OddFellas Pub & Eatery

Nice place to meet friends for a beer, watch a game or just go to dinner. I’ll be back.

This was a good place to eat. We had brunch there and it was nice. Very nice wait staff. It was a little dark since the weather was bright and sunny and the place seemed dark. I would go back.

This is my favorite place to eat in auburn! Great food, nice people, a great environment and always unique!

I’ve been here a couple times, the staff is amazing! Always friendly and very interactive! The food is ok, I wish more vegetarian options but still great food. I have to say if you haven’t been please go the staff is soo awesome and fun really makes the place!

Came in for dinner and a few beers. Sat down and waited a while before anyone came to say anything. Probably about 15 minutes. Server asked what I wanted to drink, they were out, second choice? Out of that too. Okay… What do they have? Server went back to the bar and gave me four choices… So much for having the most beers on tap on Auburn…
Ordering our food was interesting. My father asked if the chili was good, and the server flat out said «no not really.» I appreciate the honesty, but the salesmanship not so much. We asked what the best thing on the menu was — her response, «I don’t know, I don’t really have a favorite.» How helpful… We ordered our food, it came out timely. The food was okay. None of us were really impressed.
Side note, IT WAS SO LOUD! YES I’M YELLING, I STILL CAN’T HEAR!
Not sure if it was a rough crowd or what but holy cow it was loud.

My wife, daughter and I ate lunch here a few days ago. My daughter moved to Auburn a few weeks ago and we have been exploring local restaurants. We were actually going to another establishment, but it was closed, so we picked Oddfellas as a runner-​up; we are so glad that we ate here; it is great!
The place is really a pub with a large beer menu. But the food is great!
I ordered Red’s Chili ($ 7.95) with cheese & onion. This is one of the best bowls of chili I’ve ever had. I think I’ll rate it #2 compared with the Big Texan Steak Ranch in Amarillo Texas as #1. The chili had hunks of steak. Real steak cut into cubes with some beans in a delicious sauce. Fantastic!
My wife had the DBLT (Double Bacon, lettuce, and tomato) sandwich ($ 9.99) that lived up to its name with lots of bacon, extending far outside of the bread. She said it was delicious.
My daughter had the Smokey Mac and Cheese that was full of smokey sausages. She immensely enjoyed it.
We recommend this place!

We have eaten and had drinks here a dozen or so times in the past 2 years, both at the bar and in the dining room.
Service at the bar is great — the bartender and servers are very attentive, drinks are reasonably priced and well made.
The food is really good, I have had the clam appetizer, which I crave on a regular basis, the mac and cheese is fabulous, the fish sandwich is really good, and my husband and kids really like the burgers and sandwiches, and they serve tots! Breakfast is good here too, potatoes are crispy, eggs benedict was good and they allowed me to substitute tomatoes for the ham, which some restaurants make a big deal about — our only complaint with breakfast is that the biscuits are very small — when ordering biscuits and gravy, one expects a large biscuit, theirs did not make the cut.
That said, I am giving them 4 stars because the service in the dining room is only mediocre. We have waited for long periods without even seeing our server on the 2 instances we ate in the dining area, for the breakfast trip, half of our food came out, and the rest was about 10 minutes behind. We had to ask a different server to bring out the biscuits, which were forgotten all together, and when we were ready for our check, it was another 10 minutes of waiting. It was the 1^st trip to Odd Fellas for my mother in law, and she says she will not be back, which disappointed me, since we’ve had such positive experiences in the bar.
I will continue to come to the bar area, but probably not the dining room.

Tried the «Seaman’s Fav» — not just another fish sandwich. This was the most perfect fish sandwich I’ve ever had. Two cod filets perfectly cooked, crispy but not greasy. Between the toasted bun and the crispest lettuce leaf ever, this sandwich had a crunch to it that I loved.
My dining partner had the DBLT (double bacon lettuce tomato) and it was equally delish.
The atmosphere and service were top notch too. I definitely recommend it for a casual, fun night out.

I was skeptical about a pub for breakfast, but my favorite breakfast spot was closed. My friends and I saw positive reviews, so thought we’d give it a try.
I was delightfully surprised. It was really good! I asked for a few special requests for my breakfast, which they did without a problem. My dining partners LOVED their breakfasts, too. The service was not especially friendly, but was right on time and attentive.
I would definitely recommend!

Super Stellar Hash! Scrambled eggs done perfectly! Definitely my new favorite breakfast spot! Service fast and friendly. Even on the busy day of The Veterans Day Parade!

