First time eating here, and it was fantastic! We ordered a Sicilian style pizza and an order of cannoli. The cannoli was OUTOFTHISWORLD! The pizza was great, too. The toppings were fresh and even throughout the entire pie. The crust had just the right amount of crunchiness. Well worth the price! $ 22 for one pie seems absolutely ridiculous to me, but it’s worth it because of the quality and size. The pizza is huge! We will definitely be ordering from here again.
Andrew B.
Classificação do local: 5 State College, PA
Along with Roberto’s, this is the best pizza in Easton. Friendly staff with some longtime employees so you always recognize a friendly face. Tony is a good dude as well(has an old school vibe). This is what you want from a small town pizza place– nothing fancy but the food is good and you leave satisfied for a reasonable price. One of the below reviews suggests the pizza is frozen… You watch them make it… If she ordered a single slice, of course it’s been reheated… Anyway, good pizza, nice people, etc.
Andrea H.
Classificação do local: 2 Trenton, NJ
Stopped in for lunch and the place has a full dining room… but the pizza is very basic. almost like its pre-made. Don’t get me wrong it’s not bad at all. just definitely not NY/NJ pizza. options were very limited and I think the cheese may be frozen. That’s pretty funny since the Frozen song is playing on the overhead music! I ate it. but probably wouldn’t come back.
Donald M.
Classificação do local: 3 Green Cove Springs, FL
Ordered a take-out pizza last night. The toppings were very good and the amount/quality of the cheese was excellent. The problem was the crust was so soft and flexible I couldn’t pick a slice up without all of the toppings/cheese falling off. Not sure how to fix this but I thought it made the difference between an excellent and a good pizza.
Chastain S.
Classificação do local: 4 Washington, DC
Great food but a really long wait. I drive 45 minutes to eat here that’s how amazing it is :)
Cindy S.
Classificação do local: 5 Naples, FL
Authentic Italian pizza, our waitress remembers us and brings us our beers. Our favorite is the vege pizza, the best we’ve ever eaten. Definitely the best in Talbot County. Very busy most nights.
Anthony T.
Classificação do local: 5 St. Michaels, MD
The best pizza I have had on the Eastern Shore. The owner is very friendly but the lady behind the counter had a terrible attitude and hopefully will be replaced soon. The rest of my experience was great but unfortunately it is tough to find good help on the Eastern Shore.
Penny M.
Classificação do local: 5 Easton, MD
The best pizza in Easton. Friendly staff. Restaurant is always packed and still offers great service.
Warrior I.
Classificação do local: 5 Annapolis, MD
I’ve been going to Rusticana Pizza regularly when I’m in the area since 2005. Their pizza is great. I love their sauce and they don’t skimp on the cheese. While I primarily stick with the pizza, the few pasta dishes and subs I’ve had have also been good. I like the relaxed atmosphere of the place. The place always has a good crowd. Plus, their prices are not hard on the wallet.
Dave L.
Classificação do local: 4 Baltimore, MD
I just can’t figure out how this place could get one-star reviews. I’ve eaten at least a pizza a month here for years, and I can’t imagine what these low-balling reviewers think is a good local pizza joint. I’ve had pizza in a lot of places, and Tony easily makes the best New York-style pizza on the Eastern Shore. Great crust, terrific sauce, very fair prices. Plus, the guy is there virtually all the time. The place isn’t always busy by accident.
Kevin R.
Classificação do local: 4 Baltimore, MD
Pizza was ordered for take out. Sauce was very good. Crust was a little soggy from maybe just a little too much cheese. All in all not a bad pizza by MD standards. I would definitely go back for another pie. Inside was clean and well maintained.
James F.
Classificação do local: 4 Fair Lawn, NJ
We are from Jersey. Stopped in Rustica for some pizza with family. This is the best NY style pizza I have had outside NY. And the service was great. The waitress was very ftiendly.
Leslie R.
Classificação do local: 1 Glenarden, MD
Stop there last night to get a pizza for my family… the pizza was not done enough… when I went to break a slice the sauce and cheese just rolled off of it and my kids said it was cold(I don’t eat pizza)…also ordered a salad and the lettuce looked old… how y’all still in business for real!
Brent D.
Classificação do local: 1 Easton, MD
Slowwwwwwwwww. If you order and they say 30 mins. Give them an hour. Place wasnt even crowded
Jeff m.
Classificação do local: 3 Easton, MD
This review is really about the new Rusticanan Express on Dover St. What I like is there must be a family recipe used for pizza. No matter what place you go, the pizza tastes the same — VERY good. What ticked me off was the counter girl telling people that the special of the day was 2 slices & a soda for $ 5.04. I told her I didn’t want a drink, just 2 slices. She told me it would cost the same either way so I said fine. Got my slices & soda & grabbed a menu on the way out & slices are marked @ 1.95. — So my first experience at the new place is more remembered for the counter girl lying than it is for the pizza. — Which was excellent as always.
Carl O.
Classificação do local: 4 Easton, MD
Good pizza. sauce isn’t overly sweet like many pizzerias do. Good consistent pizza. It can be a little too greasy, and often requires a lot of paper towel blotting before eating.
Sheila W.
Classificação do local: 1 Dover, DE
The service was horrible. We got our drinks, and they took our order, then we were ignored. People who came in after us sat down ordered and ate and left before we got our food. They did apologize and comped our order, but I will never go back there again. The pizza wasn’t bad, but the service was so bad I will never go back there.
Jeff A.
Classificação do local: 1 Easton, MD
Terrible pizza(But better than Lido’s) terrible atmosphere(seats are attached to tables so you can’t move them, and you are packed in there like sardines, you hear every conversation around you). But the worst is the help! Old, overweight waitresses who ignore you all night then hold you hostage when its time to go. I’ll never go back there, not even for carry out. Just Terrible.
Stephen R.
Classificação do local: 3 Alameda, CA
Good value, okay pizza. My buddy and I stopped in here for dinner the other night. We weren’t too hungry but we both tried a couple of slices. The pizza is pretty greasy and has that problem where the cheese is too viscous, meaning you can take the whole(or most of) cheese layer off the slice if you don’t get a sufficient bite that separates the cheese completely. The toppings are okay. Not great. In summary, if you want a decent slice for a really good price, this might be your place. If I’m ever back in Easton and craving pizza, I’ll probably try another place. PS. The service is quite good here.
Melissa W.
Classificação do local: 4 Bronx, NY
Rusticana has been a favorite of my family for many years. I grew up in MD, but was born in(and my parents are from) Brooklyn, NY. It’s hard to find good NY-style pizza down on the Eastern Shore of MD. My family has been going to Rusticana for as long as I can remember. Tony(owner and chef) is from NY originally, so we trust his pizza making. ;-) Cute little restaurant, good prices, and good pizza. Can’t be beat.