Don Anthonys Pizza and More

So I went here today for my first time based on a couple of recommendations. I am a Long Island italian transplant to Florida so I’m very skeptical of pizza joints… Wow, I was totally impressed! Me and my wife shared a rigatoni a la vodka that was great! We also got two slices that were really good. The rigatoni came with a side salad and garlic knots (which were delicious)!
The service was also extremely kind and on point! I will recommend this to everyone and will be back, often!

15.99 pizza and wings you can’t beat! Food taste fresh and definitely my goto in Cape Coral

First time coming here. We ordered their large 2 Topping pizza and 10 chicken wings special for $ 15.99. For the price you get your monies worth! Toppings were chicken and ham which they did not disappoint! Lots of Toppings, great crust cooked right. I wish the pizza had more tomato sauce as it did feel kind of dry. The chicken wings we got were teriyaki and they were delicious! We made an order of garlic knots and THAT was literally the BEST knots I’ve ever had! Definitely in the Top 5 category. We didn’t get a side of tomato sauce like most pizza restaurants serve but it just wasn’t needed. These knots are sooo yummy, the garlic sauce is smothered all over. Just wow! I’d come back just for those garlic knots LOL.

Not sure what has happened to this place, but the food & customer service has gone downhill. It took an hour and a half for a 45 minute delivery. Management gave us a verbal voucher for a free item on our next visit/​delivery. Called a couple weeks later to order pizza & sides and claim our free item and management claimed to have never given any discounts or free items to anybody ever. We finally got the free item, but food arrived late again. Pizza was made wrong and it wasn’t very warm either. Garlic knots were soggy. Bye Don Anthony’s-you’re not worth it and the choices are too many to continue giving you our business.

Got just a simple sausage pizza and it was great. The Greek salad was good too. They had Greek dressing which said to me that they take care of the little details. Good stuff. Will definitely order delivery from them again. Pizza was hot too!!!

loveeee DA!
Both the food and service never seem to disappoint. Do yourself a favor and order the garlic knots and a scalzone. This is fresh quality at it’s finest…

great prices, freindly staff, and most importantly great food

SOOOOO disappointing. I think my title reflects the poor judgement of the folks of SW Floridians.
I saw 8 reviews or so with 5 stars on Unilocal about Don. WOW what meds are they on.
I phoned my order in. I was told 45 minutes, five stars for the delivering EXACTLY on time
Now the food. It was brought to me luke warm. I did not expect super hot but at least better than luke warm.
Lets talk heat. I requested BBQ & HOT wings. The bbq was mild and sweet. Ok thats BBQ.
BUT hot wings is suppose to be HOT thats why they give a dressing on the side. These wings were a step above catsup. Terrible.
Now the standard for pizza. Pepperoni & mushroom. The pie had plenty of topping and looked really great. I thought the crust was a tad under cooked. A bit oily, But hey its pepperoni. The sauce was a plenty. A little too sweet and not enough oregano or garlic. .
Over all I will be passing on this place.

With the help of fellow Unilocalers, we found this place while vacationing in Fl. Sausage pizza was very good, crust was crispy and light and the chicken wings very meaty. When in the Cape Coral area again, we will make plans for another stop.

I’m not a big pizza fan but I have to say that this is a WOW establishment. We had a LG pizza, Wings and 2 drinks for 20.00. It not just was a good deal but tasted so oooooh good. If you’re a pizza lover then I do recommend this business. Oh yeah, the wings were grrrrrrrreat.

Best tasting pizza and more! Wings are delicious and the tomato pizza is super yummy. Good size servings too!

Pizza is fantastic and he doesn’t skim on toppings

Fantastic good crust on the pizza. The sauce just right. Spent 30 $ with tax and delivery and Wow! We got allot of food. SALAD was huge and fresh! Garlic knots were great. Sounded busy on the phone. Only had to say my order once and it was correct. Thats almost impossible anymore.