Fellini’s Pizza

I love the pizza (1 slice of cheese is enough for me!) and the Greek salad is amazing. Portions are large but usually the wait is around at least 20 minutes for me if I order a whole pizza. I love to come here with friends because it’s a good place for a crowd. Parking is located behind the building.

Love Fellini’s. Solid prices, solid ‘za, good tap beers.

Fellinis and Antico are definitely my two favorite pizza places in ATL. Antico is more of a traditional Italian pizza place while Fellinis is more of a non traditional pizza. That being said, it’s phenomenal!!!
I always get the Fellinis special and they pile ton of toppings on. It usually takes awhile to get your food, but at least they’re staying from scratch!
I really like the one on the Westside too cuz it’s got a nice little patio.

Went here for lunch. Had slides of pizza. Lots of room in the place. The parking was great. The food was OK but on the bland variety. Ok but nothing special.

Parking: open parking lot adjacent and behind restaurant, but only few spots. However, I’ve never had an issue finding a spot.
Ambiance: no impressive décor here. You walk in and there’s a huge menu on the board, place your order, and cashier will give you a number that you place on your table. There is outdoor seating that faces howell mill rd, which seems to be a popular place to sit. There are always people sitting outside. Sometimes on a Friday or Sat night there is a rush of college kids late at night, but the wait is not terrible.
Service: Cashiers seem like they hate their lives because they lack eagerness to take your order. Server will bring your food to your table along with utensils. Sometimes there are condiments on your table, otherwise you will have to go to the self-​serve drink machine to grab hot oil, hot sauce or parmesan cheese. You leave your trash on your table, which the server will pick up.
Food: I ordered one slice of the Felini’s special, which was huge with lots of toppings and lots of cheese, thus, the crust was a bit moist and tasted a bit undercooked. It took about 5 minutes for my 1 slice to come out. I definitely recommend eating it with a fork/​knife since the crust is pretty thin. I could barely taste the tomato sauce. Pizza hut or domino’s pizza taste better… no where near as good as Jet’s pizza. Self-​serve drink machine
Overall: fast service, poor décor, huge slice, stays open late, good for a late night hangout spot! Recommend as a last resort pizza place.

Could be me, but pizza looked and tasted undercooked. I’ve tried Fellini’s quite a few times but, these last few times haven’t been the best experience :/

Yassssss to non-​fast food late night options. I got the Fellini’s special slice. Super tasty. There was a layer of cheese over the toppings which I liked. I’ll continue to make this my late night option when in the area. There was plenty of seating and it looked pretty clean. The pizza didn’t take long to come out. The staff was friendly enough.

This is my favorite pizza spot! Always delicious. I recommend the spinach and mushroom pizza.

Never disappointed when we come here just to grab a slice! Staff is always nice and helpful!

best ny pizza in Atlanta. Being a New Yorker I am confused why pizza is served with a fork and knife. Other than that I feel at home here

This is a great place to hang out and get some consistently really good pizza… Or get it to go… They have a good patio as well… Plus they stay open late which is awesome for late night munchies!!!

Fellini’s always delivers the same consistent pizza every time I visit this, or their Ponce De Leon location. The staff at this location are always friendly and this location has a fairly large parking lot that covers the entire building from side to side and front to rear. Last week I stopped here for a Calzone to share with my son, but in the past I have ordered whole pies and had their Greek salads which are very good.
Their pizza by the slice is plenty, so a grown man should be good with 2 – 3 slices. This place is not stingy either like some places, so if you need a cup for water, they’ll give you one free of charge. Their pizza sauce, mozzarella and toppings are very fresh here too.
I’d highly recommend this location.
[Review #342] (102^nd Review of 2015)

Never a bad experience when I come here. Its 1145am and they already have a crowd. The salad is wonderful and the pizza is tasty. My kids love it, so do I. Its on the best non chain commercial pizza joints in atlanta. Dare I say the pizza here is better than some places ive been to in nyc? Check em out, good customer service, good food.

Your friends and family will agree that this is some of the best pizza in Atlanta. Unless, of course, they still think Pizza Hut is the best. They have multiple locations and you can’t go wrong sampling slices at $ 3-​$ 5. It’s a dive but do not let that fool you into thinking the foods not excellent. Just drive by in the summer and you will see there is always a crowd on the weekend. I am a thin crust New York style pizza kind of guy and that exactly what you will find here. There is a decent beer selection and a patio which makes for a great spot to hang out with friends on summer days. They have been a staple of Atlanta since 1982 and there is a reason they are still around.

