Nicky & Smitty’s Deli Restaurant

Lets start with the good:
friendly staff
seated right away
good coffee
good pancakes — thin and golden
good spinach omelette
asked for extra done hash browns and they were
Clean and nice décor
Now the bad:
Waited 20+ minutes for our food
Corned beef hash omelette wasn’t edible bc the corned beef was so chewy
Our friendly server got an attitude as soon as we had a problem
All in all not a great experience. We will
Not return

Home cooked meals from a wonderful, husband & wife duo! Nothing compares to the great quality & prices. It’s like Cheers, everyone knows your name & locals hang here daily.

Not bad. Went on a Friday in the late afternoon. The matzo ball soup was pretty good. The matzo ball itself was slightly bland, but I’m spoiled with the great matzo balls my mom makes. They have a fish fry special on Fridays and everyone seemed to be ordering it. It smelled really good. I got a turkey sandwich. The turkey was okay. It had a funny flavor, but it think it was just generic processed turkey and I generally opt for a healthier sandwich turkey. Overall I would be willing to come back and try something else.

Our first time back in some time and loved it. I had the Farmers Skillet, and while not quite as large as I thought it would be, it was excellent with a good blend of flavors including the sausage gravy. The homefries are the best I’ve tasted. My wife’s breakfast included sausage links which I sampled and again are some of the best I’ve had. Will be returning!

The people there were so rude! The hostess was yelling to the people waiting for a table from the back of the restaurant… Just yelling over everyone eating saying «how many?!?» And then motioning them to follow her. You really can’t take the extra 30 seconds to greet someone instead of yelling across the whole restaurant?! The woman giving me my carry out I had to tell her about 5 times my 2 sandwich order!!! Not sure how the food is yet but I will NOT be going back to give such rude people my business.

I stumbled upon this place one morning while I was working in the area and I was very happy I did. I had the homemade corn beef hash and it was delicious. Very fresh and the portion was huge.
The service was amazing as well with the owner making it a point to talk with my group and really make us feel right at home. I highly recommend this place and I look forward to trying it again.

True, it’s no Jim’s Open Kitchen, but they do make a mean plate of steak and eggs!
I go here just for that when I’m really feeling the steak and egg breakfast. I will echo other people’s comments that the hash browns/​home fries (whatever you want to call them) are not the best (often very salty or cooling). And the service occasionally leaves something to be desired.
But I won’t write this place off just yet. Because when it’s good, it’s really good.

I looooove this place. best french toast ever, great prices, friendly family owned business:) Never had anything I do not like! Cozy space, memorable time!

My all time favorite family owned restaurant. A place that is close to home, friendly, and knows your name. They have a great menu from breakfast-​lunch & dinner deli menu. My favorite is the tuna melt and the Abby melt, my husbands favorite is the Reuben! They have a large kids menu too! The best part is all this great food and it won’t break the bank! I highly recommend trying this gem of a restaurant!

Wow, utterly delicious and authentic matzo ball soup and freshly cooked corned beef. Great! food and friendly service. Excellent menu too.

