Tommy’s Famous Cheesesteaks & Pizza

Do not order delivery from here!
Food got there 20 minutes late and half our order was missing. Went to go find the delivery guy and tell him and he was PEEING IN FRONT OF THE APARTMENT! Food eventually arrived an hour late, cold, and gross. Beware if the delivery guy with the gold grill is delivering your food — he might just pee on your apartment!

Same old. Buyer beware. Ordered at 8:58, received notice after 10:30 it was just leaving the spot. Bear in mind a cheesesteak takes 5 minutes to make. To make matters worse, upon speaking with two female employees, I caught them both in two wildly inconsistent lies about what had happened and when I could expect my order. The second person was a manager and when told the situation said «Your order left mad long ago, sweety. It should be there soon.» should anyone expect a restaurant to say anything else in such a situation? «Then where is it?» «What?» «If it left ‘mad long ago,’ why isn’t it here?» «Oh, it left five minutes ago.» Really. «What happened to mad long ago?» «Oh, I wasn’t looking at my computer.» «Then why did you tell me ”mad long ago»? I pity this woman’s significant other with this level of dissemblance. And I asked for extra ketchup. Guess how much they sent me…
0.

Have had a lot of the same experiences mentioned in other low star reviews. Ordered last night, had a plain slice, spicy fries, and caesar salad. That was late last night. Around 5 am, I woke up needing urgently to use the restroom. Woke up around 6 am feeling nausea, but was able to keep things ok. At around 8am, I started projectile vomiting (I know, I couldn’t believe it was happening right in front of my face either, but there it was). It is currently 11am and I have not stopped feeling that nausea yet. I am currently missing a product launch because of having to stay home for this crap. Save yourself the heartache. Go anywhere else.

My husband ordered from here today, instead of Peppinos, I came home starving, took one bite of the «famous» cheesesteak, and had to spit it out. There was absolutely nothing good about it, the pizza was also very thick, I took one look at it, and closed the b

There slice of pizza taste very mediocre. Don’t know if I would come back. There are other spots in Park slope that are much better. Lenny’s pizzeria on prospect ave will always be my favorite spot for a go to pizza spot.

The best specialty slices ever! The buffalo chicken slice is my favorite lots of chicken and the spice is just right. Love the guy who runs the place super friendly and makes you feel at home. Definitely one of my favorite pizzerias. The cheesesteaks are the really good also.

Have ordered from Seamless only. Fast friendly delivery, everything on order delivered hot! Kinda unbelievably too hot. hope that pasta wasn’t micro-​nuked. That was my least fave – pasta is ordinary, feels store-​bought, meatballs burnt, salty, not displaying any tastiness other than «ordinary salty meatball». Mariana sauce was OVERFLOWING… also salty but I happily used the rest of that to sop up my slightly undercooked-​dough spinach roll. WHAT – rolls don’t come w/​sauce? Loved my cheesesteak w/​mushrooms, the bread is right on, the meat was tasty & plentiful. A good ‘ol, no fuss to stand out, an ordinary, solid, good plain cheesesteak to eat!
The Margherita Pizza – LOVELY ration of sauce/​mozzarella. Sauce somehow twice since I’ve ordered it, very salty, killing the sweetness balance I wanted from tomatoes. The crust – CRAZY – we all have our crust prefs but I LOVED this crust – doughy/​chewy, some parts crispy. Def not crunchy/​crispy if u like it like that! I go to That Crust Cuz I like it that way.
Roundup: good, simple, fast, no-​frills, no-​fancy. Still I liked it all.

Ordered one of Tommys «Famous» Cheesesteaks via GrubHub, with marinara sauce. Little did I know what I was getting myself into. As I ate the sandwich everything seemed fine. However when I awoke the next morning my body let me know that my Tommy’s Famous cheesesteak was something that it could not possibly keep down. I then began to retch and vomit at least half of the sandwich up. Mind you this was on a work day when I needed to get ready to go to the office. What I didn’t vomit out came out the other end — need i say more? For the next three days I suffered watery stool (picture your kitchen faucet on full blast) and vomiting to the point where my diaphragm was sore from the internal pressure of heaving. Be very careful when ordering from this place I can only imagine how clean their kitchen is. Caveat emptor.

I ordered a spinach artichoke pizza from here while visiting my mom and it was AMAZINGLY delicious. I can’t wait to order it again! We also ordered the croquettes and they were good

Delivery took about 2 hours, which was longer than expected and wasn’t offered anything in return for being so patient, the fries were a lil undercooked and I didn’t get the mayo or ketchup I asked for. But they cooked my burger PERFECTLY and in the end that’s what really mattered to me. Probably will order from here again for my cheeseburger fix.

