El Milagro

Love this place; day of dead folk art; creative hand crafted jewelry; well organized & excellent customer service

This shop is a gem. Yes, it’s pricey. I wouldn’t expect to spend less than $ 30 here. But what you get is quality, and absolutely unique and beautiful. The owner and the staff are super sweet and always willing to help. MI GENTE!

The customer service here is extraordinary. If you are in a hurry and need assistance fast, you will not be disappointed. The items in this store are absolutely stunning. There’s jewelry to fit every price range. There is furniture and home décor, as well.

I went by El Milagro when I was in the neighborhood looking at apartments.
First, I do not know what the negative reviews are about. Definitely the décor of the store (which is under new management), is geared towards women and people interested in southwestern art/​jewelry/​décor.
I met the owner/​manager himself and his cute little dog and they were both very nice — the dog was a cutie and the manager let me try on a ton of earrings before I settled on one pair of silver earrings with a cool design and a very different look. The earrings came to $ 30, which is not that expensive in my opinion. Yes, they do have more expensive jewelry, but it is a matter of budgeting what you as the customer want to spend and not going above your limit. Clearly some of the jewelry is custom made and some of it is imported, so that should also factor into any decisions. As I regularly buy custom earrings for $ 20 or above, $ 30 is not super expensive for me.
Next time I am in this part of Park Slope I will definitely stop by again, they have a wide selection of items and, yes, they would probably have something that would make a very good present for someone, especially if I could get something on sale.

This is one of my favorite stores. I purchased some funiture here and cant stop staring at it. Its made in India and has the most amazing art-​work. Over the years, I picked up many interesting items here. The owner is very nice as well.

Where else can you find octopus earrings? Seriously.
Their prices are a little steep, but their selection is great and truly unique. They also have fantastic sales, so it’s definitely a great place to swing by for special occasions.

Expensive. No real value here.

I absolutely adore this store. From jewelry to neat gifts, this store is the epitome of what shopping in Park Slope is like. I’ve gotten some really great stuff here for holiday and birthday gifts, and some cute stuff for myself to boot! The staff here is great, and will always help you figure out what you need (or want).

Hands down my favorite jewelry store in NYC. I always find something beautiful, unusual AND reasonably priced in here. I often wish I didn’t walk by twice a day ’cause there is constantly something new in the window display that I just HAVE to have. Sometimes I think that I work just to keep this store in business. Staff is friendly AND knowledgable. I have friends in Manhattan and Long Island that make it a point to pop into El Milagros whenever they are visiting me and they rarely walk out empty handed.

Great store. Beautiful variety, friendly staff and great prices.