The Cooperstown Penguin

Delicious and innovative ice cream creations — start with chocolate or vanilla, and then they add on one, two or three additions. At the suggestion of our server, I ordered vanilla with cinnamon and apple crisp as my add ins, and it was DELICIOUS. My son got chocolate ice cream with peanut butter and peanut butter cups as add ins and he loved it. We are ice cream fanatics and have high standards, we definitely liked this place a lot.

Delicious.. and worth a couple of pitt stops whole ypu are in cooperstown. The Apple crisp was out of the world. Other flavours like peach, smores… excellent excellent stuff. The staff is friendly n there are atleast 30 odd flavors to choose from.

So delish! So many flavors and combos to choose from! The girl working was super nice and friendly as well and recommend her favorite ice cream and I got it and it was SO good! Coconut blueberry cheesecake

I thought this was simply a regular ice cream stand, but I was pleasantly surprised to see that they have quite a variety of flavors. They blend these flavors to order, which is pretty neat and you can get any combination of flavors that you want. I tried the banana coconut and it was absolutely delicious — easily one of the best ice cream cones that I’ve ever tried. That being said, a small blended cone costs about $ 4, which is definitely way overpriced and the reason for knocking off a star.
I would definitely recommend their ice cream, but beware that the prices are a bit steep; you get quality ice cream, but you definitely pay for it.

A blended ice cream parlor is something I have never tried before. I really liked it and I am FAR from an ice cream fan. Nice, quaint seating out back where you can sit and enjoy the clean, crisp air that as a NYC native I don’t get all too often.

Custom ice cream in minutes, can you dig it? Over 25 choices, better than any soft serve place I have been to anywhere. Try the peanut butter cup and the butterfinger.

Terrific ice cream stand on the side of the road between Oneota and Cooperstown. We were participating in a baseball tournament at Cooperstown Dreams Park — and the Penguin became a daily stop for us…
Great ice cream made form either chocolate or vanilla base and mixed with your choice of toppings. A junior size was always big enough for each of us.
Delicious!

Back in August, 2010 we were in town for a week of baseball. Our son was playing at the Cooperstown Dreams Park and all of us (myself, husband and in-​laws) had to occupy our way somehow so… we ate the MOST AMAZING ice cream on a DAILY basis.
This place is unbelievable and I should know… my family considers me to be THE expert on all things cold and dairy.
It’s the best of both worlds. You get the hard ice cream with the ‘mix ins’ you want and then they put it into a machine that mashes it altogether and pours it out like it were soft serve which just happens to be my favorite type of ice cream. True perfection!
The small is GIGANTIC and really their Junior is just right if you are looking for a ‘normal’ size cone. There is NO need to go any larger unless you’re feeding the entire team!
I am not lying when I tell you we were here EVERY SINGLE DAY and I have dreams of one day going back!

We arrived in Cooperstown three days ago, and have stopped here EVERY day thus far. The milkshakes are delicious, but we adore the custom ice cream — delicious ice cream that they blend in your choice of favors to order. My personal favorite is the chocolate with peanut butter and peanut butter cup. Definite yumminess so close to the Field of Dreams park. What are you waiting for? Go! Right now!