This is a review for their delicious cheesesteak which I took to-​go (though the folks I spoke with while there were nice and helpful). A couple of friends of mine (one from Philly) recently went here and told me about it so I figured I’d try it out. It was straight-​up delicious!
First of all it looked to me like the cook (chef?) tossed a couple of ice cubes on the grill made up of beef bouillon to start things off. Once the bouillon was bubbling on went the steak (convincing as real-​deal sliced good steak). I ordered mine with onions and Cheese-​Whiz (that’s «Wiz Wit» for you cheesesteak fans out there and it is a traditional option). The rolls were so perfect we inquired and yes they have them delivered from Philly daily!
I ignored the pizza because I was on a mission but lemme tell ya; cheesesteak is on point!

We usually do Peppino’s for cheesesteaks, but they were closed, so we tried this spot. These may be famous but not in a good way. Hardly any meat and the saltiest cheese whiz spilling out all over the place. I have not tried their pizza so I can’t speak for that but if you want a cheesesteak in Brooklyn this is not the place. Take a train and go to Philly… But if you can’t make that happen but really want one, order from Peppino’s. The cheesesteaks are almost better than Philly especially if you like a nice crusty bread.

Great service and great patience I watched them deal with several drunk customers and they were great! Oh the Buffalo wings were great too

Roommate ordered the jerk chicken and plain pizza through Seamless to our apartment in Crown Heights. Pizza was below average, bread was extremely thick, almost like a roll. Here’s the kicker –I do not through single stars around liberally, I use Unilocal once every 6 months tops. They sent there delivery to our apartment in the freezing cold on his bike from park slope!!! One of the coldest, if not the coldest days of the year… extremely irresponsible. Had I known she was ordering from park slope, i would have canceled the order or expected the food to be delivered by car… wow. If i am somehow mistaken, and there is a second location closer, accept my apologies and this post will be removed…

Took more than an hour for delivery and when the food came they over charged me and made multiple mistakes with my order. Was told they were too busy to fix the problem and to ask for a credit next time I call. I will NEVER call again.

I’ve been ordering from this place for at least a year and it was good at first, but lately it’s gone down hill. I placed my order through Grub Hub and was very detailed about my order. Something as simple as no whip cream on the side of my cannoli doesn’t mean remove the cannoli cream and send me an empty shell. This happened on 2 different occasions. When I called in, the girl that answered had a terrible attitude and literally said, «what do you want me to do about it». Really? Sooooo you mess up my order and then give me attitude cause your «cook doesn’t speak english»? I asked for a refund or credit and she said no. When I asked to speak with the manager ahe said he’s not here and barely comes in.
I won’t be ordering from this place again.
A message to the owner — you should probably do yourself a favor and hire people that can actually speak and understand english seeing it that we live in the United States. You should also consider hiring staff that doesn’t have a fucking attitude problem and has an IQ higher than a slug.

DO NOT GO TO THIS ESTABLISHMENT.
THE WORST!!!
They probably had to write all the positive reviews they have because I have not met one person that had a positive expereience with them. They take an eternity for something like a salad, then they said that you didnt ask for chicken when you did and then when you ask for the chicken they say that they need to charge you for a salad.
OH! and ask for the manager??? HES NEVER THERE.
GO TO PEPPINOS DOWN THE BLOCK!!! The food is amazing and the staff is a beautiful italian family that is not just out for your money. They want to servce you quality food and a great experience.
******GIRL AT THE REGISTER IS THE NASTIEST PERSON ON STAFF AND DOES NOT WANT TO HELP YOU AT ALL.***** she should really think about switching careers because it has declined their business completely.
Obviously the pizzeria is empty everytime you go for a reason.

You wouldn’t think that Brooklyn would need another pizzeria but you’d be wrong. The six or seven times we’ve been there, my family has tried any number of the different types of pizza they offer and every one of them was absolutely delicious. My favorites are the Marguerite, the Buffalo Chicken and the Grandma. Up next, we want to try the cheese steaks, which look absolutely delicious. The place is clean and the staff is very friendly, efficient and accommodating. We are now regulars.

If you’re a cheesesteak fan, hit this this place up! I love all the different cheese options. I added special instructions to the order and they followed them perfectly. Reasonably priced and came in an equally reasonable amount of time. This was my first time and I will absolutely be back. They even have salads and panini’s, ya know… keep the wife happy while you dance with impending heart disease.

I came having a fit of the munchies while shopping and asked a cashier what a good stop for pizza was. She pointed across the street and so there I was, sitting in Tommy’s munching on a slice. The pizza was a decent NY slice, cheesy, a tad on the saltier side on the sauce and not on the sweeter side that I like, with a crust not too thin and not too thick. No crackle on the crust here. An okay slice, perfectly fine if you are in the nabe and not looking perfection. The place is long, very long, and more spacious than you would think towards the back.