Good Fellas Tavern

Never had a reason to go to Argyle before, but after eating at Good Fellas during a basketball tournament, Argyle has become a destination. We left full, happy, and impressed. Outstanding burgers, pizza, apps, and more.
Top notch and personal service even through the rush. All this and I didn’t need to take out a second mortgage.
Well done, Good Fellas. Well be back!

Nestled in the heart of cheese country lies a gem of a place! Good Fellas is that gem! Where else can you walk in & find bluegill sliders as the special of the day in this area?!! Cold beer, great mixed drinks and an outstanding grill, all at reasonable prices, add that to a great Badgers, Packers, NASCAR & Brewers (and even da Cubs) sports fan atmosphere & you have what makes a truly legendary Wisconsin Bar & Grill! Well worth the stop. A welcoming establishment awaits your visit, once you step inside you feel at home. A great American menu awaits you with fresh made items from the juiciest burgers to outstanding pizza & plenty of tasty daily specials! Grandma has a tough time beating their Sunday breakfast menu, the French toast is tough to beat! If you’re ever in the area you’d be crazy to miss a stop at Good Fellas! It is the heart & soul of what make a Wisconsin tavern great.

Apparently Good Fellas is the place to be on a Sunday night. There was a good crowd around dinner time, but still plenty of space for our party of 6 to sit and get some drinks and food. Our group was definitely the out of town visitors here, but we loved the small town bar atmosphere. People of all ages were present from early 20s to folks in the 60’s-70’s and they would say hi to each other as they came and went.
Food is typical bar food, but done well. The deep fried cheese curds, deep fried string beans, burgers, prime rib sandwich, and BLT are all very good. Our waitress/​bartender was friendly and she came by frequently to check up on us. Prices are great too! (Compared to city prices in NYC and Washington DC that we’re used to paying.)

And great Food!
My new favorite is their Turkey Wrap !!
And reasonable prices
friendly atmosphere

I’m a true foodie and love to eat all over the country! The hamburgers are some of the best I have ever had! The true stare is the freshness of the ground beef, simply fresh and full of flavor! If your traveling and looking for a place to eat it’s worth the trip… This is also the cleanest bat I have ever gone to! Thanks for a great meal!!! TATER TOTS… YES!