Kroger

For years, Eaton had the IGA on Aukerman Street. Suddenly, in late 1986/​early 1987, they were replaced by Marsh. IGA (Independent Grocers Association?) has some fairly inexpensive canned goods, but Marsh is mostly the opposite, and it’s rather local, coming from Yorktown, Indiana.
Kroger is a bigger chain than Marsh, having stores in several states, and even running convenience stores in other states under different brands. They’re not really cheap, either.
This location is somewhat small but seems neat and clean and the employees are friendly. They still have a reasonable selection, they just have to stock more often than other stores, I’m sure.
I found my Turkey Hill individual iced tea bottles right next to the bigger bottles in the dairy section, and they were priced the same as the bigger stores.
Kroger may not be inexpensive, but if you hit the sales, clip the coupons, and get the Kroger rewards card, you’ll be fine.