GoodFella’s Pizza & Wings

Idk why the ratings are so low here. I’ve never had anything really jere besides calzones. I cannot begin to stress how AMAZING they are. I was disappointed when I ordered an actual pizza tho. It kinda reminded me of a frozen pizza from the supermarket. But their calzones are WONDERFUL. always hot, always cheesy af and full of toppings.

Had a SERIOUS craving for wings… Found this place on Unilocal and decided to give it a try! BOY AM I GLAD I DID!!! Possibly the BEST lemon pepper wings I’ve EVER HAD!!! They were phenomenal!!!

Don’t come here if you are expecting NY style pizza. I’ve had box pizza better than this stuff.
However, I would go back to try another item from their menu.
Pros: Open Late
Nice staff
Plenty of seating
Good location

I WILL NEVER ORDER AGAIN!!! Pizza came cold!!! Took forever to get to me. The «MEDIUM» is the size of a Pizza Hut personal pan and it cost me $ 14.80. Then had to wait for a replacement pizza!!!

We ordered delivery to our hotel after driving for 10 hours. We live about 700 miles from Atlanta and ordered from here after the front desk suggested them. We ordered online through their website at 11:15pm — they quote 30 – 45 min for delivery. At 12:15am I called them to ask where our pizza was — the girl who answered the phone was very short and stated that all the deliveries had left the store and ours should be there shortly. Really? She didn’t even know where we were… FYI this Goodfellas location is ONE block from our hotel. At 12:30am the delivery driver called my cell phone to ask me directions to get into the hotel. As I stated earlier, this hotel is ONE block from Goodfellas — and their delivery driver is calling me for directions? We finally get our pizza — which the delivery driver just left at the front desk and boogied. Pro Tip — don’t add a tip to the online order. We got the food up to our room and one of our pizzas was incorrect. We ordered a half pepperoni/​half ham and pineapple. We got half ham/​half pepperoni and pineapple. At this point we’re hungry, tired, and a little cranky due to waiting for so long. I called Goodfellas — to their credit they offered to re-​make the pizza and send it out. I declined, however, due to the 75 minutes it took them to travel one block on the first delivery. I asked if they could credit us the delivery fee (which is $ 3) or a couple bucks for the mistake. Their answer was — no — because I had ordered online through a 3^rd party — I needed to deal with them if there was a mistake — and I was told they (Goodfellas) don’t have a website. Wow. It was from their website that I placed the order online! So to make a short story long, the customer service is nearly non-​existent. Delivery times are no where near the 30 – 45 minute quote, they are curt on the phone, and unwilling to help out if you order online and they make a mistake with your order. The pizza was not too good (the crust was very flat and had a gel layer, not much sauce so it was dry), the fried mushrooms were probably OK when they were warm, and the cheese bread is a hoagie bun with some mozzarella on it. We’ll be back to Atlanta, but will not be ordering from Goodfellas.

I enjoy their food. I love the pizza, wings, fries, and the philly. The prices are really good for the quality and amount of food that you get. I never ate inside of the establishment but the service is pretty normal. Takes about 10 – 15 minutes to get the food. The last few times I went the pizza wasn’t that amazing but normally it is very cheesy and fresh. I would recommend to others.

This place is great anytime! I can tell they use the best cheese which most pizza places skimp on the cheap stuff. There open til 4:30 am for night owls. There fast and you won’t get cheap dominoes or little Caesars crap here. It gets crowded on Friday and Saturday nights but those cooks are unbelievably quick in getting you your food.

There is a reason this place is located across from the Varsity (home of mystery meat chili) and a few blocks from the Georgia Tech campus. This is cheap college food for students on a budget.
Prices are fairly reasonable but the flavor and quality are not. My slice of sausage pizza was ‘meh’ and the meat in my gyro looked like a dogs chew toy or better yet, a thick cut of beef jerky. I won’t bother rating either.
Surprisingly, despite how I feel about the food, they were VERY busy with take-​out orders and walk-in’s during my 15 minutes there. Go figure!
FINAL THOUGHTS
I was out late, they were open, I was hungry, so I gave them a shot. I hope time machines will be available for personal use in the future so I can go back and save myself from wasting both time & money. That alone would pay for my time machine, whatever it may someday cost!
If you are reading this in the future… you’ve been warned.
²⁰¹⁶⁄₄₆

Wasn’t the best slice of pizza I’ve had since living in ATL. Little over price. Good customer service. Might go back another time and try the wings.

I placed an online order and received a call from the restaurant stating my order couldn’t be delivered due to a street being closed off. I live 6 minutes from the restaurant and the delivery driver should have knowledge of the area and surrounding streets. One street being closed had nothing to do with my order not being delivered. I know the area well and all they had to do was take any of the other many routes that were available. I order from this restaurant at least 4 times a week and I am very disappointed with this experience.

