Tokyo Bay Sushi

The food here is delicious and very reasonably priced. I order delivery often (I get bubble tea cravings, they are so good and they have great flavors) and I love the delivery guy! He’s very sweet. Sushi is good, I like the Ramen. Overall my favorite place for Japanese food.

Do not recommend.
I’ve been ordering from them and it was ok. Except one time when the food I ordered seemed not freshly made.
I attempted to order form them again today. And wanted the lunch special that was coming with regular salad. I asked if I could have a seaweed salad and I would pay the difference in price. And this lady on the phone was trying to charge me almost full price of another salad. I tried to explain that I don’t want 2 salads… And she was saying that if I want extra salad she will charge me for it because it’s lunch special. This annoyed me… I will never order from them again, given that the food was not fresh last time I ordered. But didn’t wanted to give them a bad review. I told her no worries and hung up. If you want to charge those money… Make sure you provide the service and food up to the standards. Disappointment.

There was hair in the rice. I won’t be ordering from there, again. The tuna roll wasn’t very good, either. I was eating it when my son pointed out the hair in his rice.

My husband and I on our weekend walks had walked by this place multiple times, and I had made it a mental note to give this place a fair try. Last week, a friend and I just finished working out at the NYSC gym nearby, and decided to try their dinner selection.
This place by the looks on the outside, seemed to offer more seating that what they actually have. It really better serves the purpose as a take out place. There are about 3 – 4 tables, and the sushi bar as soon as you walk in. The phone was ringing pretty often, so we sat down. The waitress, who was also what seemed to be the owner, was very nice and gave us the menus. They have buy one special sushi roll, you get the next one free, which can rack up the cash quickly.
We got the King Roll and the Black Dragon roll, which were both filled with spicy kani, shrimp, eel, and all of my other favorite things. They were pretty big to share for the two of us, and were filled with sauces. If you’re into the pure and simple sushi, I would not opt for these two rolls of choice. They were really tasty, and were fresh; I had no complaints at all! Then, we both got the dinner bento box of beef negimaki. For $ 15.95, you got your choice of entrée, shrimp and vegetable tempura, a California roll, fried vegetable dumplings, and white right. It was pretty filling, and we were barely able to finish, especially how hungry we both were.
I need to come here with the hubby for his seal of approval!

My go to Sushi place! Delivery is fast, the man who delivers is always so happy, and the food is delicious without being over priced. I’ve tried many other sushi places in Bay Ridge and Tokyo Bay is my favorite!

Great sushi, great noodle, great price. You can enjoy the buy one get one free rolls. We discovered new ways to eat maki. It was even open on Christmas

I wish I could put up no stars because this place is the WORST place I have ever ordered from. My gyoza were soggy and bit into something hard which had me disgusted. My udon chicken soup came with the noodles in a separate container which were hard and had a plastic taste. the soup had a horrible aftertaste to it and what was supposed to be chicken was some sort of rubbery object. The shrimp rolls had a strange smell to them and the miso soup taste like soap. I wouldn’t eat here if you paid me. Everything had a plastic taste to it. If you would like REAL, FRESH Japanese food DO NOT ENTER THIS PLACE.

$ 41 got us:
— Samurai Roll
— Eel Avocado
— California Roll
— Salmon Roll
— Salmon Teriyaki
— Edamame (complimentary if you spend over $ 30)
Everything was quite fresh, which surprised us. I am so excited to return in the future once again for more great grub. I don’t think they offer AYCE, but if they ever did, I’d be there in a heartbeat.
FYI, they have a promotion going on where they feature BOGO rolls. These rolls just come out to average pricing since they’re $ 15+ each.
We found parking easily enough immediately outside the restaurant. Décor is very simple, and the service is passable-​friendly. Several small tables are set out for the dining area, so it is not the kind of place where you would bring a large crowd.

Ordered a ton of sushi from this place. I always expect restaurants to mess up my order but it came out perfectly. Cheap prices but high quality. Not too much or too little rice. Friendly staff too. The miso soups are generous, other sushi places I’ve been to give a few sips of soup, but I almost couldn’t finish the one I had at Tokyo Bay it was so big! Got the house special fried rice as well and it was delicious. Not too much or too little rice on that one either :)!

If I could give them 0 stars, I would. I ordered via GrubHub. The food never came. I called an hour later, and the phone clerk said that the phone number was wrong. I asked why the delivery guy didn’t ring the bell. She didn’t know. I cancelled the order and ordered elsewhere. That delivery came back 15 minutes later, insisting test I pay for the food. When I asked why he didn’t rung there’ll. He said that someone might come out and kill him. Really? I live In a private home in Dyker Heights. He went I until Ito, d him no and closed the door on him. Never again.

Positives: Fast and friendly delivery. Good special rolls. Cheaper than other neighborhood sushi restaurants. Great dumplings.
Not positives: Lower than average regular rolls. Just not quite what they need to be (tuna was not fresh for example). Feels like corners are cut on a lot of stuff.
Give it a try, but don’t expect it to be your new fave.