Ben Bay Realty Co

I recently made a big move from Chicago to Brooklyn. I had been researching areas in Brooklyn for months, but was still intimidated by the whole process. After reading a review on here about Maria, I contacted her and we set up a time to meet. I’m very happy I did so.
I only had 1 week to visit Brooklyn before heading back to Chicago to finish up my previous job. I was worried about the quick trip, but Maria was great to work with– she was quick to respond, quick to get and complete paperwork, and very understanding of my different situation (moving from far, having limited time, having a pet, being a grad student, etc.). She also took the time to explain to me things that were different here than in Chicago in regards to neighborhoods and apartments, which I really appreciated. Most importantly, I had all the paperwork done for an apartment by the time I left town and everything went smoothly!
I really like my new apartment and am very happy that I contacted Maria at Ben Bay. I’d definitely recommend her to anyone moving into the area!

My daughter rented an apartment that was listed on Ben Bay Realty, and we were very happy with the experience. Anthony Bottalico showed us the apartment. He was very professional, knowledgeable, and friendly. Their office staff was very kind and accommodating while signing the lease. I highly recommend Anthony and Ben Bay Realty.

My husband and I recently sold our Brooklyn apartment through Ben Bay and are happy with the outcome. Last winter we were looking for a real estate broker and I came across a magnet on our refrigerator that had Ben Bay’s contact information. I called and made an appointment with Charles Fabbella.
Our impression of Charles after meeting him was that he is an experienced broker and works hard to get the job done. We had met with other brokers from Century 21 Demasi and other companies but Charles was the most professional and helpful. He never asked us to change the way we live by clearing out the apartment to show it to potential buyers. It was very important to us that we were able to go about our normal routines and live life everyday while showing the place.
We were so glad that we decided to work with him. Charles was always available to answer any questions we had and he sold our coop apartment in a very short amount of time. The whole process was seamless and straightforward.

I have been stressing for 2 weeks about finding a new place. I called Ben Bay and spoke with Maria. She asked me to come meet her, which I did. I spoke with her for about 15 minutes and told her exactly what I was looking for. Two days later, she called me and told me that she had found something that she thought I would like. I went to take a look and fell in love with the place. She found EXACTLY what I was looking for and even managed to talk the landlord down a bit.
If you’re looking for a place and want someone who will work hard and fast, while not sitting on her butt making you wait — — ASK FOR MARIA! She was awesome and I’m extremely happy with our new place.

Simply the best. After MUCH looking on my own, I walked into Ben Bay Realty on Sunday, late afternoon and I was greeted by James. Let me tell you, he was amazing!
I had been working with other agents that were not helpful and James was the complete opposite. He was charming, intelligent and extremely helpful.
I met him on Sunday, made an appointment to see apartments on Tuesday and I am signing the lease to my new apartment next week.
James showed me two apartments before I fell in love with the third. He organized a meeting with the landlord at his office, he always made sure we were comfortable and even vouched for me (told the land lord I was a great person etc.). He was always available when I needed help, just a text away.

I find Ben Bay to be an interesting case study. As a buyer and someone that has paid close attention to the Brooklyn real estate market, I always cringe whenever I see the Ben Bay sign on any property. For anyone that has done their homework they will find that Ben Bay has consistently priced their property grossly above market value. This may have worked in Bensonhurst with the influx of Asian buyers during the boom era, but they’re doing a disservice to the Bay Ridge sellers who lists with them only to find their properties sitting on the market going stale. All that they’re doing is make their comps look good. It’ll be interesting to follow the development of this company in the Bay Ridge market.

While my wife, 6 month old son, and pet were looking for a place to rent in Ba Ridge when we stumbled upon Ben Bay Realty on 3^rd Ave. We walked in and met with Maria who was able to find us a 3 Bedroom, with yard, in walking distance to the train, all under budget.
Maria was great and I would recommend her for anyone looking for a rental in the Bay Ridge area!