Earl of Whitchurch

I love that they have $ 5 beers most nights of the week. Some nights includes craft beer. They have the best beer selection in Stouffville. Friendly atmosphere. Waitresses are nice and quick. Food is very good made fresh. Open Mic on Sundays are great good people and good tunes

I came for a few drinks so I can’t comment on the food (which reviews below scared me off of). The bar staff was quick and attentive, and I couldn’t have asked for more. Everyone seemed super friendly and if this place wasn’t so far from downtown, I would come regularly for a drink because it was a nice relaxing place to enjoy a good pint.

The Earl has gone through several transitions, and many changes in chefs to boot. It’s never been a great place to eat, and you couldn’t really say it was good pub food, it’s not. The best I could say is the food is passible. However, the music jams are always a good time for everyone.

Found this place thanks to WagJag! Will be back. Service was friendly. Menu was limited and very «pub» style but the quality and taste more than made up. Had the check pea stew as an appetizer. Filling and delicious. The corn beef sandwich came on a soft roll and well seasoned. The french fries superb! A great pub atmosphere with surprisingly great pub food!!!

The menu at this pub blows away any other pub food I’ve ever had. Everything seems to be made with care and some things are home made. The soft pretzels are seriously mind blowing. The sticky pudding is home made and reminds me of Christmas. Everything we ate was on point. The people are friendly and the place was cozy.

Why is the menu here so small? Needs way more options.
I ordered the Bigelow burger and it was gross. SO SO SO salty. Like I couldn’t even eat it salty. Husband ordered the crispy chicken sandwich and liked it.
Prices are way too high for what you get.
We had a groupon so it wasn’t that bad, but I would not go back.
Disappointing.

Decided to give this place a try due to Groupon.
We presented the Groupon upon arrival and was told «don’t worry we will take it off your bill at the end». Server knew darn well that we were using Groupon but encouraged us to get daily special. Then at the end told us, we couldnt use the Groupon as we got the special. This ruined my dining experience as I felt like they tried to trick us.
Food is mediocre at best. French fries were hard, burgers were not bad and Philly cheese steak was so so.
Would not want to go back, gonna try to get refund for my Groupon

So I had to drop a star. Recent we have gone here a couple of times. I find it hit and miss! Which is too bad because we had high hopes for a better local pub. Our food last night was not up to standard. French fries were bottom of the basket ends and way to crispy. My chicken fingers were good but really how do you screw up those? My husband’s fish and chips were not hot, the batter fell off and again his fries were bottom of the basket. I also noticed that sides and dips now come in plastic throw away small containers, they used to come in small ceramic vessels. What’s going on over there? Things are sliding fast. And I didn’t not mention that my husband was served the wrong beer, the waitress took it back to the bar, waited and brought back the same one. The head had disappeared but it was obviously the same beer. We talked to one the other staff member who was tending bar, he has also been there the longest and is a great server, he was apologetic, took it back and didn’t charge us for our drinks which, wasn’t necessary but very nice. We ended up leaving shortly after we were finished, usually we linger. It is too bad that it is so hit and miss — hopefully the owners pull it together and get things back on track.

Went for lunch here, was expecting a great meal considering the waitress said everything was made fresh every morning and the fish and chips was one of their top sellers. So we went with the fish and chips ($ 18). The chips were great, the fish was a strange combo of soggy and partly crisp. Did not meet our expectations at all and I normally would not send anything back, but since I couldn’t eat it I had it replaced with an equally bad tasting and over buttered Reuben sandwich that came with a honey/​something dressing that was so thick it was more a dip than a dressing.
Had a good feel of a pub and it the staff was friendly. Probably won’t be going back anytime soon.
Update!!! The food we had here made me sick and it all came back up — Now I know for sure I won’t be back here. EVER!!!

here is an honest No B. S review. They have an Ok Atmosphere. Friendly staff. too many drunk white trash Hobo customers. Like literally my I. Q dropped a 100 points sitting at the bar just looking at these Neanderthals. So, if you want to have a nonsense argument and perhaps have a fist fight and end up in jail go visit this restaurant. bunch of Mooo Mooo farmers and drunk Idiots.

New owners have taken over and renovated — food is typical pub food however the they cook almost everything from scratch. The food is quite good — perhaps I was expecting more when I heard cooked from scratch. Had some chicken fingers rolled in what appeared to be Doritos and they were way overcooked. Also had a jerk chicken sandwich and it was solid.
The place is spotless, friendly staff, nice patio out back good draft selection.

I took my boyfriend here, just 10 min from my house, because we frequent pubs downtown and in Mississauga. He was surprised how no one was on the street that night, Friday 11pm Mid-​June, and the pub is located in downtown Stouffville. But yes, Stouffville is a quiet little place :)
Anyways, we sat at the patio, which is small and their patio lights were SOOO extremely bright. We each had a beer and shared a plate of Nachos. The nachos were good, but my memory of that evening was really just my boyfriend sitting in front of me :) Also there was a spider from a nearby flower pot…
Reviews from other sources recommend the Beef Dip. They also say that people visit here on game nights. I guess that’s what the TV on the patio is for. On our night, no major games, the pub inside was pretty empty and the patio was ⁷⁄₁₀ tables full.
All in all, a small pub, good for friends/​casual outings if you live nearby.