This was my first visit to Nicki & Smittys Deli, I’ve heard of them as being a great place for the Friday fish fry and then heard they serve a breakfast all so. My visit was during the breakfast hours of 9am so I should have received everything fresh and on time.
The Environment was ok, place was clean in the seating area and appeared to be well stocked. The waitress was very pleasant and had a great personality. I ordered coffee and my friend ordered orange juice. The coffee was luke warm not sure why but I think their bun burner was not heating it properly. The orange juice had a sour taste. I ordered a country omelet with home fries and wheat bread side order or sausage for two of us. My friend ordered pancakes and bacon on the side. The food arrived 17 minutes later, they were not very busy only 3 others in the place.
The wheat bread was terrible, it has some type of butter or margarine spread on I that made it taste like soggy puke. I moved them aside, the home fries had to be the worst ones I have ever eaten, they appeared not to be fresh but instead something they made the day or two before then reheated so bad they were like dried out, hard chip pieces, and sour tasting all so, many of which you could not even put a fork in, and you wouldn’t want to either. The omelet wasn’t much better, the omelet itself was plain and the inside of it appeared again of pre made dried out NON fresh pieces or chunks of burnt green peppers and dried up sausage, mushrooms. With a slice of American cheese, the side order of sausage tasted ok but you can tell it was all so re heated because you can see the wrinkles in the casing, and that comes from heating for a very long time or re heating it. My friend’s pancakes looked good until you turned them over; they were burnt on the bottom so they placed that part on the bottom so that you could not see that. That was a very poor and disturbing idea…
After tasting the sour foods made me think they might have a cooling problem in their refrigerator unit or something. Breakfast really is not hard to make and they missed the boat on this, in fact I think they should forget breakfast. They need to make fresh food and taste what they are serving because I have to say a McDonald’s breakfast tastes much better than theirs, and that a real shame. I wouldn’t recommend them for breakfast at all; if anything they should close their doors for breakfast. The place reminded me of a needed «bar rescue show» but for a restaurant. Need I say more?
Rating I gave them: 1 – 10 1 being lowest — 10 being the highest
Service: 1 — I dropped that service rating down because they tried to hide the burning of the pancakes.
Environment: 6
Cleanliness at booths: 7
Food quality: 1
Food Taste: 1
Price: 4 not worth it
Would I recommend them: NO WAY, NEVER
Would I return: NEVER, not in this lifetime.

Best corned beef hash I’ve ever had! The only reason why I am not giving it five stars is because they do not serve it on Friday night:(

Tight and small atmosphere, really a hole in the wall. The folks who own it talk to the people who are regulars, but treat newcomers like strangers. Waiting outside is not acceptable in temps below zero. Food is ok, but not great. Prices are good.

My kind of place.
It’s the type of place that you can stroll into, relax, grab a bite, and leave happy. There’s nothing pretentious, there’s nothing rushed, there’s nothing to be disappointed about. The staff is friendly, the food is good, and there’s a good amount a space to be seated.
The word deli means one thing in my book: «corned beef». They’ve got it, and it’s very good. Slow cooked, non-​fatty, and I typically go with the Reuben. You can get the fries, but the coleslaw is a good option with the corned beef. I can’t comment on breakfast, but I can tell you 90% of the customers were enjoying breakfast past 11am, so it must be something to it.
It’s not quite a 5 star, because it doesn’t have that WOW factor like Slyman’s, it doesn’t do anything to knock your socks off, but I’d recommend it if you’re looking for a relaxing place to enjoy a meal.

I’m sad to drop them two stars but we come here about every two weeks or so and we have had consistently crappy service. The food continues to be delicious but when you enter you stand at the door for a while before they seat you. Drink and food orders are also slow to be placed even when it’s not busy. One visit here we even had the opportunity to overhear a staff member complaining about her job.

Honestly… I don’t know what the lady was saying in the last review about a rude cashier or anyone else of that matter, everyone was great. Met Joe, great guy… had the fish sandwich, absolutely awesome. Great little stop and eat. Thanks Joe for the great food and a comfortable down home feeling.

This is a great small place to grab something to eat. The food was delicious and the employees were very friendly. When you first walk in the place looks a lot smaller than it is so don’t worry there is more sweating than you initially see.

A wonderful place to come for all meals of the day. They have a great menu, and the owner is proud to tell you he only finds the best ingredients to serve and doesn’t cut corners (and it shows). Try the reuben, the fish fry, or just about anything else!

My husband surprised me by bringing home Reuben’s one night. It is hard to preserve such a sandwich for the rest of the commute, but this was FANTASTIC by the time it made it to my mouth. The meat was juicy and flavorful and the bread was soft and perfect. The fries and pickles were even awesome! I can’t wait to have this again!

In an area with almost every chain and franchised restaurant within a few minutes drive this place stands out. An extensive menu, excellent service and unbelievable prices make it well worth a visit. The regulars seem to enjoy it and you will too.