Sweet Tooth

I gave Sweet Tooth a try this week because my usual bakery (Party Favors) was closed for the week. We ordered a beautiful baby shower themed cake and it was amazing! I’ve never seen every slice at a party finished before, people were asking for seconds. It truly tasted homemade. The cake was moist, the icing sweet but not overpowering, and the raspberry mousse center was the perfect touch. I expect to be using them again and would recommend to anyone looking to wow the party with a perfect cake.

We went to buy a cake from this shop but we went to 371 W Broadway area. We went there Jan 02, as this was my hubby’s birthday. Nothing special with the cake. We don’t mind paying for food, we don’t care about the price but 55 for a small cake that tasted old… I didn’t expect this from this shop. We drove all the way from Brampton just to buy a cake form there because our friend recommended it, but there was hazelnut cake available that day and I told my husband, will buy it since we’re already there.
We decided to order a coffee and a slice of cake and the macaroons. The macaroons were so hard, like hard rock that I have to ask the server to change it. I mean the macaroons from whole foods were a lot better from this shop. The cake that we had in the shop, was really good but then when we came home, and try to eat the cake with the kids… the hazelnut cake tasted like moldy (as what my kids say). We had to throw the whole cake… we are not driving back all the way to 371 W Broadway to return it… and waste our time and gas… But lesson learned, never again we are going to buy from this shop. I am still hopeful that maybe the other location is way better than this one…

They were too busy to email me back or call me back. It took them a week to respond. Ended up getting my cake somewhere else

I have a love affair with the cookies… no joke.
My husband and I used to love a block away from Sweet Tooth and it was and STILL is our go-​to bakery! When we were planning our wedding it was a no brainer that we wanted Glenn to make our wedding cake. We had a 3 tiered cake with the bottom layer as inside out boston cream, middle layer was fudge chocolate w cream cheese pb filling, and the top was red velvet w cream cheese filling. It was finished in buttercream. It was UNREAL. The best wedding cake I have ever had, and I had many compliments. Although the cake was delicious the mini cookies Glenn made were my favorite. If you have not had a cookie from this bakery yet you have not lived. We served mini chocolate chip, white chocolate peanut butter chip and oatmeal. My mouth is watering just thinking about them. Glenn delivered the cake and the cookies all the way from Boston to the Cape himself and threw in some bonus cupcakes just for the bride and groom .
Even though we currently live in Atlanta, I plan on ordering his cookies for the upcoming holiday season and just to have some in my freezer. Glenn is very talented and was just a pleasure to work with and so is his staff. I love sweet tooth and am forever a loyal customer!

After frequenting this bakery when I lived in Southie years ago, and ordering birthday cakes for my now husband from here, it was a no-​brainer that Glenn would do our wedding cake.
Our wedding cake was beautiful AND delicious. I had never eaten good wedding cake, until Glenn did our cake. We did a 4 tier cake with 3 flavors. Chocolate cake with chocolate ganache filling, vanilla cake w French pastry cream and fresh strawberry filling and carrot cake with cream cheese filling. All finished in vanilla buttercream. My husband and I were able to split a piece of the carrot cake quickly and it was DELICIOUS. Glenn personally delivered our cake from Boston to Providence and arranged the flowers on it that were left by the florist. The cake looked even better than I had imagined. Glenn is an absolute sweetheart, he even left us a box to take home at the end of the night w 2 cupcakes in it (We ate them for breakfast the next day and they were so good).
We received countless compliments on our cake.
I can’t wait to eat the top tier on our one year anniversary! I will have to stop in before that to pick up some of their delicious cupcakes and other pastries, and of course to say hi to Glenn. Best bakery in Boston, actually best bakery I’ve ever been to, ANYWHERE.

I cant say enough about Glenn and his bakery! I needed a birthday cake for a friends party and had no idea what to ask for theme wise, He came up with a beautiful/​fun/​classy idea and the cake was AMAZING. I had people telling me it was the prettiest cake they had ever seen, (they were right) and it tasted as good as it looked. The birthday girl texted me the day after her party and said it was in fact the best cake she had ever tasted. I wish I had a pic to post! Also I will mention that they were running late on the pick up time and Glenn called me himself to see if I would need it delivered instead. Now that is customer service! Thanks Sweet Tooth for exceeding my expectations in every way.

They have Great red velvet cupcakes amongst other treats. They have seasonal flavored like the pumpkin flavored whoopie pies and cookies. The prices are worth every bite. They also make custom cakes. Customer service is always Awesome!

Thank you very much guys! My daughter had a great party with a beautiful, delicious and lovely cake! The price is also great. Unforgetable moment we had. I am satisfied. My fav cake store in Boston. Will never go anywhere for custom birthday cake

Glenn is incredible! Honestly, we weren’t sure about spending a lot of money on a cake for our wedding, but after meeting Glenn we were sold! He was friendly, enthusiastic, and so great at collaborating with us to come up with ideas about our cake.
We were originally supposed to get married in April, but I was hospitalized right before the wedding so we had to postpone it to June. The bakery had no problem with re-​scheduling our cake and did so for free and without any complaints at all.
The cake itself was amazing! It came out exactly as I imagined it… if not even better! It was a HUGE hit at the wedding and our guests devoured it! We are so grateful to Glenn and the folks at Sweet Tooth!

Glen made our wedding cake. We went in without any idea what we are doing, and he helped us figure out the perfect cake for our reception. He was helpful, creative, courteous, funny, and truly went abov and beyond to help us out. He was receptive to outlr ideas, and had a few brilliant ones of his own. I cannot recommend this place highly enough, simply amazing.

This review is long, but I believe I have to provide my full experience for you to understand why I believe Sweet Tooth deserves two stars. I typically don’t say anything at all unless it’s something positive, because I work in food service and I know how harsh people can be. But I am writing this not-​so-​positive review in hopes that it can be used constructively for potential clients and existing owners or employees of Sweet Tooth.
My sister loves this bakery, so I decided to give them a try for a trendy «naked» cake design I had in mind for my birthday. A naked cake is very lightly frosted so that the cake itself shows through, giving it more of a rustic, home-​made look.
I ordered my cake almond flavored with raspberry filling and vanilla frosting. The lady over the phone asked me to email some pictures of naked cakes, so I gladly sent three photo examples and an additional photo of some pretty purple flowers. The email was short, polite and very specific. I’d like a naked cake, saying «Happy Birthday _​_​_​_​», with some light purple flowers on top or around the bottom. Thank you so much, I am very excited, etc. That is literally all. I was sent an automatic response email from Sweet Tooth saying that they will get back to me if needed and that I should not use the email address to attempt to correspond with them.
Two days before I pick up my cake (Saturday) I have a missed call from Sweet Tooth, but no voicemail. I tried to call back but got no answer, I believe because they are closed for the evening. The next day I tried to call again, but got no answer, I believe because they are closed on Sundays. Come Monday, I am ready to pick up my cake, so I call again with determination and when I finally got an answer, the woman on the phone tells me I can pick up my cake before 3pm. I asked about the missed call I got from them, and the woman assured me everything is okay and they were only calling me to make sure I wanted my cake to look just like the pictures.
When I arrived at Sweet Tooth, I was buzzed in by an employee who was playing loud music and talking to someone on her phone about paying her rent. I told her who I was and she retrieved my cake. Then she walked out with a cake that looked nothing like what I asked for. It was covered in bright green sugar-​molded leaves and fresh raspberries. It didn’t even say Happy Birthday on it. I was pretty shocked, and I’m going to be honest, I froze up. I told the woman it was pretty, but asked if she saw the picture of the purple flowers and she replied, «No». She told me the green leaves that the cake was absolutely covered in were inedible. I said ok, this is fine, and walked away. I believe I made a mistake by not complaining then and there, but I was to be serving the cake in two hours. I could have asked for a refund but that would have solved nothing. Whether it was what I had asked for or not, I needed the cake. As I left I decided I would try to find time to fix it myself at home.
When I got home I realized just how sloppily the cake was made. It was leaning to one side, chunks missing from the cake, metal wire showing where the inedible green leaves protruded from the top, and messy bits of frosting all over the leaves and raspberries. It looked like a child made it. I hurriedly removed the decorations, threw them away, and reconstructed the outside of the cake. Crisis averted. Two hours later I served it to my closest friends and family, telling them about my bizarre experience with Sweet Tooth and they all cracked jokes about the lack of any birthday message on the cake.
I must say, the cake tasted delicious. The raspberry, almond, vanilla combination was my idea, but at least the flavors were well-​executed. Everyone enjoyed the taste of the cake and I even saw people come back for seconds, which you rarely see with a birthday cake. Thus, I added one star to my review for the great flavor.
In retrospect, I wonder who made this cake and said, «Here is a cake worth someone’s $ 40. Here is a cake that someone will be excited to show off to their friends and family. Here is a custom cake, with an idea someone entrusted in me, that I executed to the best of my abilities.» With every confection you create, your bakery’s reputation is on the line. When your specialty is supposed to be custom cakes, how can you misenterpret a three-​sentence email so horribly? I was very disappointed with the look of my cake and the unprofessionalism of the employee who retrieved my cake. I will never forget my experience here, and I will not return.

