Fire 21 Pizza

This place was nasty. And it felt really uncomfortable. I was in Conway on a «vacation,» let’s call it, and was in the mood for some pizza. First Stop told me that they didn’t have any pizza slices and referred me to Fire 21. We got there and I immediately felt uncomfortable. The place was silent. There was no music of any kind and both of the restaurant’s TVs were off. When I got my pizza, it was spicy and the crust tasted like cardboard! The staff weren’t that friendly and we had to remind the guy running the front about the milkshake I’d ordered. When we sat down, the chairs were uncomfortable and there were HOUSEFLIES flying around the food and everywhere! Houseflies come from maggots, so… EW! The bathroom was tiny and absolutely disgusting. There was no hand soap and the sink was so filthy I didn’t touch it. If you are in the mood for pizza, don’t come to Fire 21. Go to First Stop next door. Trust me, you’ll want to!

We had a large square for take out. Half cheese and half pepperoni. It was great! No complaints.
This is old school Conway. If you’re looking for inexpensive food and basics I don’t think you could go wrong. There is nothing fancy about it… so keep your expectations real.

Ok, this place is not l’escalier, but staff is nice, food is good, and pound for pound the best deal on milk shakes (frappes) on the east coast. Good New England deli fare.

Oh, man. This place is NOT good. At all. If you are an out of towner, do not listen to the reviews below. The food is terrible and the place is filthy. I mean, really dirty, dingy. The bathroom is so gross. There is no music in the place. Its quiet. Its not expensive at all but its still not worth the price. I feel bad. Thats not what pizza should taste like. Sorry. Do NOT go to this place. You have been warned.

I don’t know what was wrong but the pizza had a weird smell to it and it tasted pretty bad, I eat a lot of pizza… Like a lot and have gone to plenty of different places in my life but by god this was probably the worst pizza I have ever had I usually eat like a whole 16″ pizza when I’m hungry took one bite and immediately thought it away.

Maybe it was an off night, but we went here one night and I got the buffalo chicken pizza. It was the worst buffalo chicken pizza I’ve ever had in my life. I usually like to give a place more than 1 try before writing a negative review, but don’t have it in me to stop in again.

Went around 3 for a late lunch. They didn’t have any slices so I ordered a tiny 7″. The gentleman said that it would take 7 mins but they accidentally burned the first pizza so it took twice as long. I didn’t mind waiting because the pizza was so cheap. The pie itself was a bit undercooked but satisfied my hunger nevertheless.

After skiing, we stopped at Fire 21 Pizza in Conway Village for a late lunch. This casual «order at the counter» pizza place offers homestyle thin crust pizza (7″-10″-13″-16″ pies), deep dish pizza, 10″ subs, bulkies, salads, pasta dinners, Hood soft serve ice cream & cold treats, fresh baked cookies, and cold beverages (Coke & Pepsi). The food prices are very reasonable. Pizza (cheese & pepperoni) by the slice ($ 1.49 each) is served 12 – 3. See the menu and pricing at
There’s upper tier table seating overlooking the counter/​kitchen area, TV, the Conway to read, video games and pinball machines to play while you wait. There’s also free wi-​fi too!
Ordered a small 10″ Sausage Pizza ($ 4.75) and a Linguine & Sausage ($ 3.99) for takeaway, which was ready in 15 minutes as promised. The pizza was on the greasy side, which had a thin soft homestyle crust and topped with plenty of sauce, melted cheese, and sausage bits. The linguine & sausage was a pretty good sized portion for 4 bucks, which had a thick chunky tomato sauce and Italian sausage over soft linguine and served with crispy baked buttered garlic bread (10″).
Overall, the food tasted pretty good and the prices were very good. We spent under $ 10 including tax for the pizza and pasta, to go with our frosted beverages back at the hotel.
(3.5 stars rounding up)
WEBSITE:
FACEBOOK: