Dewey’s Pizza

I have never had a bad pizza here. Their Seasonal pizzas can sound strange (sometimes…Like a pizza with a mustard base, hot dogs, and sauerkraut), but they’re always awesome. I usually don’t order a salad when I go out for pizza… but their salads are pretty great. Not to miss. I recommended the Peppercorn Bacon Ranch.
Prices are reasonable. You can have your pizza split, if you want to try two different types.
Also, they usually have a pretty good draft beer selection.

Really good pizza no matter what you order and the service is excellent. Connor waited on us and he is great. But coming on a cold snowy night, I can’t figure out why they keep the inside so cold. Pizza was cold after the second slice. If it wasn’t for the good service and the good food, I would have given 2 stars for to night’s cold performance. Try the pizza, you won’t regret it.

I love Dewey’s! Been there multiple times, but decided to get carry out this past Saturday and thought it warranted a review. Ordered 2 calzones and 2 salads. The calzones were perfectly cooked, hot and very flavorful. The salads are really what I love to rave about though. I had the Caesar salad. I just love the croutons which are more like mini-​garlic bread slices. The dressing isn’t watered down and it’s just downright tasty. Hubby got the candied walnut and grape with balsamic vinaigrette and it was very good. Price tempted me to give 4 stars, but I just can’t because it’s just that good! This review specifically for the Lee Road location.

I’m not a fancy pizza expert. Tasty, giant slices with awesome ingredients. Haven’t had a bad pie yet. Also had the Harvest salad for the first time; amaaaaazing. Also good low key service which is my favorite type of service.

Very good pizza with a great variety of specialty pizzas. It’s carry-​out or sit down with a good selection of beers (if you’re into that). For a chain pizza place they are VERY good. I would give it four stars, but I think the price is a little too high.

Wowsas, what a delicious pizza! Would love to try this again. We tried 4 of the specialty pizzas and all 4 were amazing! We also got a couple of the salads, which were great but tiny. I would recommend getting bigger salads if you plan on sharing.

Really good pizza! I’m a fan. I’ve ordered take-​out once and eaten in once. The service has always been friendly and easy. So far, our stand out favorite has been the Green Lantern. Additionally, we had a seasonal harvest salad whichconsisted of greens, figs, bacon, pumpkin seeds, boursin cheese, and an apple cider vinaigrette, which was delicious. I will be sad to see it go when the seasonal menu changes, but I’m excited to see what comes next.
Also, I always respect a restaurant that accommodates any requests or changes. You can basically customize anything. The only thing is that I was not so impressed with their sausage that we added to an order. It was sliced (rather than ground) and the flavor was lack-​luster… but the other ingredients were still so fresh that it really didn’t deter. I just wouldn’t order it again.
Other points: good beers on tap, wish they stayed open later.

One of the best family restaurants in the city. Pizza is terrific. Ingredients always taste fresh. Service is outstanding. I’ve heard people complain that the pizza is pricey but that’s because it’s a huge step up from the competition… and worth a little extra money. This place is a rarity – a chain that feels like an independent.

Nice pizza spot on Lee Road. Greek salad was good, although it doesn’t come with the traditional Greek dressing. Their house Greek dressing was a roasted red pepper version… it was still good though. We ordered extra cheese on our pizza and it turned out to be too much! The dough at the bottom wasn’t fully cooked. Won’t hold it against them though… just noting here in case someone else orders extra cheese. Pizza had a great taste, customer service was great… would return if back in town.

Any and every Dewey’s I’ve been to has been wonderful from the service to the food. Some of my favorites are the candied walnut and grape salad and the green lantern pizza. Also, there’s the Cuban pizza monthly special — to die for! This is a Ohio chain I Love to support!

Pizza is great. Even a plain cheese with their unique slightly spicy red sauce is amazing. Seriously their red sauce is the best pizza sauce i have ever had. Also recommend the Socrates Revenge and the meatball pizza. Great selection of draft beer.

Great selection of unique pizzas. You can do half and half with different types of pizza. Toppings are very fresh. The service is amazing — they are very attentive and friendly.
I’ve eaten there at least 50 times and have never had a bad experience. Definite 5 stars!

Good pizza place with having Little Italy just couple blocks down the road. I like the option to have half and half pizza. Servers are nice and friendly.

