Broadway Pizza & Pasta

Soggy slices and sour, slimy mushrooms, my pizza was falling apart no matter how carefully I tried picking it up. Those «garlic knots» were literally dinner rolls with dried parmesan on top. Despite being difficult to eat, the taste wasn’t completely inedible.
However, customer service here is a wreck. Despite physically coming in here to order my food, they completely forgot to call my order when it was done. So what should have been a 15 minute wait turned into a 40 minute wait after we finally came up to ask about it. My bad for being patient, I guess.
Other than it’s generous late-​night convenience, there’s no real reason to come to this pizza joint. It’s pricey, the pizza and service sucks, and there are so many other pizza joints on the street.

Solid plain slice, wasn’t terribly impressed with the grandma slice which was essentially Sicilian with big chunks of tomato. Certainly not bad, I would definitely stop by to try some of their other choices. Service was pretty quick, nothing to be overly dramatic about.

Road to 2016 #1
This coming from the Bronx in the Kingsbridge area, when i think of a family owned pizza shop, I think of this place! this is my neighborhood pizza shop I always get pizza from so to pay my respect to this place I thought of placing this review showcasing how good this family owned shop is!
«Pizza… want more pizza»
they have an assortment of pizza and you can basically have any topping you desire (just ask and they will exceed your expectations!) pricing is very reasonable, for a plain slice of pizza it is about 1.75 and if you like extra cheese (my suggestion for those who have those munchies in) its about 2.75 and man the pizza comes out nice and fresh from the oven and you see the cheese ooze out with greatness on your plate. you know its a good pizza when the oil is trying to escape the plate.
«the people»
depending on the time you take this trip to this pizza shop will determine your experience here, reason being some of the employees could have attitudes so bring a space of headphones and your phone so you can tone them out. sometimes the Bronx way can be a bit rough.
overall
this is a wonderful spot for pizza with lost of family history and the history is shown in the way they make their pizza.

I Personally Work At A Pizzeria And I Still Come Here Because of One Specific Slice… The Goodfella Slice… The combination of broccoli, tomatoes and chicken is simply the best… i enjoy every moment i go to eat my slice… Friendly Staff and Recommend it to everyone…

Monday afternoon, after shopping, I was craving pizza… I popped into Broadway Pizza shop and discovered a great new to me place…
Fresh out of the oven, Mom and I both enjoyed a plain slice. Simply the best: fresh crispy crust– folded in ½ and it held it’s own for each and every bite of tasty cheese and real Italian pizza sauce!

3 stars! Not four or five as I used to feel about this place. 3 reasons:
My delivery took FOREVER to get here. (An hour an a half opposed to the usual 45 mins tops.)
Ordered for delivery to my business in Dyckman, and delivery man was pretty rude. While receiving the order, he complained that it is very far and even questioned if anyone had delivered my food here. Mind you, I’ve delivered countless times from this place with no problem.
Phone girl was a sweetheart (as usual) but unfortunately RAPED me for a chicken-​less Caesar salad ($ 10) for a handful of lettuce with some shitty stale croutons and carrot shavings. WHAT!
Fettuccine chicken Alfredo was extremely oily, pasta was overcooked and slimy.
Seriously Broadway Pizza, the food used to be way better. I don’t know what happened man…
Until they improve their service and quality of food, I won’t be ordering from here for a while.

This is some of the worst NY pizza I’ve ever had. It’s really very easy to get NY pizza right (it’s another thing to get it very right), but my slice here was the first time in a lifetime of living in New York that I encountered stale crust. They probably don’t keep their pizza fresh. Avoid.

Pizza here is not bad. Not that good tho. But what bothers me most is the prices! The prices dont match the quality of food u get. For 2 slices and 2 cans of soda i paid 10 $! That ridiculous! And the people that work there are rude. Wont be coming back unless prices drop! Too expensive!

For some odd reason, the pizza taste better when it’s delivered to my house. Also, I tried the chicken ziti parmesan for the first time the other day and I was disapointed. $ 15 dollars for that?

I was going to give it 5 stars, but then I remembered how horrible it can be after 2:30. When all the kids come out of school, it’s a total mess.
Some people are taking chairs from other tables so it will leave you with one chair at a table. I usually HAVE take the food to go. The food is delicious. Just wish it would expand. Delivery depends on where you live. Sometimes they feel like delivering to me, and sometimes they don’t & I live on Heath. Go figure.

This place has horrible customer service. I had place an order for delivery and after waiting patiently for over an hour, I called to check on the delay. The lady insured me that the food was on route and that it should be there any minute so I waited. A few minutes after we hung she called back to inform me that the food was brought back because «no one answered the door». Meanwhile no one called and/​or rang the door bell … So I told her to just cancel the order and to place the money back on my card. She insisted on sending the food back out with an attitude and since I refused she replied with sarcastic remarks. I normally never write a negative review but I do not appreciate rudeness and the fact that she threaten to write my apt number down to refuse serving me again.

Decent enough pizza and friendly staff but this place always seems a bit run down and dingy.
I wouldn’t complain about eating here but I wouldn’t seek it out either.
The pizza prices are a bit high too.

I drop in here from time to time to order pizza and other items for take-​out. The service is great. The two ladies behind the counter are friendly and the pizza makers are always happy. Food is always cooked the way I like it.

What the hell?
Went there not too long ago to get a slice and I had to take out a second mortgage. If I was on a date and he paid I know that I would have been obligated to give him the goodness, that’s how expensive it was. now I’m expecting some damn good pizza for a the money I paid but lo and behold it was garbage. The sauce was non existent, the cheese wasn’t melted, I’ve had way better slices for $ 1. Never again and also there were flies everywhere. If you want to throw away money and get less than mediocre food this is the place to go

A little neighborhood spot near the subway that serves an ok slice with friendly service. There are 6 tables that seat 4 and an island in the center where you can grab napkins & condiments. My slice had a nice thick crunchy crust, but there was an odd aftertaste either in the sauce or the cheese. My boys enjoyed the food here, but I’ll try another pizza place the next time I get a craving.

I ordered from this place with some consistency from 2007 — 2012. I see several other reviews which indicate that this place can be hit or miss. Perhaps I was lucky enough to have almost all hits.
If you’re going to have pizza from this place, drop in. The pizza is fresh, hot, and ready to go in a hurry. There’s usually a crowd so nothing hangs out for very long. I’ve had regular, sicilian, white, and buffalo chicken slices and they’re all good.
For delivery, they’re more miss than hit. I’d advise against it altogether. If you’re dead set on it, make sure you order at least an hour ahead and get your toaster oven ready to crisp up those soggy slices.

They put that annoying fan that blows the sent of pizza into the street. I feel sorry for the people at the bus stop. Use to be the best back when they had the 2 dollar special now its average at best. Its not bad at all just average.

Just placed an order for pickup and there was hair in the pasta.
When i went to take it back the owner goes «mistakes happens it gets busy in here» hair should not be happening in my food.
Horrible !

Loved the pizza. Keep up the good work!

The best veggie pizza ever… I have been going to this place forever. And I have never had any complaints for the veggie slices to plain to eggplant parm. The staff as always been pleasant and inviting. Great family neighborhood eatery!!!