Pennie’s Bake Shop & Espresso Bar

My husband and I went to pennies and got cinnamon rolls and coffee we where so impressed we bought two more cinnamon rolls to go. very nice sitting area on comfy leather chairs where we were about to relax and chat

Great treats and amazing espresso.
Customer service is out of sight.
Parking is slim but not inconvenient enough to take away a star.

Perhaps it’s sacrilegious that I’ve never eaten cake from here (only cupcakes), but this is by far my favorite café in Butler.
Part of its charm is that it’s a business nestled in a residential community, rather than another storefront along Main Street. Knowing that mother and son do a lot of the customer service only adds to the cozy atmosphere.
As a regular customer, stopping by about once a week, I usually order a mix of specialty coffee drinks or sweets. A mocha latte drink with a salted caramel brownie or a cookie for takeout is a pretty typical order. Scones are also delicious, and I’d highly recommend the salted caramel cinnamon rolls if they’re in stock.
All of the baked goods are made fresh daily — sometimes they’ll have end-​of-​day specials to clear the shelves for the next day. Especially keep an eye for that on Sunday afternoons, since they’re closed on Mondays.
Biggest drawback: Parking is super limited. There is a small lot that fits about six cars. Others try to squeeze in other parts of the lot making it difficult to leave if you’ve parked there. I usually opt to park on the residential street nearby if the lot looks too chaotic.
All in all, though: If you’re in Butler, this is your best bet for a caffeine and sugar fix while supporting a locally-​owned business.

I met my sister here the other day for coffee and something sweet, it was fantastic! The people that work there are very friendly! My sister got the café mocha probably one of the best I’ve tasted, and I got the kona frappé it was really good like a chocolate milkshake! They bake all there products on site, they have an assortment of cupcakes, cookies, pastries, cakes, etc. They do wedding cakes also and all occasions ! They have these coconut cookies that are to die for if you like coconut! I also tried there cupcakes very good, I had the chocolate one, love the icing! I also tried the the chocolate cupcake with salted caramel icing so good! Probably my favorite!
They also have a nice deck with tables to sit at outside on nice days!