Dominick’s Pizza

BIG pizza fan but not a big Dominick’s Pizza fan unfortunately. The pizza is just «alright».
On some days the crust is perfect, some days its too dough-​y. Their pre-​made pies on the counter have all your classic toppings but never anything new or creative.
Guys at the counter are always friendly. They’ll even deliver your slices or sandwiches to the table once they’re ready, which is a nice touch. I was a regular here for some time… until I became disappointed with one of the guys at the counter who rushed the reheating process of my pizza every day at lunch.
They have a solid mushroom slice and their cheesesteaks aren’t bad either. I’ve tried their eggplant/​ricotta slice which was delicious when served crispy and hot. Decent plain slice too!
Sometimes the mozzarella cheese they use doesn’t sit right in my stomach. Tried their chicken parm sandwich once and the cheese smelled very pungent. Ended up throwing away most of the sandwich since it tasted off.
They sit at the corner of a small strip mall, making it a convenient stop for shoppers. They recently remodeled their dining area and it’s much more cozy now.
Dom’s Pizza was my go-​to pizza spot in the area for quite some time. but I’ve since moved on.

Ziti pizza was very good, but wasn’t heated up all the way. Tasted great either way.
We’ll be back.
Could use a facelift inside, but whatever.

People complaining about cleanliness… Go to Italy and order a pizza. Guarantee those guys don’t clean or wash there hands for a week yet the pizza is still the best. Americans are to soft. Great pizza.

Pizza is just okay. The reason for the one star, is how grossed out I was before I left. The guy behind the counter touching the food and everything else with his bare hands. I don’t care if his hands are clean, but there’s no way they could be if he’s handling money, wipes his face and his hands on his pants. The worst was when he used a wet towel clean his hands the used it to wipe down the surface areas. GROSS!!!

Pizza was excellent, they made one to order and it was so good! Fast service too!

This has been my favorite pizza for 15 years! Perfect thin crust pizza, handmade from fresh ingredients. You can see them making each pie by hand, and there’s always a big variety to choose from. They do take-​out too.

Pizza was good, especially since they got the order right. Cheese pizza, extra sauce or light cheese (whichever) and lightly baked. Bring it home and pop in oven to crisp and it’s perfect. Good pizza isn’t buried in cheese!

The pizza is good but once I called in a order and when I got there to pick it up he didn’t have the order. He said «oh I must have given it to someone else» so he put one of the pies that have been sitting out on the counter for god knows how long in the oven and gave that to me. First of all that’s gross and second of all he never said sorry or offered me anything for the inconvenience. He actually made it seem like it was no big deal that he gave someone else my order. Never went back after that and probably never will!

I ordered a pizza, they said 10 – 15 minutes, I send my boyfriend to pick the pizza up. Boyfriend calls and says «uhhh are you sure you placed an order here because they say they never received a call» I verified the number with him an everything. I called the number again asked them what happened to my order they said they had no such order offered to make one real quick. Seriously? No apologies or anything? You’re just gonna assume I’m some crazy whacko who never called. Never again will
I order from these people again. Whoever took my order must not have cared enough to write it down.

best pizza around! It really is the local hot spot with great, friendly service! They just renovated the place and it looks amazing. No where else compares!

The pizza here is good. Came here tonight for the first time in 6 months and noticed that they re-​did the inside so now it looks more «restaurant like» and less like a pizza pit-​stop. The man who always rings me up isn’t the friendliest guy but he isn’t rude either. I don’t find him to be insulting & I like their food so I give this place a thumbs up. Little more pricey than I’d like though… Paid $ 6 for a slice of veggie and a bottled drink.

All the people leaving One Star ratings obviously do not know what a REAL ITALEAN Pizza place is. People Complaining about employees «not wearing gloves» and «touching money before handling food». First of all, Real Italeans DO NOT wear gloves, especially not while preparing food. If the wear gloves, how can they get close to the pizza and give it the Italean flair? Second, everyone knows that any good Italean Business owner should count his wad of cash every 1 – 2 hours to keep track of his earnings, as well as to show off his success. If you want a true Italean Pizza experience, go to Dominick’s, you wont be disappointed.
— the connoisseur of Gabigool

Smallest Sicilian slices I have ever seen. Food has no taste and counter guy was rude. No «thank you» after paying. We went here once before and had similar experience. Two bad experiences is enough to know that this is how they do business.

The pizza is very dry and tasteless and the people that work here are always nothing but rude.

One of the best stuffed pies in the area. Other pizza always looks dried out and over cooked.

Probably the best pizza in the area after trying just about every place near by. The ony reason it doesnt get 5 stars is for 2 reasons. For a pizza place it’s pretty unreasonably expensive. Its about $ 4 for a slice of pizza that isnt big. The other reason is its pretty much required that youre an a**hole to work there. Years ago there was this spanish guy who was pretty nice, other than that there has never been a kind soul working there. Which is kind of weird for a pizza place

I’ve been going to this place for years not often but for decades. I always liked their product and never really had a problem. I went in today cuz I had a hankering for mozzarella sticks. I witnessed one of the managers/​owners? take his finger tip, put it in ricotta that was on top of a slice of pizza and flick it to another slice of pizza. I don’t know what he was attempting to do, get a hair out or something but it was really disgusting. I was the only customer in there and I was standing right there in front of the counter watching the whole thing and he didn’t even try to cover it up which makes me think he thinks it’s not disgusting and he thinks its normal. Next he needed cash cuz they were only open maybe an hour so he goes over to the other manager? and that guy digs in his pocket for the cash, handles the cash, and then continues to put his hand in a bowl of mozzarella to make a pizza, no gloves. Third and final when I get home I realized they put the piping hot marinara sauce in the BPA plastic disposable container which preceded to melt and disfigure which opened the lid and poured all over the mozzarella sticks making them disgusting and soggy. I go there because these mozzarella sticks are a particular brand, the best and no one really carries them. But now I have chosen after these three disturbing accounts in one visit, I will not be returning. I understand I’m only one customer out of thousands but I was a return customer and customer service needs to be respectful again I don’t know what has gotten into these places lately. Somebody please tell me where I can find good customer service with cleanliness? Is that too much to ask?

Pizza wasn’t too bad. Considering there’s a pizza joint on every block. We normally use Italian restaurants in the area to place large orders for our organization. In almost every instance, places are eager to earn our business and establish a relationship for future business. They offer savings and compensation for placing such an order. This place wasn’t having that. I called, asked to speak to the manger, and he said no so fast I was shocked. I had to ask him to repeat his answer. Not very good business man if you ask me. he could have easily said I’ll throw in cups, ice and plates and I would have been happy. Doesn’t take much. But this manager truly ruined my experience to do future business here as well as my organization. I am a manager myself, that isn’t how you talk to future potential business. We simply took our business down the road from them and got delicious pizza delivered to us. We will continue our business with organizations that know how to conduct a real business.

Called to place an order for my party and got the nastiest rude attitude. You get a 1* for poor business etiquette and lack of professional mannerism. Should probably train your staff to be courteous, I’m a customer service manager and it funny how another customer of yours referred me to you. I would never recommend your business to any of my friends or family.

Grew up in the area but now live in Colorado. Came here on business and *had* to have the Jersey pizza experience. Great no nonsense Jersey pizza place. 5 stars for that. Didn’t have any of the other foods — seriously why bother. Til next visit…