Di Vita’s Pizzeria

I tried this neighborhood staple after a long time resident praised the place. The extra thin crust pizza was perfect! Crisp, thin, perfect amount of cheese and sauce. Could have used more jalapeños– but thats my only complaint. Delivery was fast, food was hot, antipasto had authentic meats and was a nice size.
I cant wait to try the rest of the menu!

I love their thin crust pizza! I order a thin crust extra cheese from Divitas at least twice a month and it’s always delicious. Haven’t found a pizza place yet that I like better so far. I will say that most pizza places do not have other good food. There has been a few times where I’ve rolled the dice and ordered something different. The results were… chicken parm sandwich, very good. Lemon chicken, very good. Baked manicotti, very good. They never disappoint! Also, it’s a cute little place for dining in too.

Pizza here is great. Have had it twice and both times it was great thin crust pizza. The service was great both times and the waitress is extremely friendly.

I love the taste of their pizza, and their turnovers… And their pasta is great. They always deliver within the specified window of time, and the deliveriy guy always calls when he arrives. The food always arrives hot. The one thing that holds them back from getting 5 stars is they’re pricing,. They are just a bit high. Will continue to order from them as I have for years now, but wish they would drop the price a bit.

This place is great! And good prices too!
I only lived in the area for a short period of time, but Di Vita’s quickly became a personal favorite of mine for take out. They’re fast, friendly, and affordable.
My favorite menu item is the Veal Parmesan sandwich, I suggest you try it if you’re a first timer.

I have been ordering from here for at least 3 years before I realized I have never written a review. THE PIZZA IS AMAZING the thin crust is sooo crispy there is a perfect combination of toppings and its just perfection. It is affordable, I recently made a trip to sit inside and its byob and the staff is so nice. This is a great place and again very affordable. –The only thing I have not liked are the salads, but hey its a pizza place so what. The jalapeño poppers are amaze too! I highly highly recommend it!

It seems as though Di Vita’s had my review removed, so I’ll write a new one. Decent pizza, but their service is so awful… I had ordered delivery, and asked them to just call my cell (2 dogs and a newborn, so I needed quiet). Delivery driver rings the doorbell, making dogs bark, waking up baby. I asked him why he didn’t follow the instructions «Ah, nobody reads that» and then proceeded to yell at me, calling me a motherfucker. On MY OWN porch! And I paid him to do that! When I called, the manager said «oh, well you know, delivery drivers are all like that». No, no they’re not. He never once said he was sorry. So, Di Vita’s can suck it.
If you want better pizza, try John’s Pizzeria (on Western), Pizza Art Café (on Rockwell), The Art Of Pizza (on Ashland) or any Chicago’s Pizza. Or even a frozen Jack’s. Don’t give your money to these slugs.

New go-​to for pizza! Quite delicious. Cracker thin crust. Ask for pie cut, if you want it. 8)

This food was absolutely inedible. We ordered the chopped steak sandwich with grilled onions. The onions were huge chunks and raw. The steak was way over cooked.
We also ordered the calamari which was so tough, we couldn’t even chew it.
Finally we ordered the linguini Alfredo. It was mediocre at best. The only edible thing we received was a side of bread.
What a waste of money, will not be ordering from here ever again.

Had to wait 45 minutes for our deep dish pizza, but it was worth every minute! Incredible cheese, delicious sausage, flaky crust. Friendly waitress, good music, cozy setting. A great neighborhood «joint!»
We’ll be returning often.

It’s hard to find a pizza place that does both thin crust and stuffed well. Di Vita’s is one of the few. Neither are the best in town but both are very good. This is now my neighborhood go-​to place for both styles.

HORRIBLE The only good part about this was the food came on time. When the driver showed up, he RUDELY took my tip money and commented ‚” Oh that’s not bad”. I was so shocked i didn’t have time to comment. When i got upstairs i was horrified. My Medium well steak was Burnt to a crisp, the Italian beef was soaking with juice when i asked for Juice on side, and the hamburger tasted like an unfrozen paty microwaved and smashed between a bun.
I would NOT recommend eating at this place. For $ 40 its a complete RIP OFF It your looking for a good place try Out Door Grill on Milwaukee.
SHAME ON YOU DI VITA.

I order out pretty much every other weekend never had any problems I always get the rib dinner its super delicious!