I am a bit surprised that this place does not get any anymore shout outs. First, it is an actual sit down pizza joint. It is harder then you might think to find one these days. One of the interesting thins that they are going with the open, industrial look. At first I was a little bummed, but it really settled with me in no time. They have great open view into the kitchen (behind glass) for the kids to watch and the folks in the back really play it up with the kids watching. Lots of fun.
The staff was great. very attentive and had great suggestions. They even have their own beer made at an Ohio micro brewery.
The larger pizza’ are actually large. To give it perspective, and I am not sure when the world changes, but a Large today from just about any pizza joint is what I would have seen as a medium (and in some cases a small Mr. Papa John) when I was growing up. Here a large will fill your table.
Their salads are the same way. The large is about $ 10.00 but would feed 4. They are huge.
The Pizza options are very creative and you can always build your own. I will be interested in their white pizza next go round. In this trip we had the Green Lantern and added pepperoni. it was fantastic.
The only odd thing is that they do not do appetizers. I think they helps with keeping the kitchen focused and the storage neat, but I would like to have some garlic bread to snack on, especially given their pizza crust (awesome).

I am laughing because I just reread my last review of this place from 2010. Apparently, in 2015 they still train their servers to be up your butt while you’re trying to enjoy your food. I mean, yes, thank you for checking in, but 5 times?! By more than one person? Please just let me enjoy my meal in peace. I know they were just doing their job. I don’t fault the waiter/manager…but maybe Dewey’s should rework their training/​philosophy on customer service to be a little less over-​the-​top. I doubt I’m the only one who feels this way.

How could you not love a place with menu items titled «Edgar Allen Poe,» and «Green Lantern?» I came here with a group of friends and LOVED it. After having Guys Pizza stuffed down my throat for years since it’s always the choice for last minute meals with friends, Dewey’s was a refreshing change of pace. The flavors are bold and the experience is fun, since you can split your pie, making choosing just one style a thing of the past. I agree with other reviewers that wait times and prices can be exorbitant. However, the deliciousness of the meal is certainly worth it, in my opinion. They don’t skimp on the toppings (like I’ve often noticed with Guys Pizza), and the service is very good. If they delivered, they’d become my new midnight craving speed dial entry :)

The pizza at this place is ALWAYS great! They have a great selection and always have something seasonal on the menu to try. The really nice thing is that they split the pizzas in half! So you and your boyfriend do not have to agree on toppings ;) There is a pizza for any mood and I have not had a bad one yet. Last time we went we had the Socrates Revenge… If you are an olive fan… GET IT! So yummy! The place is usually packed and they don’t take reservations, so prepare to wait at least 15 – 35 min for a table, but once you sit down service is usually pretty quick. Their beer list is a little lacking, but they have a huge wine list. Overall a great spot!

I love pizza. Who doesn’t? It’s polarizing though. So many different tastes out there. I drove 30 minutes because of the reviews and interesting menu.
It’s a great menu. You can even modify the specialty pizzas. I am sure I wouldn’t let people mess with these and just let them create their own from the build your own section. The staff and service are outstanding.
I ordered a terrific house side salad and I combined 2 specialty pizzas into a ½ and ½. Wild Mushroom and Green Lantern. I ordered both with red sauce even though the mushroom usually comes with white. I think their red sauce is too spicy. The crust is tasty and comes out properly baked, not exactly crisp but browned nicely. There’s not enough top heat in their oven. The tops aren’t cooked enough. The mushrooms are raw and shouldn’t be. I didn’t really defect a medley. All I saw were regular white button mushrooms. I liked the green lantern better but again wish the top was cooked a little more.
It’s good pizza. I would maybe go back and perhaps ask them to bake mine longer. I would also try the white sauce instead of the over seasoned red.

Dewey’s is one of my favorite places in the land of the Cleve for pizza. You have to try the Green Lantern. Their delicious crust topped with pesto, artichokes, mushrooms and goat cheese all yummy and gooey. It is probably my favorite specialty pizza around. Though in all honesty, all of the specialty pizzas I’ve had there are yum yum! The meatball pizza is covered in delicious meatballs, perfectly seasoned without any gristle or grease. Really, any pizza you get here is going to be great because their crust itself is amazing to begin with. Anything on top of that is deliciousness.
In addition to their great pizzas, their salads are also amazing! In the fall/​winter, they have a Harvest salad which is out of this world. It’s worth going to this pizza place for just its salads and I promise you won’t look like that weirdo ordering a salad at a pizza place. The portions are very generous. With my four girlfriends, one regular salad and one large pizza is plenty enough to feed all of us with usually a slice of pizza to spare.
The service is also well done here. My glass was never less than half full, and the server was always checking to make sure all was well. I will definitely be back for more Dewey’s!
P. S. I’d give five stars if they delivered. What pizza place doesn’t deliver?

Dewey’s is super-​fast if you can survive the endless wait in their awkward corridor. Even seated in the waiting area, I was always in the way of the servers.
We had the Peppercorn ranch salad w/​parmesan together, and the Green Lantern pizza with pepperoni, sausage and oregano. It was crispy and tasty all over, and hit the spot for values of New York style.
We also gave the triple layer chocolate cake a go, along with a Fathead IPA.
Ve’ll be back — just not during the dinner rush.