Roma’s Pizza & Restaurant

Roma’s is one of our favorite pizza places to enjoy when we visit family in Dallastown (York). They deliver and compared to the chain pizza places who also deliver, Roma’s tastes more like a hometown, authentic pizza experience. On my short list of best pizza shops in Dallastown/​York, Roma’s is at the top.
Their sauce is sweet and their pizza slices are huge! Pizzas from Roma’s tend to be thinner crust, so while its delicious, it goes way too fast and you may find that you’ll want 3 – 4 slices to feel like you’ve gotten a full portion.
Along with pizza, I’d recommend trying a stromboli sometime too.
The price is about what you’d pay at a chain delivery pizza shop, but you get something that tastes unique — I highly recommend this place if you’re looking for great pizza!

Went to Roma’s for the first time tonight during the dallastown Halloween parade. Ordered a cheese steak and chicken steak boli. My boyfriends cheese steak came out but I had to wait another 15 minutes for my boli. I’ve never gone to a place that served part of the table. However once it finally came out it was very delicious. Will order again but probably to go so I know my food will be together.

We ordered the 2 large pizza deal this past sunday and it was nasty! We’ve ordered from there before and it was always «okay», but this time will be the last for me. From the moment I picked it up, I felt like it had an odd smell. The pepperoni were so thick, it was like have summer sausage on the pizza. Sorry, but there are a lot of other pizza places around. I will not be back.

Nice sweet sauce, great crust, fresh cheese

By far the best pizza in the area in my opinion. We eat here once to three times a week. I live in York now so it’s a small drive but worth it. Justin and his family are good people.
The pizza can be a little hit or miss as some mentioned. Depending on whose making it. But if you were to speak up they wouldn’t have an issue making it right for you.
The cheesesteaks are amazing. The bread is all home-​made daily. I could eat the bread alone and still enjoy it.
Finally the bolis. Man are they good. My gf wants a boli daily after trying one. They aren’t soggy and are packed with ingredients.
Try it for yourself. I don’t think you will be disappointed.

Roma’s is my favorite spot to get pizza, however some times it is a hit or miss. Most of the time to food is delicious but every now and then the food is not so great. I also really like the tuna boats and gravy fries. There is also another location in Red Lion.

Decent pizza.

Great restaurant with several locations in the area. This is just a small shop and not a place I would reccomend for a sit down family dinner unless you don’t mind sitting in cramped booths, but then again they do not try to come off as a sit down restaurant either. This is a pizza/​sub shop where you order at the counter and pick up the order, although occasionally I have had the food brought to the table when they aren’t too busy.
Now onto the most important part, the food. I have been getting food here for at least the last ten years, and I have to be honest and say it’s been a few years since I’ve gotten the pizza here. This is not a reflection on the pizza though, as they have some pretty tasty pie. This actually says more about their subs (grinders or hoagies depending on where you’re from). This place has some of the best bread, baked fresh daily. It definitely makes for a great sub. There are numerous choices for subs as well, including hot and cold subs and several parmigiana subs. One of my favories is the sausage parm. The bread is also used for the garlic bread. I reccomend getting the garlic bread with cheese. Another of my favorites are the strombolis. They have several options as far as the fillings, but they are all good. Italian dinners are also available here. I’ve had some of those meals and have never had a reason to complain. You can also get appetizers here, which is you typical pizza/​sub shop appetizer selection. Wings, cheese fries, fried mushrooms, onion rings.
In my opinion, a great place to stop for lunch, but for dinner I would either do delivery or carry out. They always have great lunch specials at low prices. Overall they are very reasonably priced and I would reccomend this place to anyone.
Also a special thanks to the drivers that still deliver to me even though I’m technically a fraction of a mile outside their advertised delivery area.

Best pizza. Everytime I visit York, I stop by roma’s for a sub and pizza. A++++++