Cream & Sugar Cafe

My wife and I came in on a Friday morning and tried not to be bothered by the very large for sale sign in the front window. Service was prompt but not exactly friendly. The server’s energy was an extension of the mood set forth by the for sale sign in the window: perhaps they’re done with running a restaurant and they just can’t find a way out of it. Sadly, the quality of the food supported my theory. I ordered the biscuits and gravy and, while the biscuit was fine (just the standard baking soda biscuit of the South), the gravy was horrible. It could have been easily mistaken for a bowl of porridge as it had the same texture and no salt or pepper to speak of. My wife’s eggs and bacon were just fine, nothing special. Friendly service could’ve made up for the bland food but it was clear that neither the server nor the cook we’re interested in our continued business in the future.

Wednesday 9am breakfast, only ones in the place. Had to ask waitress for more coffee, remind her we wanted ice water.
Food came out, we all ordered scrambled eggs, which were all runny. Biscuits were hard. And sausage patties were clearly once frozen (recently) and premade.
Upside: pancakes were good, home fries were good and the price was decent.

What a great breakfast place. It’s on the Main Street of town but you need to get away from the hotels and fast food places off the exit to find it. It’s hometown breakfast and lunch fare with a two page menu. Simple and delicious. The food was hot and well prepared. The staff is great but it seemed like just one girl was doing it all which meant service was a little slow but She was super friendly. Maybe the rest were manning the grill.
Wish I lived closer as we would go more.
Or recommend this for a lazy Sunday morning or any time you want to take your time and enjoy breakfast with your family and eat real food.

Quaint, charming café with awesome breakfast and lunch menus (didn’t try dinner). The Olde World Panini is excellent as well as the chicken salad and desserts. Reasonable, clean, great food!!! My family ordered Derby pie, lemon pie, and peanut butter pie, and they were all wonderful (served with homeade whipped cream piped over the top). This place is a must!

After traveling for 10 days, this was a good place for some fresh home cooking. No powdered egg omelets. Fresh ingredients, good coffee, fluffy pancakes. Clean, friendly. Downtown Cave City. Only 1 mile off way. I would definitely go back.

A wonderful, friendly diner with straight forward, simple and delicious food. An obvious following of locals, also friendly, a great atmosphere. Check out the art by locals, fabulous, natural and u ique canes for great prices :)

Had breakfast here after a great night at the Wigwam Village. Highly recommend! They had the best biscuits I’ve had in a really long time, along with some wonderful pancakes. Delicious hot coffee was constantly refilled, and I asked for some oatmeal with nothing on it and it was creamy and perfect. Fast service and incredible prices!

We had breakfast here after our overnight stay at the Wigwam Village in Cave City. The meals we ordered were fabulous and the waitress was super friendly. She called most of the other patrons by name. There wasvsome local art for sale near the registers. The sesting area and restrooms were spotless. The glea, ing hardwood floors made it homey. I would definitely recommend the Cream and Sugar Café over a chain whenbyou visit.

Cream & Sugar Café is located in a storefront in the heart of Cave City and serves only breakfast and lunch. However, what they should really be advertising is their amazing pie! Upon walking in the first thing that I noticed was that the décor was warm and welcoming and the booths were comfortable. The next thing that I noticed was that when I ordered a sprite I was brought a cup of ice and a can of sprite. I wasn’t given another can when mine ran low so it appears that there are no drink refills. The menu was fairly standard for a breakfast diner. I ordered a cheese omlet with pepper jack cheese and a biscuit and my boyfriend ordered pancakes with bacon and eggs. My egg omlet was only made with two eggs and they used cheese slices which did not fully melt when they cooked the omlet. The biscuit was hard instead of being light and fluffy. Not a stellar meal. However, my boyfriend’s pancakes were light and fluffy and fairly tasty. They did have an undercooked section in the middle though. He did enjoy his bacon and eggs. This would be a two star establishment however, because I was still hungry after my two egg omlet I ordered a slice of their peanut butter pie and it was AMAZING. If you are in Cave City and you don’t stop in and order a slice this smooth, creamy, delicious pie then you have probably missed out on one of Cave City’s best attractions. You can even skip the meal, just don’t miss this pie!