Good, solid pizza! Since my main chick broke up with me (600 Degrees by my house closed its doors), I had to find another spot for my pizza fix. I’m definitely a fan of the Fellini’s Special, hold the green olives please. It has a really good variety of flavor and is just enough to fill me up. Their hours of operation are great! Perfect if you want to make a late night food run and don’t want that garbage fast food.

The last time I came to Felini’s on Ponce, I said I would not go back. That was two years ago. An acquaintance talked me into going to the one on howell mill, I was in the mood for pizza so why not.
I got the vegetarian pizza with no mushrooms. Mind you, I only got one slice. I was pretty hungry but after seeing how big one slice is, I’m glad I didn’t get two.
I got a glass of Moscato as well.
The pizza came out in about 15 minutes and it was hot and fresh. The only think I would have preferred is if they cooked/​sauteed/​grilled the veggies they put on the pizza. Actually the veggies were like stuffed under a blanket of cheese. So when I bit into it veggies were everywhere. No biggie but just a preference. If someone comes to town and asks for pizza, I’ll consider Felini’s again. Not too expensive and defect pizza.

The parking situation here can be a bit scary at certain times. I must’ve come at the right moment because one was available. I’ve been here before when I’ve had to drive around 10X or attempt to park across the street.
The line wasn’t long (Tues night), I ordered a pepperoni slice. My usual is tomatoes and spinach but I was kinda in a rush and pepperoni is my «go to» for pizza. I also ordered a glass of white wine. It doesn’t come in a wine glass but I’m pretty sure it’s equivalent or more. It was filled to the brim. My slice of pizza was good even though the crust seemed a little thicker than normal.
I love wine. I love pizza. This isn’t my fav Fellinis location but they’re still very great and also open late. I’m a huge Fellini’s fan.

You’re either a Beatles person or an Elvis person — the same can be said between Fellini’s and Mellow Mushroom in Atlanta.
My big complaint is that Fellini’s pizzas are too thin. You get huge slices of pizza that quickly get soggy — a bigger problem if you’re taking it home. If you’re a knife and fork person, I guess this isn’t an issue. My favorite is the house special, where I’ve never had a problem with the crispness of the many vegetables toppings.
Their house salad, and especially it’s dressing, is awesome. The dressing makes an excellent dipping sauce for crusts.
The service is always good here. This location has a large Georgia Tech crowd which comes in weird waves — typical dinner hours might be dead and then everyone shows up around 10PM-​11PM. Parking can be a pain, not just because it’s limited but because the intersection where the restaurant is weird.

My husband and his family loves Fellini’s. The first, second, third, etc-​th time I’ve gone with them, I didn’t [and don’t] quite see what all the hub-​bub is about.
Decent customer service, large slices of relatively thin crust pizza that you can specialize with toppings, and salads which have white onions, thick shreds of mozzarella cheese (too much personally), black olives, green peppers, 2 – 3 slices of tomatoes, and iceberg lettuce.
It’s not bad, but it’s not great. However, $ 18 for three slices (total of 6 regular toppings… 2 on each slice), one house salad, and one fountain drink, that’s a little much don’t you think? I could have gone elsewhere for more and paid less.
If you want pizza and don’t want to go «high-​end» (CPK, Antico) and you’re not quite feeling like Pizza Hut, Papa John’s, Domino’s, or Sarpino’s, then yeah, Fellini’s is a good option. If you’re just hungry and want something kind cheap, you might be walking out with a higher tab than you anticipated.

Just left the food truck park and now want pizza. As much as I love pizza I had never been to fellinis. We ordered by the slice which Is $ 2.50 plus 50cents for extra toppings.
I had no idea that the CHEESEEEE per slice would be so plentiful!!! I had nerve to order two slices, the fellini special has 8 toppings and the poor crust could not hold all the heavy loads of melted CHEESEEE!!! The other slice was spinach/​mushroom, spinach was fresh but once again the CHEESEEEE took over the flavor!
We chewed and chewed each bite to make sure we could get the wad of CHEESEEEE down with out clogging our esophagus. So glad we ordered drinks to ease it all down.