Chicago Pizza & Catering

Just moved out this way and tried this places thin crust pizza and it was pretty awesome. Super thin crust and melty cheese the ingredients seem pretty fresh. Delivery was quick so overall I’m happy with them. Great set of coupons and deals when I got my first menu also so I will definitely be ordering again. The toppings could be a little more thought out and/​or spread out more on the pie.

We love Chicago pizza. Never had any trouble. Hot and fresh! Great deals and Saturday night special is the best. We’ve only done pizza, nothing else. Our kids love it, sauce is not spicy. Highly recommended!

Their pizza is delicious! I am not quite sure why there are so many bad reviews of this place. I come here all the time for lunch and I have gotten the food delivered. I have never once had a problem. The staff is alway friendly and polite. I say if your looking for a pizza place look no further. This is my favorite place for pizza in the area!

One of my top 3 pizza places in the area. Incredibly disappointing experience tonight though.
I ordered spinach and sausage as an add on with grub hub. They didn’t put it because it would have been an extra charge. The manager or owner stated she didn’t have time to call me to check. There was 2 other orders in the heating box and the cook wasn’t making anything else. He was standing around front. They were not busy at all so all she did is make an excuse
The fact is instead of calling to check she just assumed I didn’t want to pay extra and gave us a very large cheese pizza. When customers ask for something add it on. Especially when it even says on the website in that section «may include additional cost».
Anyways, hopefully it will be a much better experience next time. Also they changed their delivery area and my complex is no longer included in it.

First timer here. Got the S.O.B. [Sausage, onion & bacon w/​BBQ sauce]. 18″ with double dough crust ($ 3 upcharge) came to about $ 28.00 which I didn’t think was bad at all considering the group of 3 of us was eating this for 2 days.
The toppings were ample and the pizza was hot and fresh when I arrived. I didn’t think the double dough crust was especially worth it though.
The girl who rang me up was very nice and helpful. I was paying with my bosses credit card and she rang it up using just the CC info without the physical card, no problem.
I would definitely call this a hidden gem as it is not very prominent in it’s strip mall location. Certainly a good price though and I will be back for another S.O.B. It was great cold the next day!

This pizza is clearly made with fresh ingredients. It is full of herbs, spices, and flavor. There are pizza locations in Batavia that take pride in their food, but none of them compare to Chicago Pizza. Chicago Pizza is obviously passionate and full of expertise in the art of making pizza. This is the best pizza that I have ever had.
This place is a hidden gem in Batavia. I have ordered from them previously for a March Madness party (where our food was catered, delicious, and completely in the budget). Today, my dad and I ordered a deep dish meat lovers pizza. When my dad picked up the pizza, we started eating and we didn’t find any meat inside. We called them and told them what happened, and they are currently in the process of delivering another pizza free of charge. Not only was this kind, but they also said «Go ahead and enjoy the cheese pizza with your family, and we will be delivering you a new pizza immediately.» The person on the phone was sincere, kind, and really wanted to give us the best experience possible.
Customer service seems to lack nowadays, but not here. I am incredibly impressed. I look forward to doing more business with them in the future.

The food is okay if you order the right time of day. The delivery drivers are awesome.
Their managers are a joke. Just today I attempted to call in to find their website. (You know, b/​c they have 4 and none of the ones that show up on Google actually work.) and the girl on the phone put me on hold for an extended period of time. I call back, «Thank you for calling Chicago Pizza, can you please hold?» in about 2 seconds and can’t be bothered to wait for an answer. 4 times. All I wanted was a website.

This Place is AMAZING!!! I have been there three or four times now. Excellent PIZZA, fresh hot – DELICIOUS!!! Today I got the 4-​piece fried chicken with fries and coleslaw – AWESOME!!! The chicken tastes like White Fence Farm used to taste like years ago. Fresh, JUICY, hot! Good eating! LOVE THIS FOOD!!!

I thought it was better than Rosati ‘s pizza but then I walked in on a couple fooling around on a counter used to make their product. I was embarrassingly served my pizza. Batavia is void of good clean pizza.

