Renzo’s Cafe & Pizzeria

We called for delivery. They do not — DO NOT — have a menu to fax, email, or to view online. How can we try it and order? Through osmosis!!!
When the food arrives, it was wonderful! Loved the pizza and Stromboli!

We got take out pizza and wings. Everything came out really hot and right on time.
Wings were very very good. Pizza was also good, but a little too greasy. But still good.
Owner was there and very friendly.
We would go back.

This place deserves more credit than some of these reviews. I recently moved here from New York and have been SO dissapointed with the pizza south florida has to offer… until now.
Not only is the pizza amazing, crispy, thin, with a slightly chewy crust. but the ingredients are fresh and the restaurant is a family oriented place. I haven’t tried the rest of the food yet but the pizza is a must. Will become my regular order out p

I decided to give Renzo’s another try. I am happy to report that some changes have been made. The tables now have tablecloths and cloth napkins. My server was very attentive but not motherly. The music was now Italian style and not Spanish. It made the place feel more like a restaurant than a pizzeria which was one of my observations the last time.
This time, I went on a Tuesday night. There was only one other table occupied when I arrived, and once again there were no take out orders or deliveries in the hour that I was there.
That was very surprising, considering on Tuesday nights they offer a $ 6.99 special on a medium cheese pizza
I went back because the calzone I had last time was good, & I had a craving for another. This time I had it filled with sausage and pepperoni, and I asked them to put in a spoonful of sauce on the inside as well. Again, the marinara sauce served on the side is something they could bottle.
I have upgraded my review from 3 to 4 stars for the improvements made to make it look more like a restaurant than a pizzeria, and for the very attentive service I received. More accurately, I would call at three and a half stars., I would be apt to go back.

Very nice family and friend place to have very delicious pizza.
If you want a place to go eat with family and enjoy each other’s company or if you are on lunch and wanna swing inside for a quick bite this place has the flavor and ambience
Very friendly staff
We ordered a classic cheese pie and it has very nice flavor
Then the deep dish and it came out great as well.
The wings were crispy and evenly flavored
Very accommodating.
They light up the plaza
This plaza would be dead without this place haha
Why does Unilocal ask me to write so much?
Anyways this place is my new pizza joint in town

Incomplete. We stopped there around 4PM and they didn’t have any pizza nor was there any offer to make us pizza. Weird! Being generous with 2 stars. Place looked like it could have been good… if only they had food.

I think for pizza they’re awesome, but we didn’t like the panninis, very dry, or the wings.

Went to Renzo’s last night fantastic! Best pizza I’ve had in a long time it’s hidden away on Boynton Beach Blvd where the Blockbuster used to be I would’ve never known it was thereif I didn’t pull in the plaza. Food was great service was perfect I’ll be going back again.

BAD Business! We have ordered from Renzo’s quite frequently. Today they screwed up our order for take out, we only realized this once we got home. We called immediately to tell them & to have the order corrected. They would only do so if we paid for another order! I think NOT! In my book that is bad business & I will never be back to this establishment! Just plain wrong! Zero ethics! #neveragain

Great food, great service with an awesome staff! Huge slices of pizza for such a great deal. You must try this place if your ever in Boynton

Decent for Florida standards? I don’t know. Would I ever eat this if it was available in NY? No way. It’s way too expensive for mediocre pizza. Why can’t we have NY style pizzerias where you can walk in a grab a slice and maybe some chicken rolls and rice balls for less than $ 5? This place tries really hard to be a fancy restaurant and that’s not what pizza is about. I order here sometimes cause it’s close but the prices deter me from visiting frequently.

The experience I had here was from a one time only visit, so I am writing based solely on that.
I noticed Renzo’s opened up in my old favorite pizza spot (still crying about that place closing its doors). I decided to order their $ 12 18″ cheese pizza special on a Tuesday afternoon. I picked it up and noticed that they updated the pizza location a bit. Instead of feeling casual as the two previous places once did, it was updated with some fresh paint and white linens placed on the tables.
I grabbed my pizza and took it home to enjoy with the other half. As excited as I was to have delicious pizza, I was disappointed. There was WAY too much cheese. And I love cheese. So much so that the pizza was very chewy. The crust was crispy, but the dough underneath the cheese was not. On top of that, the pie lacked sauce and some of the cheese on the slices tasted strange. Very offputting.
As for right now this place stands at 2 stars for me. I may try them out again to see if it gets any better, but not sure I want to have another pizza tasting like that again.

Ok, a quick history of my experience with «Renzo’s». I went to one of them years and years ago down in Boca. That was terrible. So long ago (before Unilocal and many online reviews) that I dont remember specifics. I do remember sweating like a stuffed pig in there. And I remember that the food was «OK» but after you factor in the rave reviews… it become not so «OK». So, I saw that they were opening up in Boynton and I live there so I figured I would try their pizza. Oh, my. I felt like it was my first time experiencing terrible Florida pizza again when coming home from visiting NY. Wowzers. I seriously needed to reach into my mouth and pull the «cheese» out to make sure that I actually did in fact have cheese in my mouth because it had no taste. I have had homemade mozzarella. I’ve had bad mozzarella. You name it, I have had it so I know how sometimes your mozzarella can be a little «light» on flavor. Nope. This wasnt light. This stuff tricked my taste buds into thinking nothing was in my mouth. There was nearly no sauce on it either. Luckily the bread was not dry. Pass this one up. And if this guy does Boynton like he did Boca, there will be another Renzo’s at the next intersection. I’m not joking. Google «Renzo’s Boca». He has two of them 9 blocks away.

Just got done devouring a yummy Margherita pizza! Definitely up with New York pizza. My wife an I have been researching for good pizza in Florida, and this is definitely the best yet. Even though we just had the pizza to go, the staff seemed really nice. We highly recommend Renzo’s in Boynton Beach!