Croydon Pizza

They have the best pizza around. I wish I lived in Pa., so I could have it more often.
The sandwiches and the salads are also very good.
We order from there for work functions and are always happy that we did.

Besides from the Croydon Pizza serving out the best pizza in town, their Chicken Focaccia is deliciously amazing! And it’s a nice switch up in between pizzas;)

The interior reminds me of a 90’s era Taco Bell with it’s turquoise paint job and wooden booths. It makes me nostalgic in here, and though they’re peddling pizza and not cheap tacos, I can dig it.
As far as pizza goes I actually really like their pies here. They’re filling with just the right amount of cheese to sauce ratio. They are salty but not overly so, and though the dough is a bit thick they aren’t very sweet in either the bread or sauce. The pizza itself gets a four out of five stars from me, it’s tasty but not out of this world. That said, I would definitely have it again.
On the other hand the garlic knots are atrocious. They’re not cooked very well and smothered in oil. Usually the problem with garlic knots is that they’re lacking oil, so the problem here is a very unusual one. It’s too bad that too much oil can ruin them as well.
So in short, I’ll be back for the pizza and will skip the garlic knots. A decent joint.

Best pizza you’ll find in Pennsylvania… I used to live in NYC and I would prefer this pizza to any joint that I used to go to in Manhattan.
Love supporting small business, but love supporting amazing small businesses even more!
Buffalo Chicken Pizza is bomb! — definitely try it.

The best Pizza on earth. No kidding. I have lived everywhere all over the United States and have been to Italy. No one makes pizza like Croydon.
If anyone gives it less than 5 stars they clearly do not have taste buds.
The only pizza that comes close is NYC pizza.
If you stop in you won’t regret it.

5 stars for pizza! Not crazy about a lot of their other offerings. BUT, ugh it’s pizza you want there is none better in there’s area. Try the chicken foccacia pizza, you’ll be hooked.

Best pizza around, period. Even beats out places inside the city. People who say otherwise clearly think places like Papa Johns or Pizza Hut are good.

Great homemade chicken soup Italian style. Pizza is outstanding. All ingredients are fresh good quality.

suprised at some of the harsh reviews. their pizza is nothing short of excellent. they make like 30 different kinds, and all are fantastic. some of the best sicilian pizza i have had. i read 1 reviewer say they only have 2 kinds of pizza slices??? she must have gone there at 9am, because i counted 21 different kinds the last time i went. they have great pizza, sandwiches, strombolis. yes, the owner can be intimidating, but he is simply entertaining. i highly recommend the meat lovers (2 slices will wreck you inards for 3 days), and the amazing «brooklyn style». i have trouble stopping eating this when i start. simply love their pizza!!!

I’ve eaten at Croydon Pizza 3 times and after each time I become more convinced I’d rather be ordering pizza from somewhere else.
What I don’t understand is why they only sell 2 kinds of pizza by slice. Do locals from Croydon only ever order Buffalo Chicken or plain slices, and nothing else?
When I first noticed that, I asked if they could just put one topping on a plain slice and charge me extra. And I kid you not, they absolutely refuse to make any changes to their plain slices of pizza. HUH?!
How complicated or difficult is it to just charge me $.50 extra for some sausage on my plain slice! Why is my only other option to just order an entire sausage pizza when I only want 1 slice?! OR anything other than a Buffalo Chicken slice.
And to only sell 2 slice varieties, you would think that their plain and Buffalo Chicken pizza would constitute to being AMAZING, right?
WRONG. There is nothing special about the pizza I’ve eaten here, nothing to make someone from Levittown or Bristol or anywhere other than Croydon, travel all the way there to eat. I mean, their Buffalo Chicken pizza is GOOD, no doubt about it. But nothing that YOUR local joint can’t also do or do better.
To be clear, I’ve only ever ordered their pizza slices NOT a fresh-​made pie, so I’m reviewing Croydon Pizza solely on that. You could say that’s not fair, because fresh will always be better than reheated slices that sat on the display for x-​amount of time. However, I’ve had good slices (WITH toppings) and pizza from so many other places, so why can’t Croydon do it too? Unless you really love plain or their famous Buffalo Chicken, look elsewhere for good pizza by the slice.
BTW, this low rating and review has nothing to do with the fact that I’m not from Croydon. Sorry guys: P

I love this place. Pizza and a show. The owner is like the soup nazi of pizza. The pizza is good, and it’s fun to watch the newbies panic when the pizza nazi yells «NEXT!!!»
Seriously I don’t know why the other reviewers gave it such a bad review. The food is good. The owner can be gruff when there is a huge line. The fact that there is a huge line speaks to the food quality.

This place should be avoided. One day for lunch, me and my wife stepped in here only to watch the owner snatch a plate of pizza out of one of his own employees hands because she was trying to call the man over who bought the slice but had walked away. He then left it on the counter for at least 15 minutes.
Then he yelled at other coworkers like they were trash, and treated the customers like we were bothering him, instead of giving him our money.
This place does not deserve your hard earned dollars. It certainly won’t get anymore of mine.
As for the food… meh. There is better in Croydon.

I really don’t understand the appeal of this place at the office. I’ve jumped on the Croydon take-​out bandwagon twice already… and both times I’ve been left unsatisfied, the latter being more. It’s a standard pizza shop, with offerings of pizza alongside sandwiches, entrees, strombolis, etc. The first time I got an Italian hoagie which woulda been great had the bread not been stiff and stale… the bread is a crucial part of the sandwich! The second time I ordered the petite pizza with pepperoni and garlic. Upon the first bite, the cheese came right off the pizza… ugh. Then, to make things worse, it just didn’t taste that great.
To say something good about this place though, the girl who attended me at the counter was nice and friendly. She even helped me carry some of the massive take out order into my car.
Fortunately and unfortunately, I will not choose this place again if it were my choice…