Lizzy’s Sweets

I found Lizzy’s Sweets on Unilocal when I was looking for semi last-​minute treats to take to a potluck. I’m glad I took the risk because she was a great find! LIzzy herself is very nice and easy to communicate with. Her cookies are delicious! I’ve tried several flavors and they’ve all been great. I’ve used her cookies now for both small and large events (as party favors) and they’ve been a hit each time. For something affordable, delicious, and different, I would definitely recommend Lizzy’s Sweets.

A pleasure to have finally tasted Lizzy’s Sweets! Not only are her cookies delish, her delightful persona makes it the perfect experience.
Fast and efficient, as others have mentioned, her customer service skills are outstanding.
Lizzy is so sweet! I needed a few dozen cookies in two days time and she was able to make magic happen!
Cookies were chewy/​soft and the flavors were true to description. My friends raved about the Eclipse — A pairing of desserts from opposite ends of the world, gives rise
to this soft and chewy cookie blended with roasted black sesame,
sweet rice and roasted peanuts, where east meets west.
Her cookie creations are memorable and worth every bite!
What you need to know:
– You will find the classics to the gourmet for every cookie connoisseur
– Some order requests can be shipped! (I know that I will be reordering)
– Lizzy is very thoughtful in her packaging
– Orders request a five day notice
– Always ask for recommendations.

We are doing a cookie exchange on next Monday and my co-​worker told me about Lizzy. I contacted her and told her what I wanted on Wednesday. I told her that i wanted to bring some cookies to my family for our Friday night gathering. Lizzy was sweet enough to accommodate my request and delivered the snickerdoodles and Heart of Rangoons to my house right after work on Friday! The first word out of my husband’s mouth when he tasted HOR was: WOW! And my family loved her cookies too! My aunt said to order her a dozen of HOR next time for her. The cookies were a hit! I am getting another batch of cookies on Sunday for our Monday cookie exchange and I cannot wait!

It was one of those nights where you are at home and trying to stay warm. I had the sudden craving for Chocolate Chip Cookies and did a search. Lizzy’s Sweets came up and all the reviews looked good. I opened the menu and behold «GOLD». I was a little overwhelmed to see so many different flavors and there was more than just the classic. There are some flavors that have earl grey, lavender and hazelnut!
I decided to place my order. I called at first but no one picked up, so I hung up and was going to call back after dinner. But Lizzy actually called me back. How many times do you call a place or even a friend and they actually call you back? I can’t even name anyone. She also left me a voicemail and texted me too! She also replies really quick by text!
I ended up ordering two dozen cookies. I ordered the Campfire which is a cookie with graham cracker, chocolate chip and marshmallows. Yes, you’ve read that right, marshmallows! You can actually see the marshmallows when you bite into it, which surprises me, cause i thought it would have melted. I love this, because i love Smores and this wasn’t as sweet as your normal smores. I don’t like it when my cookies are too sweet. This was perfectly soft and chewy.
Drops of Corylus was the second cookie I ordered. My friend loves Hazelnut and i wanted to give her a treat. So I ordered a dozen of this. Wow, this cookie taste like a Ferrero Rocher. It was so good! i love it so much. I love how Lizzy’s cookies are not too sweet and they are all soft and chewy. I also got to try the double shot of chocolate, which is perfect for you chocolate chip with chocolate lovers. The ulti-​Mint cookie taste like andes chocolate! Thanks Lizzy for the wonderful customer service and the delicious cookies!!!

Lizzy is great I recently tried her hazelnut cookies they are unbelievable, I think it is the best cookie I have ever eaten .If you don’t know what to get someone for Christmas Lizzy’s cookies would be a great choice and she packages them beautifully for the occasion.
Lizzy also caters large events or just for your individual needs.

Lizzy’s is awesome! I requested a large custom order — I had specified instructions on what I wanted — she took care of everything I asked for and delivered everything on time. Her prices are par for quality highly customized orders and did I mention they are de-​li-​cious!!!
I recommended her to all my pals at work and they all order from her now!!!

I came across Lizzy’s Sweets one day while looking for a «thank you» treat for a friend. Although the timing didn’t work out for that (I didn’t realize that orders needed a few days advance notice), Lizzy was so nice and the cookies looked so good that I couldn’t resist placing an order — glad I did because her cookies are superb! Here’s a breakdown of my experience with Lizzy’s Sweets:
Service: Absolutely phenomenal. Lizzy was always prompt about getting back to me, friendly, and incredibly accommodating/​flexible (I could call, text, email, even facebook her — I felt like I could just reach out to Lizzy anytime like I would a good friend).
Presentation: Lovely. A friend and I decided to split an order of 3 dozen cookies and Lizzy packaged them evenly and beautifully for us. I would have no problem with presenting a box of her cookies to someone as a gift. Each flavor was wrapped on its own, the presentation was festive, and the box looked «full» but not overstuffed.
Taste: Amazing. Unique flavors that are expertly mixed together. I sincerely prefer the taste over Mrs. Fields (too processed), Specialty’s (too buttery/​oily), and Anthony’s Cookies (good but wasn’t amazing to me… and not worth driving into the city and looking for parking). I got to try her ‘Wedding Day’, ‘Ulti-​mint’, ‘Cinna-​Yum’, ‘Eclipse’ and ‘Double Shot of Chocolate’ cookies. Each one was distinctly different and really good. My personal favorites were the ‘Wedding Day’ (Lemon, raspberry, and white chocolate) and ‘Ulti-​mint’ (mint cookie) — flavors I don’t often see and have a general preference for.
Pricing: Definitely worthwhile. You’re spending more than you would for a bag of Chip Ahoy cookies but you definitely see/​taste the difference. Cookies are unique and made/​packaged with love. Pricing is reasonable and competitive (perhaps even lower than other specialty cookie places or bakeries).
Overall: I highly recommend. I had a great experience with Lizzy and would definitely order from her again (Thanks Lizzy!!).

WOW! This is what I thought when I first tried one of Lizzy’s cookies. The cookies have a perfect blend of ingrediants that make you want more and more. Thank you Lizzy for sharing your passion with the rest of us so we all can enjoy your cookies.

Lizzys cookies are the Cadillac of cookies … Only the finest ingredients are used and they combine for a heavenly treat! Decadent!

Yummmm and really good. I didn’t think I was a big cookie fan until I ate Lizzy’s cookies. Everyone is baked perfectly and taste for me is what it is all about. I bake but Lizzy has «The Cookie» down. Done with care and perfection. Sooo good. I love all of them and can’t decide which I like better. Great gift for the Holidays! Don’t go on my word… order a few dozen now but save a few dozen for gifts!