They always hit a home run! YumYumYum. Ps, pick up a bag of cookies while you are there!

Loved my cake. They designed the cake exactly how i wanted it. Got so many compliments. Loved it

Absolutely discusting. I went in to grab a pastry and everything looked pretty good. So I bought a couple of pastries, and they weren’t all that cheap. When I but into one there was nothing but mold inside. I’m highly disappointed that I could have digested that and I should not have paid for something as such. Very disappointed.

I have champagne taste on a beer budget. I wanted a bmw car shaped cake but was quoted that it’d be over 300 $! Eeeks! I never order custom cakes so paying that much for a cake is shocking to me lol. They were helpful in coming up with another alternative of a round cake with a car on top made out of fondant for 85 $. Not too crazy on the handwriting but it still turned out looking great!
I had a friend pick up the cake the day of the event and they didn’t have a box that would close all the way because of the fondant car on top. They also didn’t have any bags to help cover the open box so my friend had to leave to find a bag and come back.
The cake itself tasted really good! Not dry at all — just a really delicious tasting cake! I would recommend sweet tooth bakery.

Another year another excellent cake by Sweet Tooth. My guests loved the peanut butter filled chocolate cake and my son lit up when he saw the design. Ordering takes minutes at this point and the bakers always give me exactly what I’m looking for but surprise me all the while. I really love this bakery and the fact that it has become a birthday tradition :) I look forward to what they do for us next year.

I went here for the first time yesterday, and was amazed by how amazing everything looked. I actually took a few minutes to decide since everything looked so good, and i couldn’t pick out a few items. I ended up getting the milk chocolate cookie, as well as the white chocolate cookie, and the boston crème cupcake. the cookies were ginormous, and amazing, and I am glad i work so close to this place. The lady working there was really nice as well!

My wife just went to pick up her paid order of desserts for a party tomorrow. Knowing they are closed on Sundays and are only open until 3pm on Saturdays, she requested the order be ready for today for pickup.
She gets there and is told the order is not ready, with the associate telling my wife that she told them she’d be picking up the order at 4:30pm — 90 minutes after they close! Apparently the customer in line with my wife had the same issue with her order, so it appears rhis may not be an isolated issue.
It’s the 1^st time we’ve ordered from Sweet Tooth and let’s just say they haven’t made a good first impression. My wife was told the owner will deliver the order tomorrow to the event location. We hope they come through; otherwise it will be the last time we will do business with them.

Glenn and his team knocked it out of Fenway and over the Green Monster!
Communicating with them while in Paris, they were very easy to work with and really focused on the details. Not only was the cake delicious, but it matched our travel theme perfectly.
Arrived on time and looking way better than expected. Glenn is a master at his craft.
From what they produced for me, I think Sweet Tooth Boston could make anything you want into a cake.
Highly recommended and will be used again when I’m back in Boston.

AMAZING cakes here; more expensive than other bakeries but worth every penny!
For my girlfriend’s 30^th birthday they made this awesome Pusheen chocolate cake with fresh cream and crushed chocolate cookie filling. It was incredible.
Would definitely absolutely order from them again!