So Y did we place an order @ 0200 & we just called them to follow up on our order; its 0503. Security answered the phone and we ran through the order. After discovering that the order was taken but noted under the incorrect number, the security guard says to call back to speak to «John» if the food is not delivered in an Hr. Really?!? The order was placed @ 2 a.m. Y does one pizza & 20 wings take 3+‘Hrs to prep & deliver if the pizza house is .05 miles away from the address of delivery?!? We still have not received the food we’ve pd for?!! So, after we’ve called to verify the delivery, our door bell rings @ 0525. The delivery consisted of one COLD pizza and did not accompany our 20 piece wings.
The only solution to this incident is to tell the delivery to return the very COLD pizza & cancel the entire order since it was a partial. Even if today was New Year’s… But, really?!?

Ordered delivery to a hotel in Midtown. They came in the expected timeframe. Cheese pizza… Outstanding! Garden salad… Fresh and delicious. Calzone… Very good. Definitely recommend

Checked out Goodfella’s as a change from lunch on campus. I ordered the Philly sandwich. The cashier asked if I wanted peppers. Of course, and onions. There’s an extra charge she tells me. Ok… maybe an ‘authentic’ Philly doesn’t include these things. But I’m not in Philly, and peppers and onions seem reasonable to add. Cashier was great and didn’t upcharge me for the veggies.
The sandwich was underwhelming. Meat, so so. Cheese wasn’t really melted, it sort of lay awkwardly on the bread. For the price and quality, I was left a bit disappointed. I would give Goodfella’s another try, but definitely attempt a different dish next time.

The only good thing I liked about this place was the cheese fries. For some crazy reason I assumed «goodfellas» meant it was New York style pizza. Nope. It seemed more like a deep dish pizza. It also didn’t taste that great. Also, even though there was a security guard in there it didn’t keep this homeless man from coming up to us while we were eating mumbling something we couldn’t understand. Disappointed

Bad service and bad pizza. Too salty. They forgot the sides I had ordered and the employees didn’t seem to care about that. The manager had to step in an tell them to bring what they had forgotten to include. Quality of the food is not good either. As I mentioned, too salty. I wouldn’t spend another dollar in this pizzeria, ever again.

This place is terrible. Delivery service is awful — both times I’ve ordered I’ve had to walk out to get my food. Don’t charge a delivery fee if you’re not going to finish the job. The food also sucks. My calzone was super undercooked to the point that it was basically raw dough filled with ricotta that literally had ice crystals.
The first time I ordered, delivery took twice as long as the quoted time, and the delivery guy «forgot» my pizza. He then asked me if I would like him to come back with it (I had prepaid for the order) as if it were an option to just not fulfill the order. The return trip took another hour for a total time of order placement to fulfillment of about 3 hours.
Won’t be repeating another try with them.

Ordered stomboli combo and it was good. Only problem was the cashier gave me attitude when I tried to change my order but the food made up for it

I love this place its fantastic the food is fresh it’s always moving out quick because it’s so busy and everything is clean, staff is very knowledgeable, very courteous as well as very clean next to none…

Been to Atlanta a ton of times and have never been to this place until tonight. Heard about this place through a friend and again through the hotel clerk at the hotel we’re staying at, decided to try it after the drive and walking around all day.
The family got two orders of wings, one lemon pepper order (dad/​mom) and one hot order (me). Wings are hot and delicious, if you order them with sauce they come basically bathed in the sauce of preference, so no dry wings. Wings are a good size and come with pretty good fries and your dressing preference.
Also got the Spinach and Feta Calzone, Meatball Parm Sub, and Chicken Gyro Wrap. Spinach and Feta Cal was for my dad and it came hot, cheesey, and smelling good. He gives it two thumbs up. Meatball Sub for my bro, very saucy, good amount of cheese and seasoned well, also a two thumbs up. Chicken Gyro Wrap for mom, she loves these type of wraps and was very pleased.
All and all this place is a good place to give if you want a snack between big meals or even get a meal since they offer some meals and also great for late night since they are open so late. Will definitely be coming back

After a long day of working then driving to Atlanta my husband who always likes to try a local pizza place where ever we go was recommended this place by our hotel clerk.
It was after 9pm when we placed our order, one Greek pizza and one steak and cheese. We were told 45 minuets to an hour on delivery which was no problem for us.
I would say food arrived between 20 – 30 which was a huge bonus because we were both hungry.
I ordered the Greek, it’s basically a gyro on pizza and it was good, enjoyable but just not my thing. My husband had the steak and cheese, lots of melted cheese and some «steak» looked kind of like ground beef or maybe even Italian sausage either way it was very delicious. My husband ended up having to share his with me because it was so good!
I typically always look a restaurant up on here before we order from them and this was the one time I actually waited until AFTER we ate there. If I had of read some of these reviews first I probably would have looked elsewhere. I know everyone has their own opinions and service is different to each person but I was impressed and had no issues with goodfellas. If we were in town longer I’m sure my husband would order pizza again!