoning but still good, nice balance between lettuce & tomato toppings). Everything was excellent and the service was prompt and friendly as well. We would definitely come back for more!

Our first visit for dine-​in and were welcomed warmly and asked to sit anywhere. The waiter-​in training took awhile to get to our table as he seemed overwhelmed but his trainer covered for him while waiting her tables. We shared a 10−12″ (?) cheeseburger bacon «½ pounder» that we both enjoyed! It came out quickly and was hot. A cheap date for less than $ 9 sharing a sandwich!
We were intrigued after paying and saw the pizza-​Meister making a cheese-​stuffed crust pizza… will have to try that on our next visit.

UPDATE:
I’m updating my review because I was very damn pleased to discover that the pizza here is as good as it has ever been, which is to say exceptional. BUT, in the spirit of the season this wise (ass) man comes bearing gifts of pizza-​related knowledge:
Little Nicki’s makes their ricotta FRESH. For those unfamiliar with the art that is a well-​made calzone, this is important. It’s excellent ricotta, and you can’t make a proper calzone without excellent ricotta. That’d be like Michelangelo sculpting his David from manure. It’d be like Da Vinci painting in mud. I’m gonna stop here before this Italian artwork metaphor gets away from me; try a calzone, and get it with a side of sauce. It’s a masterpiece.
Another thing I’ve discovered about this gem is that their hot wings are great. I consider myself a wing snob; I was born that way, and I’ll die that way. I’ve long accepted this facet of my personality, this elitist attitude of my poultry palate. I know a good wing when I taste it, and these babies are good. Properly fried, no breading, moist chicken, crispy skin, well-​sauced; the gang’s all there. It’s a good value, too, at $ 6.25 for 10 good-​sized wings.
Yes, there are people around town who get pizza from places other than little Nicki’s, but there are also people who rock out to Creed and dabble in cross-​dressing.

Let me start by saying that I am from Philly but come out to Lancaster each year on Black Friday to cut down a tree. While we are out here we like to try different places. After reading reviews we thought we would try it.
We had the cheese steak stuffed pizza. This must be a Lancaster county thing because I have never had stuffed pizza. I have had calzones, Stromboli, NY style pizza, Chicago deep fish pizza and even double stacked pizza but never stuffed pizza. Think of two large pizzas coming together with the toppings touching each other, then pinching the crusts to seal it in. It was delicious. We also had the wings and loaded fries. For 6 of us our bill was $ 50 including tip which was not that bad. I would definitely come here again.

Got take out of a large cheese pizza and large cheese fries. Staff very friendly and to date the best pizza in Ephrata. This place will now be where we go when we crave pizza. Can’t wait to try some of the specialty pizzas and the stuffed pizzas.

Little nicki’s is a family owned business. It is very clean and the service is great. Their pizza is also great but sometimes they take a long time to do the food. Their stuffed pizza is amazing and it is the one of the things on their menu that I would highly recommend anyone.