Lehigh Pizza

I wish I could give this place 0 stars after the terrible experience I just had. The manager refused to give me a refund after the disgusting Sicilian pie I purchased. It was sloppy, burnt and soggy. The manager was rude and the food was gross. Save your money your better off eating frozen pizza.

Great pizza and better customer service! Were super nice about us using a coupon even though our pizzas weren’t the right type of crust. Kicks Pizza Hut right in the butt!

I’ve ordered here a few times now and they have great service and food. They have a reasonable delivery charge

Lehigh Pizza serves the best New York style pizza I have ever eaten! I don’t understand some of the reviews. It sounds like some of the customers don’t have good taste. More for me. Thank you, Lehigh Pizza.

So nasty. Pizza was terrible. I just arrived in Bethlehem for graduate school and I’ve quickly figured out that this place is for drunk people. I won’t eat here again.

My first encounter with Lehigh Pizza was when I began my graduate work at Lehigh University. Seven years and a Ph.D. later, I STILL make the four-​hour round-​trip to Lehigh Pizza JUST to have their insanely crispy fries (literally my favorites fries in the world), their deep-​fried cauliflower (that dipping sauce is soooo tasty that it must be some kind of black magic), and pizza that has a playfully chewy crust and enough cheese to please anyone. We always purchase a whole pie … so it is piping hot and at its absolute best. And, let me say, this isn’t nostalgia talking … I’ve had plenty of Sal’s and Penn’s pizza (and even once had Campus, ONCE). Lehigh is, BY FAR, the best.
As for the staff, they are pretty much the most accommodating, coolest crew that there is! Don’t expect a bunch of fake «kissing up» and plastered on smiles … but do expect people who genuinely appreciate their customers and aim to please!
Lehigh Pizza, keep doing what you do! You are the best! (Easily worth the four-​hour round-​trip!)

Standard. Nothing special. Good selection, nice people. Beer in the coolers. Plenty of seating. Open late usually.

My favorite place to grab pizza and beer. Plus they don’t judge me when I wander in here during my drunk-​capades.

After going consecutively following last years and this years Cars n Coffee events (where there’s — serious lack of food service), we can say it’s a favorite amongst our group to sit with good pizza, beer, and good conversation while watching the crowds leave the event. The selection of beer and ciders is very diverse. You shouldn’t end up with a bud light… unless that’s what you like.

It’s too bad people rate this so low, I love this place! One of the best places to get a burger for cheap in the valley — char-​grilled and delicious! And the cheeseburger sub is even better!
Pizza is usually pretty good, but pizza is hard to rate because everyone has a different kind of of favorite pizza.
Their drink selections — beer and otherwise — are pretty varied and you’re guaranteed to find something you like.
I go here all the time.

Okay, I’ve had their pizza now about seven or eight times, either for work-​related events or with friends on a Friday night. The convenience of free delivery is great, but getting a pizza warm is still a chance that you take by ordering from here. Also, the pizza is consistently okay — not great, but pretty good (although my friend really likes this pizza, so maybe it’s just not my style?).

Service was great and workers were very welcoming. I had a pepperoni pizza and a ginger ale soda. Pizza was not fulfilling taste wise but I will go back for other menu options and update my post.
UPDATE– I was replied by the pizzeria that the lack of parking lot advancement is not their fault. Great customer service.

I had a bad experience yesterday but they went out of their way to make it better. Truly amazing customer service.

Lehigh Pizza is the best place in Bethlehem to get slices! Try the greek or the eggplant… They won’t disappoint! I’ve been coming here for years and have been a happy customer every time. The service is pretty quick and the staff is always pleasant.

Over cooked slice with a wait.

The cheesesteak is AWFUL!!! The meat is dry, unseasoned, grinded up crap! I also got hot wings which were pretty bad, they were not hot by any means, which isn’t a big deal, except they also had no flavor at all.

Went there this past Wednesday. I had a ham and swiss club. Nothing crazy. Was actually pretty good. So good that I am writing about 2 days later. My boss got a chicken parm sandwich and said it was the best he has had yet. If we are in the area again. definitely be back

Lots of varieties of pizza available by the slice at the counter. Fast service. The artichoke & tomato pizza is amazing!

Lehigh Pizza is what you call standard Pizza fare. When you walk in, the first thing you notice is the register is pretty cramped, especially with a line. If your going for slices, Lehigh has basically a glass window with pies where you can pick your slices. Slices range from cheap to about $ 3 a slice for the more high end varieties. The place also has a full pizzeria menu for what you would expect from the area. Nothing crazy, but nothing horrible.
Pizza is good, and service is usually fast. Most days even at lunchtime I can get two slices heated up in 5 minutes of less. It also features enough seating for the crowd. It’s not as good as Sotto Santi, but then again it takes way less time to get your food. So if your in a rush and you want a pizza fix, lehigh will suffice. Otherwise Sotto Santi is your best bet.

So there I was, trapped in Bethlehem for two days due to some flight cancellations. The first night we were so hungry, and Lehigh is only a block from our hotel. Pizza and beer? Yes please!
This joint takes me back to my days living next door to a small by-​the-​slice pizza place in New Jersey. Everything was delicious in a low-​quality Jersey style pizza sort of way. The beer selection is fantastic since they double as a liquor store. Open late, friendly, prompt, and tasty? I’ll be back.