We came here with friends on a Friday night. Got here early, around 6pm and were told there was an hour wait. No problem, a quick trip to the bar gave us something to do while we waited. A lot of people checked in and then proceeded to leave while we were waiting. Our wait turned out to be only about 30 minutes. Not too bad. The beer selection was great! Something to suite just about any beer taste. The place was busy and it took a few minutes to get served. Once we did, service was timely. I ordered a french dip (called something like a «French dunk»). It was quite good, but more than I could eat. The fries and chips were really good. Overall this was a great experince with good food and great beer!

3.5
The atomesphere was good, I love the décor. Customer service was friendly. The Dill Do bread was a bit tasteless. I had the cheesy brit. The sandwich was crunchy and full of meat. So crunchy, the roof of my mouth hurts. And the turkey seemed a bit off. The sandwich was small for the price but I would visit again

The food here is average and service depends on who the server is .
Taste wise it’s nothing special and wraps are pretty basic nothing that stands out much

I am dumbfounded by these ratings. We came for dinner and were really disappointed. Most of the meals were cold. My «german vegetables» that came with my dish were clearly previously frozen. Mashed potatoes were flavorless (and also probably frozen). Beer selection is fair — actually, quite vood for Auburn. Our server was nice and did a fine job, but the food was really not at all good. It’s a fine place for a drink and snack, but it it pretty terrible for a sit down meal.

Had breakfast here a couple of days ago. The place is huge inside. We were seated right away and our orders were taken soon after. The food was good and plentiful. My wife’s eggs were underdone. At first I thought she might be being her picky self but I looked at her plate and they were very runny. The server replaced her eggs right away. Overall a good experience. The menu is pretty short but if you don’t want to wait a long time for the wildly popular place across the street, this is definitely a safe bet.

Typical bar and bar food. Lots of choices on drinks and a nice menu.
Customer service is hit and miss depending on the day. Food are normally spot on. They carry 25 different beer selection at any one time and they rotate beers on and off their taps all the time. They carry quite a few Washington brew beers.
It’s a good place to meet up with friends or co-​workers after work. Nice atmosphere, and good location in auburn.

A solid little spot in downtown Auburn. There are a few blocks through here with some cool old brick buildings, and OddFellas occupies a nice corner space in one of them. There’s not much in the way of a parking lot right around here from what I could see, but street parking was an easy score.
Inside, everything has been overhauled to bring it up to modern pub standards. There’s a mishmash of tables and stools throughout, with some areas that feel more like dining rooms and some that feel more like bar seating – but I believe it’s entirely 21+. The main bar is across from the front door, with about 20 faucets pouring a mix of Irish imports and domestic craft beers – mostly big IPAs, porters, stouts, and the like. All good stuff, and some is from very local and very small breweries, which is really cool.
There’s at least one raised table in here with about a dozen throne-​like dining room chairs ringed around it, and a flat-​screen overhead on the wall. Creates a great effect, makes the table seem like it’s hosting an important conversation. Overall, the place feels much more like a sports bar than an Irish pub, but that’s mostly due to all the flat screens and the clear focus on watching the game. The décor, food, and many of the beers all aim for an Irish feel.
The staff here are super friendly and right on point throughout the time you’re here. They seem to draw a great stream of regulars through here.

I have eaten here a few times and it is good. An old Irish Pub with a wall clock counting down to St Patrick’s day.
I tried their «French dunk» dip which was tasty with great Au Jus as were the French Fries However I did find their Coke was watered down which is surprising for a pub.
I also did have real good service — she was both friendly and attentive.
It was not busy but the atmosphere was enjoyable so I would recommend the place.

Sat in the bar, slower service despite how empty. A few errors on our order/​drink however the food was wonderful as always. Hobo clams are back and very fresh/​wonderful. The fish and chips are very tasty and the burger we’d give a solid B+.
Bathrooms and restaurant were clean.

Found this place when doing a Unilocal search. The reviews drew me in, but the service and food will make me go back again.
I love tater tots. I especially loved the Irish Nachos. I got the beef added on top of them, and man that was good. We split them between six of us, and there was definitely enough to go around.
The Cottage Pie was well made, tasty, and filling. I should have asked for a bit more gravy, and a little more cheese. Otherwise, it was perfect.
The service was outstanding. I didn’t have to ask for a refill once. Our waitress was very pleasant and attentive.
The atmosphere of the place seems ‘lived in’, but not in a bad way. Very down to earth, quirky, and comfortable.
About the only negative thing I could say is that there’s no sign in the front saying ‘please wait to be seated’ or any indication where I would wait to do so. It took a couple minutes for someone to come seat us, and that was confusing.