Tomatoes Pizza

The food is ok. I don’t eat there anymore because service is very horrible. I ordered delivery for my family about two hours before delivery service stopped and never got my food. I called to double check that my food would be delivered they told me it was on its way. I called back a little later they refused to deliver my food. I kept calling requesting to speak to a manager but I guess this establishment doesn’t employ managers or owners. I would give no stars if I could.

While there are a metric shit-​ton of pizza places in Buffalo, there are few that make a decent pie. A pie worth Unilocal’n about. One of those pizza spots is Tomatoes. The sauce is not too sweet, and the dough is not to thick. I ordered this for my moms repass, and they are the most professional people in the pizza delivery game.
During such a difficult time, it was nice to see that the pizza arrived on time. I ordered 200 wings in 3 different flavors and they were all fantastic (lemon pepper being my favorite). The pizza was also great. Sometime sheet pizza can be undercooked, but this was just what the doctor ordered!
My only thing is that we ran out of blue cheese, but that could be due to the people gobbling it up.
It wouldn’t have been a success without you. Great job!

This is sort of like calling a Pizza place Cheese Pizza or Bread Pizza, but having said that, I can’t think of a better name. It’s a bad neighborhood, but it’s a good pizza! This area is pretty run down, as is most of Kensington these days, but this is a good, and fairly cheap, Pizza place which is nice and crusty and saucy and well worth a try. It’s not in my top 20 pizzas in Buffalo by a long stretch, but is worth a try by all means! I’d like to also shout out to my friend Ski Mask that lives in these parts and tell him I miss him :)
It’s been a long time since I had it. There’s a lot of competition, because this city is the King of Pizza (I suppose New York would have a lot to say about that, but the two are both very different and equally delicious), so I wouldn’t put it in my top 10 slices. But it’s definitely delicious and worth a try.
I am going to give it a 5 because I remember really really liking it and it is definitely one of the cheapest slices and best value for money in the area. But bear in mind I haven’t had it in a few years. And it’s definitely not a sit down place.
Buffalo actually has the best Pizza in the world — check my «best Pizza in the world» list to see all the best Buffalo pizza places, lots of my choices are Buffalo based.