I liked their thin crust pizza a lot. It was about $ 10 cheaper compared to other places where we normally get this kind of pizza — East of N Western Ave. Lot’s of pepperony.
Crust is good and really thin and tastes fresh. Inside of the restaurant is rather gloomy. I do not recommend dining in. I recommend delivery. The only bad thing — they only open at 4 pm. Even on saturday — we could not order pizza there for lunch. So, we had to order at LaVilla. LaVilla’s pizza has a rather inferior crust that tastes like premade.

3.5÷5
Ordered a single slice, but it looks like they hooked up 2 and had to place it in a small pizza box. $ 4 well spent. I was told it would be fresh and would take 15 minutes. It was more like 25 mins. Luckily, I had to wait only the additional 10 minutes in their warm, cramped carryout waiting area. I felt like I was suffocating, as the waiting area is completely walled off.
The most important part: the taste. I got the slice late night as a result of my wife’s pregnancy craving. It hit the spot for her. And with (technically) two slices, I snagged a couple bites myself. Pretty standard quality, relative to all pizzas. But for the neighborhood, it was above average. Pizza places are aplenty in Avondale; I still have yet to find one that is as good as any of the south side spots — thank goodness for Giordano’s on Milwaukee.
Sauce could be sweeter (possibly personal preference). Toppings were fair. Crust was meh. Cheese was standard. Two slices for the price of one (value) made this a good overall purchase. I might order again; I’ll just be sure to call it in for carryout instead of putting in an order on the spot.

Perhaps I should have gone with one of their Italian dishes since it appears those received good reviews but I was in the mood for a fish fry. Long day at work do I figured I’d grub hub it. Perch dinner was a decent price so I ordered that with coleslaw and fries. To meet the minimum order price, I added cheesy garlic bread.
The perch was noting special. Seriously, it could have come from the grocery store freezer aisle. Was not impressed. Maybe I’m used to different coleslaw but it was just 3 large hunks of lettuce with a couple tomatoes thrown on top with dressing. Not good.
The garlic cheese bread was ok and the delivery was on time, but I don’t myself ordering from here again.

The pizza here was pretty good — sausage and ricotta. Nothing spectacular, but enjoyable and a decent price.
The cheesy bread was laughable. Literally single sliced packaged cheese laid on top of a baguette that was cut open with a little butter and garlic. Would definitely steer away from.

I’ve been meaning to write about this place for awhile. The details are a little blurry but no less I gotta give my two cents about the place.
We walked in on this place on a random weeknight and it was our own private dining experience. There was no one there. Since we were the only there our server was very attentive. We started off with salads that were just mediocre. Nothing to exciting. Just some greens and a few veggies to fill in.
We ordered a pizza that was decent. I didn’t hate it but I didn’t love it. We all know I love pizza. It was thin and crispy and tasted decent. I thought it was weird that it was a round pie and they cut it all the way through in rectangles. I can’t remember exactly what we ordered on our pizza but it was probably pepperoni, sausage and mushroom. We’re still on the fence on this place. There’s nothing that will bring me running back but I would go if I was just settling for something for the night.
Give it a try if you’re in the neighborhood and can’t get out but if can be adventurous there’s lots of other places to go to.

Horrible and absolutely rude delivery service; he complained and yelled at us for not providing proper directions/​instructions on location of our condo building AND that he was waiting for a long time. We’ve had no other complaints from other delivery services.
They charged us for sauce as well and it was never included in our delivery after they dropped it off. Quality was not the greatest, but will definitely order elsewhere in hopes that customer service/​delivery person knows how to treat a customer.
Unless you want a foreign, rude, driver who is getting paid to give awful service, then sure, I’ll recommend this place. I’m sure everyone has a bad day; but it would be great if they would not take it out on other customers. And yes, granted this deliver was a late night order, i highly recommend finding a driver who doesn’t mind late night delivers or not offering late night deliver service with a frown.

No.
Ordered a small, thin crust pepperoni pizza.
Too much grease. Sauce is non-​existent. Cheese is deflated and not even stringy (you know what I mean, when you take a bite and pull away from your slice and that cheese just doesn’t want to let go). Pretty sure it’s just grease in between the cheese and crust. I’ll even upload a pic for ya.
Total with delivery was $ 12.15. I just gave the guy $ 15. That’s how much it costs to get a GREAT medium pizza from Coluta’s (on Diversey). I always order from them because they have really tasty sauce that has a hint of sweetness. But I wanted to try other businesses in the area.
Would I get Di Vita’s again? No. They’re better than Sarpino’s. That’s about the only good thing I can say.
P. S. I normally eat half of a small pizza and am done. I could have finished this entire thing — but didn’t because I plain did not enjoy it. Better off getting a $ 5 Lil Caesar’s.