58 Main

It was good food, but didn’t «wow» us. The pulled pork mac ‘n cheese was a little light on the cheese flavor and didn’t have a lot of pulled pork in it. The buffalo-​style ribs appetizer with the blue cheese was great! Both dishes were really heavy on the salt. Service was fast and the atmosphere is good.

Great food, I recommend the garlic Parmesan fries. Excellent servers and bartenders. Great entertainment and a beautiful outdoor space. Lots of TVs to watch any sport you might like. Great ownership and very clean establishment!

Great bbq food (the best in the area), friendly attentive service, fun events and specials like trivia/​wing night/​paint nite/​food specials/​live music, and newly renovated family section. You won’t be disappointed! It’s usually packed because of all the specials and events but it’s well worth the wait.

Visited 58 Main St. last week and both my wife and I had an enjoyable time. We went for a 2:00pm lunch and there were just a few patrons at the time. Our service was good and the waitress very helpful in helping understand the menu. We had BBQ dishes, the chicken was good, moist and flavorful. The ribs, good but could have been a bit more tender but tasty. The sides were amazing, these are all homemade and you can tell right away. If you’re looking for some nice options for BBQ or otherwise I would recommend 58 Main, I know I’ll be going back again.

58 main is one of my favorite places to eat in Brockport. They often host live music on weekends which brings a big, friendly crowd. Every time I go I order the buffalo chicken wrap and fries which brings me joy. Their pulled pork nachos is a yummy appetizer! They host a lot of great specials during the week and coupons in the mail! Their rum buckets are delicious. This place is more of an older crowd which makes for a relax, fun setting. I love it here!

They will be out of business Soon. I’ve never seen more than 10 people there at once! Also, it smells like cat pee :(

Clean, great service, good prices and excellent food! I’m looking forward to our next visit!

We made a pit stop here on our way back from Canada. It was really good!
Nice staff, great food and not crazy priced. I would definitely suggest it to anyone in the area!

I hosted a wedding rehearsal dinner there recently. 1. When calling to confirm a week before they knew nothing of the reservation. Turns out they had my name down wrong. After that was fixed I though OK… one little thing. No big deal. 2. We got there and the room wasn’t ready for us. 3. I watched as the servers stood there looking at me… sitting in a booth… no beverage… Nothing. Did I mention I was in the service industry for 15 years? 4. Everything I touched in the place was sticky. I took a shower when I got home. 5. We couldnt take home $ 100 worth of food because of some nys «law» which I have never heard of. Point being, I was not informed of this when I ordered the food weeks ahead. If I knew this I would have ordered half. Lastly, 6. Most of the food we were served was actually OK… except mine. I ordered a buffalo chicken sandwich fried. It turned my stomach at first bite. They served me what seemed liked a pounded out chicken they would have used with the chicken French. This place was so bad I broke my cherry on Unilocal.Don’t go there. Thanks.

Got a pulled pork sandwich with beans and coleslaw. The slaw was okay but the beans and pulled pork were some of the best I’ve eaten. If you can eat it all you won’t have to eat breakfast in the morning — you will still be full. Fair price, nice service and totally recommended.

Good food. Great specials everyday of the week. Food portions are very big and a good value. I would go back.

Great brunch. Brisket and eggs delicious. Try the biscuits and gravy as well. Definitely a must try. It’s great to have a change up from the standard diner breakfast.

Good food… Good drinks…
Definitely will come back
of you are in the area… Come eat here

Always a go to when I’m in Brockport. Always has great food and service.

Love the food. I think the atmosphere is neat because the front is 50’s diner style and the rear is more modern and sports bar style.
It could use some maintenance though. The building is old and it shows inside in some areas with the lack of upkeep. Namely in the area by the wooden booth nooks between the front and rear dining areas.