Knocking them down to one star. Yet again screwed up the chicken Cesar salad. We got the dressing this time… Just not the chicken.
In fact, I chose not to order the wings because I am confident that it would be a snowball’s chance in Hell to get both ranch and blue cheese dressing. I’m deeply disappointed that this place isn’t run better.
About a month ago…
Good luck ordering from these folks on Grub Hub. They don’t even know that a Caesar salad COMES with Caesar dressing. One star for being unqualified to work in the restaurant industry; plus one star for having amazing lagazna and garlic bread, for a total of two stars.

Sauce is too sweet for my taste. If you like a sweet sauce then you will love it. Everything else we good.

So here’s the update:
All the «before» events took place on Wednesday 6÷23÷2014. On Saturday evening, 6÷28÷2014, the owner/​manager called me to apologize and explain that the driver was fired and had been a problem for them several times. He offered me $ 15.00 off my next offer and asked that I give them a 2^nd chance.
Today 6÷29÷2014, I came into work and spoke with my co-​worker and we decided we would try again and order some food and use the $ 15.00 off. When I called, the owner/​manager was transferred in and personally took my order and was very polite and personable. I ordered a chicken salad and an order of fried veggies. My co-​worker got a calzone with green olives. He said it would be about 45 minutes to an hour.
About a half hour later, the food showed up (at the correct place), and before the driver made it to his car, I had opened everything up and noticed that my fried veggies were missing. I ran out and told the driver and he called, came back in and said another driver would be bringing the veggies. About 20 minutes later, another driver dropped off the veggies.
As far as the quality of food. Well, its not horrible, but its nothing out of this world. It was a chicken salad, so how hard would it be to screw that up? Chopped veggies and chicken cubes, pretty standard. The ranch dressing is… also pretty standard for a pizza restaurant. Kinda tart, but not horrible. The fried veggies were soggy, but again, what to expect? My co-​worker said his calzone was really good though. It was huge. Had to be stored in a smaller pizza box instead of being just wrapped up like most places.
All in all, the place got an increase in stars strictly because the owner did the professional thing and tried to make up for a bad employee. Beyond that, I suppose I’ll have to order something else before giving this place a final judgement.

I used to like to get pizza slices here for lunch. Not anymore, after I got 2 burnt, greasy, pieces that were spongy, and undercooked, with a horrid plastic taste.
A total waste, I ended up pitching them out.
I can’t recommend this place.
For pizza slices at lunchtime, try Antonio’s, Rosati’s, or Papa Saverio’s.

Good cheap pizza, decent if light sauce, good ingredients. Would recommend for lunch on the go.

They were very rude to me over the phone. Don’t think I’ll be eating here.

Pizza is good, but don’t order the shrimp basket none of the shrimp were deveined ! Called to complain and was told that they have been buying it like that forever and won’t be changing it. So I figure if they leave poop in the shrimp, what else are they hiding? Nasty, and thanks for the crappy customer service.

One of my favorite places in Batavia for pizza.
Good, consistant and very reasonably priced pizza. It beats out the Rosatis down the road. The sauce is tangy yet good, and toppings are always fresh. My pizza is always ready on time, and always hot. My favorite is the pepperoni, light on the cheese to allow the sauce to come out more.
Not the best pizza out there (or for your health: P), but It sure is good.
They are always doing specials, check on their website or Grubhub.

Wasn’t terrible but also not good just mediocre

The pizza is just ok, to the commenter below if you think this is excellent, you must have spent your whole life eating tombstone frozen pizzas. The price is good for the size of pizza. I’ve only ever had the thin crust and deep dish. I have to say the deep dish was very disappointing, but the thin crust is decent and very similar to a rosatis pizza with appearance and taste.
We have had some of their pasta and the sauce isn’t that spectacular but where they lack in flavor in they make up with lots of cheese! (that is definitely not a bad thing!)
Batavia doesn’t have very many good pizza places so this is probably top 5. Their location is very convenient and pizza is decent, so we will keep ordering.

Was out in the suburbs and needed to find food for my very picky niece & nephew, We just ordered appetizers, but they were a hit! Beer nuggets, toasted ravioli, pizza puffs, mozzarella sticks and even a free order of bread sticks were delivered and made for very happy campers — at a very reasonable cost.
I highly recommend if you are in the Geneva/​Batavia area!