Algieri’s Pizza Restaurant

Friday night I ordered Pizza with Broccoli Rabe, omg it was amazing I would recommend this place and put it on your Pizza night you will not be disappointed the owner is one of the Nicest guys and will go out of his way to make your order special

Ironically, I don’t flip over their regular pizza but Algieri’s is a constant meal stop in my home. Their sandwiches are huge and delish (hot or cold), one of the best Sicilian pies around, and some of the best apps around.
If you are just ordering for yourself, then only get the half sandwhich. I’ve put a few whole ones away but then regretted it. Actually did it with the Italian hot dog a few times. What can I say, I’m a glutton for punishment.
When my wife and I order, we usually order a large sandwhich and a buffalo chicken salad. Everything is on point and more than enough.
They may have the greatest mozzarella sticks around. Have bought from them to host friends over before and pretty much everybody agrees. The buffalo wings are legit as well. The very last time we got them, it seems they were made differently. I hope they go back to the way they were
The Sicilian is on point. In a heavy Italian area, to say it’s the best Sicilian pie around is the best compliment I can give. It’s all in the bread and the bread is excellent in whatever you need bread for. Great bread place.
Owner is a really nice guy too. Always greets me by my first name. Outside dining in summer is nice as well

Stopped in to grab a pie on the way home from my sons baseball game. Ordered a large thin crust pie. The pizza was excellent and the cheese tasted fresh. Will definitely stop again when in the area.

I’ve gotten plain pizza here twice: once a large pie and once a personal pie. When I got delivery they were prompt and polite. When I came in to get a free pie (I had a special coupon), they were polite and made my pie quickly. I like their pizza quite a bit. I did not use their dining room, so I can’t comment on that.

This place has been hit or miss lately, mostly miss. The older guy (I assume was the owner) that always used to make the pizza is rarely, if ever there anymore. The younger guy could use some lessons from the old man. First off, use more sauce, the old man had perfected the sauce on pies, each slice always having a generous 1 inch or so thick sauce up near the crust, the pie I ordered tonight had no sauce by the crust and was pretty bland. Secondly, don’t pound the crust so thin, if the pizza is still hot, the cheese and toppings slide right off into box leaving a nice soggy sauceless piece of bread, if you put more sauce on the pie this would help prevent this as well. It’s a shame cause this was my go to pizza place for the last 4 years but i just can’t see myself going here anymore, there’s nothing worse then getting excited for your favorite pizza and getting home to find out it’s terrible, thumbs down, there’s really no good pizza places anywhere in this area now, Dominos hand tossed deep dish it is for me now I suppose.

Not Good. I ordered a plain pizza for delivery. First of all the pizza was thin like a piece of paper. IT COULD NOT EVEN HOLD THE SAUCE, which by the way was tasteless as if a can of crushed tomatoes was poured. Full price for a pizza that was so thin? I couldn’t get over how thin it was, as if the owner was trying to save money and make two pies out of one. Well I wont order from here again and will tell everyone to never order from here. Lots of good places to get a pie.

I’ve only ever had plain pies from here, but they don’t disappoint. Best in Belleville.

Pretty good! $ 8.99 for a pizza on a Tuesday (most places in Belleville have early week prices). The price goes up $ 1 for delivery. The shop is small, but new and clean. They have a self serve fridge and a small counter. I don’t think they sell by the slice.
I did not like that the guy took a minute or so to acknowledge me. His laptop and iPhone were more important. But my pizza was baking and wasn’t ready yet, so no harm, no foul. He was friendly otherwise.

A great place to order from the pizza is the best I’ve had some years… grill chicken salad is great also.

I’ve pobably tried almost every pizza joint in my area. And I find this place to be one of the best. Pizza fantastic, they even will make anything you can think of if they have the items like an italian hot dog pizza or even a blt pizza. Haven’t had everything on the menu but what I have had is great roast beef sub out of this world especially if you like a rare RB sub. Cavetelli n broc, veal parm awesome tender thumbs up guys

5 stars for the pizza alone. The plain pie is perfection. You *might* get better pizza in Italy.

Generally speaking I am very happy with the food I get from this restaurant, however, my most recent purchase was less than satisfying. I ordered an Italian sub and when I opened it up there was about a half of an onion’s worth of onion on the sandwich. Now I love onions on my sandwiches but that was way over the top. The next thing I noticed is that as much as there was way too much onion there was almost not meat. A very thin layer each of ham, salami and provolone. I tasted more bread, lettuce and tomato than anything else. For the price, definitely not worth it. My first disappointment. I hope there aren’t any more.

Algieri’s makes the best pizza I have had since I was a kid. I love their meatballs, sausage & peppers, and the Buffalo strips as well. I’m not a huge fan of their calamari (sad to say), and the salads I have ordered have been hit or miss. Delivery is one extreme or another… lightening fast or s l o w. Parking isn’t always convenient, but you CAN get a spot within a block of the restaurant.

Algeri’s has the ambiance of a typical neighborhood pizza parlor with the addition of some tables outdoors.
While they have a full menu, I’ve only had the Pizza so thats what I’ll focus my review on. The pizza is probably the best I’ve ever had, if you’re a thin crust lover you must try Algeri’s! The crust is thin and crispy with just the right amount of their tangy sauce.
Take advantage of Monday take out deals where a large pie is only $ 7.