Old Chicago

The kitchen stays open late, which is great. The food is consistently not bad. It’s Casper, so the service isn’t always great, but good help is hard to find here.

This place sucks. It’s really a cleverly disguised Applebee’s. Food is awful, I doubt anything is prepared on scene. For a place that bills itself as a beer bar, terrible selection. You are better off buying a few craft ales at a bag of chips at the store. Also, this place is terribly overpriced. This is another chain that will not get my money.

I was very surprised one of the best happy hours in town. My husband and I had several apps and a couple drinks and spend less than $ 30. The waitress was very attentive and pleasant. It was very busy and the food did not take that long. We had the wings which were crispy yet not dried out. The loaded fries (bacon, beer cheese, other cheeses, tomatoes, scallions, sour cream) YUM and the fried calamari. All were pretty darned good (loved the lemon aioli on the calamari) and half off to boot! Happy hour is 3 – 6 all week

Walking distance of Courtyard and Holiday Inn. Not quite a selection of beers as Denver, but still great choices. Surprise to see the create your own dishes. Went with the mac n cheese, and yes made some good choices to make the meal good.
Love the fact their menu always is is the change which makes a visit any time of the year a visit. If you have not tried an Old Chicago then you must try you will be happy you did.

Ordered the deep dish Hawaiian pizza for take out. Pizza was a bit soggy at the bottom and hard to take slices out, but overall delicious. Would want to go back and check out their beer Hall of Foam.

I have been here almost every day-​off I have from work during happy hour. The beer is good and the food reasonably priced during happy hour. I don’t think I would buy food if it wasn’t happy hour though. The bartenders Aaron, Mike, and Vanessa were all nice and helpful in choosing what would best fit my palette at that moment.

The chicken got stuck in my teeth, but it’s no biggie because they had some toothpicks and it all worked out.
The bartender is kind of a Guido but I guess he is kinda funny so he’s cool too.
All the other employees seem like they shower at least daily if not more and are polite and everything so that’s good.

Fun place to take the family or your buddy’s to. The food is usually killer and they add new stuff frequently

What a find. great service and great bar. 3 pm to 6 pm all drinks and most of the food is half price. Many different types of beer. They have a beer club if you try enough different types you get a tshirt. I really enjoyed this place.

Very good food. We had the chicken avocado salad, Thai chicken wings, tri Chicago platter. Our server was Rick and he was very good.

I am a total fan of this place! Great thin crust pizza and Ranch dressing! The pizza crust has a buttery, crispy flavor. Great beer selection. The only reason I give it 4 stars is b/​c of the price. A large thin crust is $ 18.95. Even though its higher priced than I am used to, I will keep going back when I’m in the area.

Very awesome pizza and Dessert:) any draft beer you can ask for!!!

I am a huge fan of Old Chicago.
I’ve been to so many Old Chicago’s from Iowa-​Chicago-​Minnesota-​Denver– and ect… this one is the 2^nd best I’ve ever been too. The staff was VERY helpful, managers were GREAT, service was quick, and well, just a great experience. So if you like great service and like being treated like you matter this is the place to go

Yay! I’m a fan. I’ve been here several times over the past few weeks and they never disappoint. We visited on Saturday night last week and everything was great.
Promptly seated and served drinks. Waitress was friendly and helpful with the menu. We ordered the thick crust pizza which was excellent. I hoped to get the really thick Chicago style pizza with a layer of cheese and sauce on top but that has proven difficult to find outside of Chicago. NBA playoffs on TV was an added bonus.
This location is turning into my go to spot in Casper.

I didn’t enjoy my experience here at all. I’m not terribly hard to please as far as food goes. I mean, I eat Hamburger Helper more often than I’d like to admit. But my spaghetti was honestly just bad. The sauce tasted like the awful canned stuff (I can do boxed pasta but not canned veggies), the pasta was meh. I didn’t eat most of it. i tried. I don’t know how hard spaghetti can be. Even the McCormick dried seasoning stuff is better. My boyfriend got fried macaroni and cheese, which is pretty good and comes with barbeque sauce (a strange but tasty choice).
It was impossibly loud, and we came at about 10pm during the week… We saw our waitress a grand total of two times. We were both glad to pay the ticket and leave, to say the least.

Pretty good, as far as chains go, especially given the solid beer selection. Food was… fine. About what you’d expect really, Sodexo or related products, fine but not particularly good. I had a funky-​tasting Arnold Palmer… not sure what that was all about. Replaced with a perfectly fine diet coke though, so no real hard feelings there.

Two stars because they have some respectable craft beer one tap.
What else can I say, its a chain restaurant. Lots of screaming children, mothers who are yelling, and dads who are just there to have a good beer. I suppose it would be better later at night, but I’ll never know, I’ll stick to eating at local pizza/​burger joints.

Okay just recently went back and they have yet another new manager. I do not know her name but she is a young blonde chick.
Went to go use my gift certificate from my presviously bad experience there with the raw chicken. Sat at the bar with my hubby and friends. I didn’t bring my purse as I am not driving and I am in my 40’s so not like I have any getting carded issues… or so I thought.
After we sat at the bar we all got carded. I didn’t have my purse I was not driving nor paying the bill. I have some gray hair on my head and I to my sadness (lol) do not even look remotely close to someone 21. I have not been card in many a year and I have never been carded at this establishment. I was told she would not serve me since I didn’t have ID. She says they card any person that may be under 50. Now I may not had been so mad but a few people came in and were near the pool table. I knew one of this kids (23) talked to him on the way out as he had his tank of beer (the giant beer they serve) and asked him if he had gotten card he said nope!!!
I am done will never go there again… I ripped up the gift certificate I had received… we ordered nothing and left.

I passed by this place a few times and this place regardless of the time of day/​week seems to be busy. I just came back from eating here for the first time and we will be back! We waited about 10 min for our food. I ordered a Calzone *build your own* lot of cheese. It was delicious. You have the option of adding chicken for about a dollar more and that is what I did, but our waiter didn’t add it to our ticket so I got a side of chicken for free! Our waitress did a couple of «drive by» refills while we waited for our food to arrive. She was crazy very pleasant through the whole meal. The overall experience was great, but I’m sure that there are other restaurants here that easily compare to Old Chicago, but I like the staff and the goofiness’ there. We Will RETURN!!!

I go here late night on Saturdays with friends from church. It’s like the only decent place to go after 10 pm in Casper.
I like the atmosphere and the employees. They’re always upbeat and friendly. The food is delicious. The prices are reasonable, and if you really just want a snack, at 10 they start a happy hour menu which consists of wings, fries, mini-​pizzas, and a few others I can’t remember. If money isn’t an issue, I suggest the regular sized pizzas. They are filling and still, reasonably priced. They have some bomb-​digity sandwiches to.
They have sports on T.V.s all over the place, and ample seating. I can’t remember ever waiting for a table even when we showed up with a group of twenty. Don’t tell everyone, or this might change.