Sergeant’s Pepperonie

We ordered this while sitting at the rooftop bar of the Bayfield Inn (PS, they will deliver to the bar!). The guy told us it would be about 45 minutes, which we did not mind as we were having a good time anyways. We did end up leaving the bar early because there was a storm moving in and we just called them and told them to hold it for us as we would pick it up. They were very friendly and accommodating. The pizza was awesome! I don’t think it lasted more than 15 minutes from the time they gave it to us.

A little bit of confusion on the order supposedly because of «bad cell service» even though he confirmed my order at the end which caused a longer wait when we went to pick it up. So there’s that and really should make this a 3 star review but let’s forget it for now.
Pizza– pretty good! Better than I expected considering resort towns usually have a cheap fix.
Word of advice-​Next time maybe offer a little bit of gratuity for waiting around on your mistake and step up the customer service to make this a must visit spot in Bayfield!

Delicious.
After a full day all we wanted was something to fill the tummy and when you are in a small town on a Sunday night if you are not careful you may miss all options. Good thing for us we saw the «Open» flag flying on this small pizza joint. To call is small is suggesting it actually has any space at all, it is actually a pizza oven, prep, and cold storage behind a half door. You walk up look at the menu choices, listen to the recommendations and either wait on the front porch or head down the street for a drink while you wait. 20 minutes later we walked back up and our pizza was ready.
Food — Plenty of cheese, meat, sauce on a delicious crust.
Service — Pretty good as they were about to close and stayed open to make that last pie for up.